AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Audio theory, Setup and Chat › subwoofer size that goes with in-wall speakers?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

subwoofer size that goes with in-wall speakers?

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 
Just wondering if I should go with a 8 or 10 inches subwoofer.

I am trying to install KEF Ci160QS that are in-wall speakers. Not sure if 10 inches would cause too much base, or if 8 inches would suffice.

Thanks!
post #2 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by malnutrian View Post

Just wondering if I should go with a 8 or 10 inches subwoofer.

I am trying to install KEF Ci160QS that are in-wall speakers. Not sure if 10 inches would cause too much base, or if 8 inches would suffice.

Unfortunately the above question suggests a lot of misunderstandings about both speakers and subwoofers.

First off, congratulations on choosing an in-wall speaker that looks pretty nice on paper. I have long had a pair of Q15s, and appreciate the theoretical advantages of coaxial speakers.

The first problem with your question is the implied idea that you can tell how much bass a subwoofer generates based on the diameter of its driver and that larger diameter drivers necessarily generate more bass.

In fact a well-implemented subwoofer does what you want it to do within useful limits. You have several effective adjustments on your AVR for controlling it.

The idea that larger subwoofers necessarily generate more bass is wrong because how much bass the subwoofer generates is up to you. I suspect that your real fear is that your subwoofer will have boomy bass, and the answer to that fear is counter-intuitive: Generally, boomy bass is due to subwoofers that lack sufficient bass extension or deep bass capability.

The important parameter for subwoofer performance is bass extension, or how deep or low the deepest or lowest frequencies in the music or movie can go and still be effectively reproduced. That is not necessarily a function of the diameter of the woofer driver. It is very possible and even not uncommon for a 8 inch driver to put out more bass than a 10 inch driver.

You see the effectively of a subwoofer driver is dependent on how much air it can move in a well-controlled and accurate manner. All things being equal a larger woofer driver can move more air, but all other things are rarely equal. One can find 8 inch drivers with linear operation over distances ranging from nust a few mm to maybe a dozen or more mm. Thus an 8 inch driver with 12 mm linear travel and outperform a 10 inch driver with 3 mm linear travel.

Another serious issue is that the bass response of open back wall-mounted speakers like the one you seem to have chosen is very dependent on how it is installed.

So, your question can't really be answered well as it is currently written.
post #3 of 12
In general, it takes a 12-inch subwoofer to give sufficient clean undistorted bass in most rooms, and at least 300 watts of RMS subwoofer power. There are a few smaller subwoofer drivers that can move enough air, but not many.

Without knowing the dimensions of your room, however, there is no way to specifically answer the question.




Quote:
Originally Posted by malnutrian View Post

Just wondering if I should go with a 8 or 10 inches subwoofer.

I am trying to install KEF Ci160QS that are in-wall speakers. Not sure if 10 inches would cause too much base, or if 8 inches would suffice.

Thanks!
post #4 of 12
Thread Starter 
Thanks... hereby I try to supplement more details for your kind advice.

The room is 14 x 10 feet. I am trying to install three KEF Ci160CS as LCR speakers on one end (of the 14 inches wall), and two in-ceiling KEF as rear speakers on the other end above the sofa.

With that, any suggestion on the placement of the subwoofers, and what kinda specs would be needed??
post #5 of 12
Thread Starter 
Is this correct? With in wall speaker, I should go for better subwoofer than usu speaker to compensate for the inadequate bass?
post #6 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by malnutrian View Post

Thanks... hereby I try to supplement more details for your kind advice.

The room is 14 x 10 feet. I am trying to install three KEF Ci160CS as LCR speakers on one end (of the 14 inches wall), and two in-ceiling KEF as rear speakers on the other end above the sofa.

With that, any suggestion on the placement of the subwoofers, and what kinda specs would be needed??

Ceiling height?
post #7 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by malnutrian View Post

Is this correct? With in wall speaker, I should go for better subwoofer than usu speaker to compensate for the inadequate bass?

It is not written in the laws of physics that an in-wall speaker has to have inadequate bass. The bass you get out of a speaker has a lot to do with how you enclose it as compared to its own internal dynamics.

Do the speakers you chose have their own enclosures?

I suspect that an in-wall speaker on a wall composed of single thin sheets of drywall have a lot of bass loses and exposures to rattles in the wall.
post #8 of 12
Thread Starter 
It's 9 ft high. And the speakers are placed within an artificial wall that's 9 inches from the real wall behind. They r not enclosed themselves.
post #9 of 12
The beauty part of subwoofers is they all fit. Big, little expensive , and cheap. Thats all they do is fill in the bottom octaves. With in walls and their inability to play bass at all, your sub may have to be placed upfront and XO kinda highish, due to the inwalls inability to do so. It will be placed upfront so you dont notice it reproducing higher frequencies as you would if it was to the side and you heard voices coming from it.

Whats your budget. Or did i miss that part....
post #10 of 12
Thread Starter 
I am thinking KEF HTB2SE, or Scandyna Ball, largely for aesthetic reason. Again I am using KEF Ci160QS as my LCR speakers.

Which would be better subwoofer?
post #11 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by malnutrian View Post

I am thinking KEF HTB2SE, or Scandyna Ball, largely for aesthetic reason. Again I am using KEF Ci160QS as my LCR speakers.

Which would be better subwoofer?

The Ball appears to be a joke, as serious A/V subwoofers go.

The KEF model you mention appears to be pretty lightweight and limited.

If these were the only alternatives, the wall-mounted speakers would appear to have the greater potential for bass.
post #12 of 12
Thread Starter 
Yeah they aren't really powerful but prolly would be ok for now. Thx. I will likely go for the kef sub to pair my kef in walls
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Audio theory, Setup and Chat
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Audio theory, Setup and Chat › subwoofer size that goes with in-wall speakers?