Please bear with me on this one as I am still pretty low on the learning curve. I was heavy into hi-fi in the 70s and 80s, but there is a great deal about digital that I just don't get. This will be a long post because I just don't know enough to write a short one. The question I am asking here is just one of several inter-related questions I have about an evolving system, and I am not sure just what is and is not relevant to the question. Alas, there does not seem to be a right place to post this question.
My wife owns a 30's era log cabin on a cliff. A few years ago, the cliff began acting like it did not want to be a cliff anymore. Rather than risk waking up in the Chesapeake one morning, we decided to have the cabin moved back from the cliff.
The upside of a fairly expensive move is that for the first time we have a dedicated home theater room in the basement. The plan was to use it pretty much exclusively for Blu-Rays and streaming videos from NetFlix or Comcast On Demand. Previously, we had a 5.1 system in the living room, but the components were sort of hit-or-miss and the speaker placements were uniformly "miss."
Old System
Panasonic 50" Plasma (1080p)
Yamaha RX-V661 Receiver (HDMI 1.3)
Samsung Blu-Ray (not top of the line)
Fronts - Polk Monitor 50s
Center - Polk CS3
Rears - Polk R-15s (akin to the current T-15s)
Sub - Advent 12"
The new room is about 16x17. Part of the ceiling is about 8' and the rest is about 9'. I decided to go from 5.1 to 7.1 and put Polk VM20s in the front and center slots and pushed the remaining speakers to the sides and rears and replaced the Advent with a Polk MicroPro 3000. As this was a new room, I was able to decide on speaker placement before anything else. A sofa close to the center of the room is the main viewing location. I bought some Blu-Rays from the 'reference sound' list in an AVS forum.
And thus my troubles began! From the instant I hooked everything up and ran the YPAO setup program, the system sounded a thousand times better than either the prior upstairs system or the somewhat better main house system had even sounded before. Paradoxically, because the system sounded so good, I felt an overwhelming need to spend money make it sound even better.
Which leads me to the:
New System
Panasonic 50" Plasma (1080p)
Yamaha RX-V661 Receiver (HDMI 1.3)
Samsung Blu-Ray (not top of the line)
Fronts - Polk VM30s
Center - Polk VM20
Sides - Polk VM20s
Rears - Polk VM20s
Sub - SVS PC12 Plus
Front&Center Amp - Emotiva XPA-3.
Roku2 XS
The MicroPro 3000 spent very little time in my system!
The system sounded great before the latest upgrades. I am not sure just how much better it is now because I had to ship one of the VM20s back to Polk to fix a crossover, and thus cannot rerun YPAO with the new gear. I do know it looks and sounds better than I thought a moderately priced home system could sound. I expect to have the prodigal speaker back in time to install it and run at least preliminary YPAO set-up this coming weekend.
So, what is my problem?
Well, first of all, the combination of a Rives Audio test CD and what I think is a Radio Shack SPL meter tells me that what sounds great to my ear actually has frequency responses that are scattered all over the sonic map. The results are so bad that I think there must be something wrong with either my test equipment or my testing procedure. Among other things, I apparently have no output at all from 10Khz on up. As I am pushing 60, I am not going to hear much in that range in any case, but the meter tells me the sound simply is not there.
I think I need to play with this some more before I can ask the right questions about this.
My second problem is what brings me here. Although this started out as a home theater system pretty much exclusively, I have now decided that I would like to be able to listen to CDs as well. I do not have many CDs at the cabin, but the few that I have popped into the Samsung BD player so far have not sounded very musical at all. Music sounds great on the soundtrack of BD reference discs, but merely so-so with ordinary CDs. I do not think the difference in dynamic range between the two formats can account for that much of the difference.
So, where should I go from here? I don't want to shell out a grand or so for a high quality CD player - especially if the problem is elsewhere in the system! I have an old Rega Planet laying around that was a very good player in its day, but it has been close to ten years since I have used it, so I am not confident it can answer my question either.
What should I do to get the best music out of my system without giving up the home theater that I am already very happy with? Should I be listening in Pure Direct, 2 Channel, or something else? My sub seems to be pretty much MIA with CDs, and that could be a setting issue, I think.
I also wonder if the Oppo BDP-93 warrants consideration. I am not unhappy with my simple Samsung BD as far as it goes, but it is clear that the Oppo goes a lot farther. However, I do not own any SACDs or DVD-As, so some of those improvements will be lost on me. Will the Oppo give me better sound from my CDs? Will it give me noticeable improvement as a BD player?
Sorry this is so long. All advice, long or short, will be appreciated.
My wife owns a 30's era log cabin on a cliff. A few years ago, the cliff began acting like it did not want to be a cliff anymore. Rather than risk waking up in the Chesapeake one morning, we decided to have the cabin moved back from the cliff.
The upside of a fairly expensive move is that for the first time we have a dedicated home theater room in the basement. The plan was to use it pretty much exclusively for Blu-Rays and streaming videos from NetFlix or Comcast On Demand. Previously, we had a 5.1 system in the living room, but the components were sort of hit-or-miss and the speaker placements were uniformly "miss."
Old System
Panasonic 50" Plasma (1080p)
Yamaha RX-V661 Receiver (HDMI 1.3)
Samsung Blu-Ray (not top of the line)
Fronts - Polk Monitor 50s
Center - Polk CS3
Rears - Polk R-15s (akin to the current T-15s)
Sub - Advent 12"
The new room is about 16x17. Part of the ceiling is about 8' and the rest is about 9'. I decided to go from 5.1 to 7.1 and put Polk VM20s in the front and center slots and pushed the remaining speakers to the sides and rears and replaced the Advent with a Polk MicroPro 3000. As this was a new room, I was able to decide on speaker placement before anything else. A sofa close to the center of the room is the main viewing location. I bought some Blu-Rays from the 'reference sound' list in an AVS forum.
And thus my troubles began! From the instant I hooked everything up and ran the YPAO setup program, the system sounded a thousand times better than either the prior upstairs system or the somewhat better main house system had even sounded before. Paradoxically, because the system sounded so good, I felt an overwhelming need to spend money make it sound even better.
Which leads me to the:
New System
Panasonic 50" Plasma (1080p)
Yamaha RX-V661 Receiver (HDMI 1.3)
Samsung Blu-Ray (not top of the line)
Fronts - Polk VM30s
Center - Polk VM20
Sides - Polk VM20s
Rears - Polk VM20s
Sub - SVS PC12 Plus
Front&Center Amp - Emotiva XPA-3.
Roku2 XS
The MicroPro 3000 spent very little time in my system!
The system sounded great before the latest upgrades. I am not sure just how much better it is now because I had to ship one of the VM20s back to Polk to fix a crossover, and thus cannot rerun YPAO with the new gear. I do know it looks and sounds better than I thought a moderately priced home system could sound. I expect to have the prodigal speaker back in time to install it and run at least preliminary YPAO set-up this coming weekend.
So, what is my problem?
Well, first of all, the combination of a Rives Audio test CD and what I think is a Radio Shack SPL meter tells me that what sounds great to my ear actually has frequency responses that are scattered all over the sonic map. The results are so bad that I think there must be something wrong with either my test equipment or my testing procedure. Among other things, I apparently have no output at all from 10Khz on up. As I am pushing 60, I am not going to hear much in that range in any case, but the meter tells me the sound simply is not there.
I think I need to play with this some more before I can ask the right questions about this.
My second problem is what brings me here. Although this started out as a home theater system pretty much exclusively, I have now decided that I would like to be able to listen to CDs as well. I do not have many CDs at the cabin, but the few that I have popped into the Samsung BD player so far have not sounded very musical at all. Music sounds great on the soundtrack of BD reference discs, but merely so-so with ordinary CDs. I do not think the difference in dynamic range between the two formats can account for that much of the difference.
So, where should I go from here? I don't want to shell out a grand or so for a high quality CD player - especially if the problem is elsewhere in the system! I have an old Rega Planet laying around that was a very good player in its day, but it has been close to ten years since I have used it, so I am not confident it can answer my question either.
What should I do to get the best music out of my system without giving up the home theater that I am already very happy with? Should I be listening in Pure Direct, 2 Channel, or something else? My sub seems to be pretty much MIA with CDs, and that could be a setting issue, I think.
I also wonder if the Oppo BDP-93 warrants consideration. I am not unhappy with my simple Samsung BD as far as it goes, but it is clear that the Oppo goes a lot farther. However, I do not own any SACDs or DVD-As, so some of those improvements will be lost on me. Will the Oppo give me better sound from my CDs? Will it give me noticeable improvement as a BD player?
Sorry this is so long. All advice, long or short, will be appreciated.









)
, but it just did not sound all that "live." It sounds more like a decent quality table radio than what should be expected from relatively full range speakers with 200 wpc amplification; especially when they are backed up by a truly fine subwoofer like the SVS.



