AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Receivers, Amps, and Processors › Onkyo TX-NR818 "official" owner's thread discussion
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Onkyo TX-NR818 "official" owner's thread discussion - Page 142

post #4231 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by william06 View Post

Al though I have not noticed the issue, I understand that does not mean it is not there . If it is a case that it is a hardware issue, then since the 0007 series every year there has been some sort of issue with the Onkyo receivers. Both hard or software.At least they offered a firmware to correct the issue if software if hardware they issued an ra to fix or at least made sure it was taken care of. This seems to be another one of those issues. If software they should offer a firmware, if hardware they should definitely offer free fix or replacement or a different unit of at least equal value. If they choose to ignore the issue and put owners through a dog and pony show as they presently are doing, then anyone thinking about purchasing one of these or another Onkyo should definitely wait to see the outcome. If people are noticing the issue on a recently purchased unit and still in the return window, I would seriously consider taking advantage of they're dealers return window.

+1

I'm returning mine tomorrow.
post #4232 of 7323
I'm looking to replace my old 12-year old Onkyo receiver that has continued to work well up to this day - I do like Onkyo products. I would like to have another Onkyo and have been eyeing the TX-NR818 model (great features for the price), however, the issues related to 24P bug, the drop outs when streaming high resolution music files, some networking issues has made me pause.

Is there a way I can let Onkyo know that they'll be missing out on sale due to their head in the sand approach in dealing with defective equipment? Maybe AVS forum is not the right place, but surely there must be another forum that Onkyo management does monitor and will take note.

Perhaps if there are enough of current and future Onkyo owners who can state the facts about the problems, then make it known to the rest of the world about Onkyo issues, Onkyo management wont be able to hide or say these are minor - that only the fringe (the minority or what ever one would refer to) at AVS forums are experiencing. It's not that I want to belittle Onkyo, it's to help management understand what the problems are, address them and help make a better product that people would like to purchase and continue to purchase with confidence.

Steve
post #4233 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by cytoSiN View Post

Everyone who is complaining here but who has not yet complained in the Onkyo thread, get on it! http://forums.onkyousa.com/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=138

Quote:
Originally Posted by steveting99 View Post

I'm looking to replace my old 12-year old Onkyo receiver that has continued to work well up to this day - I do like Onkyo products. I would like to have another Onkyo and have been eyeing the TX-NR818 model (great features for the price), however, the issues related to 24P bug, the drop outs when streaming high resolution music files, some networking issues has made me pause.

Is there a way I can let Onkyo know that they'll be missing out on sale due to their head in the sand approach in dealing with defective equipment? Maybe AVS forum is not the right place, but surely there must be another forum that Onkyo management does monitor and will take note.

Perhaps if there are enough of current and future Onkyo owners who can state the facts about the problems, then make it known to the rest of the world about Onkyo issues, Onkyo management wont be able to hide or say these are minor - that only the fringe (the minority or what ever one would refer to) at AVS forums are experiencing. It's not that I want to belittle Onkyo, it's to help management understand what the problems are, address them and help make a better product that people would like to purchase and continue to purchase with confidence.

Steve

If you feel your words will make any difference, the link is above, feel free to try, the more the better, but this was reported back in mid to late July or early August, and still no FW fix...

Most answers would fall into to categories:

1) You either like this receiver for it's over all features for it's price point, mostly because of Audyssey MultEQ XT32 and Your willing to overlook this 24P issue, and play the waiting game for Onkyo to release a FW fix.

OR:

2) If your on the fence, and question how this will go, several posts ( back a few pages ) have warned caution of this receiver, until a fix is confirmed and posted in this thread, and just like me, I returned my 818 on not taking any chances with playing the waiting game, in the end, some of the flaws don't bother some, but to the other percentage of owners here, they are making the issue very well known, to also help with getting a fix..
Edited by TheaterChad - 1/13/13 at 9:24pm
post #4234 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by FlatRocky View Post

If you have ipad or iphone, try Oremote app, best $4.99 that i spent on an app for this receiver. Most of the settings are one touch shortcuts on Oremote. I use it 95% of the time. For me, it also controls my cec hdmi conected oppo dvd player.

I wonder how iRule and the gang do a lot of those settings. A lot of them are buried in the GUI "Quick Setup" and have no discrete controls. I did find the IP controls to handle those, but they are undocumented and a pain to deal with. The undocumented command set is even larger than the documented set - it lets you get into nearly everything the receiver can do. On the 818 I can do interesting things like pull the temp, firmware revision for each chip, and even do a full system reset.

I have about a dozen or so commands that are as of yet a total mystery. My holy grail would be to find one that would switch regions from US to EU or JP - since at least the US and EU versions seem to use the same firmware. JP models might be a bit too much to ask for.
post #4235 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by rworne View Post

I wonder how iRule and the gang do a lot of those settings. A lot of them are buried in the GUI "Quick Setup" and have no discrete controls. I did find the IP controls to handle those, but they are undocumented and a pain to deal with. The undocumented command set is even larger than the documented set - it lets you get into nearly everything the receiver can do. On the 818 I can do interesting things like pull the temp, firmware revision for each chip, and even do a full system reset.

I have about a dozen or so commands that are as of yet a total mystery. My holy grail would be to find one that would switch regions from US to EU or JP - since at least the US and EU versions seem to use the same firmware. JP models might be a bit too much to ask for.

Where do you find the undocumented commands? I checked the "documented one" and the one to completely turn off VFD is "N/A", but given if you are in pure Audio mode, the VFD can be turned OFF completely, I think there is likely a way. Does this exist in the undocumented world?
post #4236 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by rworne View Post

I have about a dozen or so commands that are as of yet a total mystery. My holy grail would be to find one that would switch regions from US to EU or JP - since at least the US and EU versions seem to use the same firmware. JP models might be a bit too much to ask for.
Any chance that you've discovered a way to send custom CEC commands? My Samsung LCD ignores documented commands to control TV set.
post #4237 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by MadMyers View Post

If your contact at Onkyo knows about it, he should tell Onkyo's support people about it... wink.gif

Has anyone been able to determine if other models are affected? 809, etc.

As a previous poster mentioned, it works fine off the HDMI sub-out. As far as we know, the only difference is that the sub-out doesnt display the OSD. Would logic then say its whatever chip is handling adding the OSD to the video stream? Probably not the HQV or Marvell chips.

On top of that someone mentioned an Arcam receiver that has the same issue, and they confirmed its a hardware thing along with that its a Broadcom-based unit. 2+2....is there a Broadcom chip in the Onkyo unit providing OSD to the video stream?
post #4238 of 7323
Quick question on speakers for the 818. I'm currently breaking in a set of Energy RC-70s. Nice sound so far. I've researched and reviewed a lot about the Martin Logan Electrostat ESLs. There's quite a difference in price. Is it worth it. I love the 818 and want good quality, crisp, clean sound. In order to show off what the reciever can do, there needs to be some descent speakers! Any thoughts or suggestions? Is it worth the upgrade? They are double in price.
post #4239 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrisexv6 View Post

Has anyone been able to determine if other models are affected? 809, etc.

Here's a link to a European forum that found it in 609 and 809's back in January.

Start at post 73.

http://www.avforums.com/forums/av-amplifiers-receivers/1574646-onkyo-tx-nr609-owners-thread-part-2-a-3.html
post #4240 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by Patrick Murphy View Post

Here's a link to a European forum that found it in 609 and 809's back in January.

Start at post 73.

http://www.avforums.com/forums/av-amplifiers-receivers/1574646-onkyo-tx-nr609-owners-thread-part-2-a-3.html

Onkyo released a firmware back in 2011 that mentioned something about 24p sources.....since I havent seen any recent complaints about 24p on an 809, but the 818 has pages of them, I wasnt sure if that firmware actually fixed the 809 or not.
post #4241 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by fight4yu View Post

Where do you find the undocumented commands? I checked the "documented one" and the one to completely turn off VFD is "N/A", but given if you are in pure Audio mode, the VFD can be turned OFF completely, I think there is likely a way. Does this exist in the undocumented world?

Brute-force scanning codes for days and weeks. Only some models support DIM commands to turn off everything. To do that, I think you just need to select the "Direct" mode.
post #4242 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dums View Post

Any chance that you've discovered a way to send custom CEC commands? My Samsung LCD ignores documented commands to control TV set.

Nothing yet. I did find the Audyssey Pro calibration stuff, and verified once and for all the 818 does not have them. I need to get a pro compatible receiver to further my studies.
post #4243 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrisexv6 View Post

Has anyone been able to determine if other models are affected? 809, etc.

I've traced it back at least as far as the 807 (Faroudja chipset), so we can safely remove the HQV as being the problem.
post #4244 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by fahrenheit View Post

I've traced it back at least as far as the 807 (Faroudja chipset), so we can safely remove the HQV as being the problem.

The fact it doesnt happen on the HDMI sub-out makes me think its whatever chip/processing is adding the OSD thats the issue. Unless there are some other differences between HDMI main and sub-out that we dont know about (or it really doesnt work on the sub-out either)
post #4245 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheaterChad View Post


If you feel your words will make any difference, the link is above, feel free to try, the more the better, but this was reported back in mid to late July or early August, and still no FW fix...

I understand the frustration with the issue, but there have also been no firmware updates since that time either. The latest for the 818 was in the fall.

I have two stupidly simple bugs they could fix but they remain, though only one update came out shortly after I reported them.

Chances are they are working on something, hence the long delay. The receiver certainly isn't bug-free (like I should throw stones) but they have some minor work left to do on their network protocol.
post #4246 of 7323
A few things here from a first time user:

It appears Onkyo could have made the firmware update notifications a little more obvious. I did spend quite a bit of time trying to update last night, when it appears it had already been done for me in the background. Many users have commented on this so far as they did not know they had already updated. A simple "your firmware is up to date" notification perhaps?

I setup my receiver for the first time last night. I only have one issue so far. When trying to calibrate through Audyssey, my remote wouldn't work and I had to use the button on the front panel on the receiver to progress. This also occured when trying to switch sound modes (games,movie, THX) from the remote, simply would not work. I downloaded the app and the remote app worked fine.
Not sure if there is something wrong with my remote or I need to select something on it to allow these functions to work..

Also Audyssey said that my sub was 9 metres away which is about a three fold over estimation. Will this be an issue? Should I manually change it to 3/4 metres which is the actual distance?

What are the supreme listening modes for music/movies/games?

thanks folks!
post #4247 of 7323
Response from email from Onkyo after I sent hem my set up info.


Hello Craig,

We have received your information and we are in process of researching . We will contact you as soon we have a response.

Patrick Fider
Social Media/Product Support Specialist
ONKYO USA
18 Park Way
Upper Saddle River, NJ 07458
(201) 785-2659


From: Craig [mailto:amacron7@gmail.com]
Sent: Saturday, January 12, 2013 9:21 PM
To: CustSrvc askOnkyo
Subject: 24p bug


I also have the 24p bug.


My set up :

Panasonic TC-P65gt50
Onkyo TX-NR818
Panasonic DMP-BDT220
post #4248 of 7323
If you take a look at the Onkyo support forums one of the replies made it look like they physically want to verify every device in the stream.

I think it comes off as their attempt to start finger pointing and/or skirting around the issue.

Hopefully thats not the case.
post #4249 of 7323
How many people have actually seen the effects of the 24p bug?
post #4250 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by Adam James View Post

How many people have actually seen the effects of the 24p bug?

Enough to confirm its existence.
post #4251 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by freshdecay View Post

A few things here from a first time user:

It appears Onkyo could have made the firmware update notifications a little more obvious. I did spend quite a bit of time trying to update last night, when it appears it had already been done for me in the background. Many users have commented on this so far as they did not know they had already updated. A simple "your firmware is up to date" notification perhaps?

I setup my receiver for the first time last night. I only have one issue so far. When trying to calibrate through Audyssey, my remote wouldn't work and I had to use the button on the front panel on the receiver to progress. This also occured when trying to switch sound modes (games,movie, THX) from the remote, simply would not work. I downloaded the app and the remote app worked fine.
Not sure if there is something wrong with my remote or I need to select something on it to allow these functions to work..

Also Audyssey said that my sub was 9 metres away which is about a three fold over estimation. Will this be an issue? Should I manually change it to 3/4 metres which is the actual distance?

What are the supreme listening modes for music/movies/games?

thanks folks![/quote

Don't forget to press RECEIVER (as a source on the remote) when using your remote to control receiver functions. ..
Don't change the sub distance. Your sub has probably a DSP which delays the signal.
Distance in Audyssey is actually "time" (messured in the time domain).

When whatching Blu-ray then I'm using straight decode Dolby Digital/DST bitstream. Don't forget to set your BD player to bitstream also.
If you have a 7.1 (or larger) system the you should try Audyssey DXS or NEO X modes.
I'm using DD TV Logic when watching TV, and DD Music or Stereo (2.1) for music.
Is all down to your own preferences:)))
post #4252 of 7323
Freshdecay

Don't forget to press RECEIVER (as a source on the remote) when using your remote to control receiver functions. ..
Don't change the sub distance. Your sub has probably a DSP which delays the signal.
Distance in Audyssey is actually "time" (messured in the time domain).

When whatching Blu-ray then I'm using straight decode Dolby Digital/DST bitstream. Don't forget to set your BD player to bitstream also.
If you have a 7.1 (or larger) system the you should try Audyssey DXS or NEO X modes.
I'm using DD TV Logic when watching TV, and DD Music or Stereo (2.1) for music.
Is all down to your own preferences:)))
post #4253 of 7323
Hello Ryan,

We have received your information. Due to not being able to duplicate the problem in our lab, is it possible that we set up a Skype Video Call with our technician to see what's happening to your setup. If possible please let us know when you are available.

Patrick Fider
Social Media/Product Support Specialist
ONKYO USA


Awesome. I thought they found the issues??
post #4254 of 7323
The same guy, Patrick Fider, e-mailed me as well and asked if a technician could come to my house to investigate. I'm moving this month so it will have to wait a little while, but I'm happy to take them up on it. That said, I did ask him if they put an Edge in the chain and measured the output. I refuse to believe that they can't reproduce the issue in house when it's really as simple as taking a measurement with equipment they must have handy...
post #4255 of 7323
I gave up and shipped my 818 back.

It was a cludge to put two video processors in series. Oppo does everything with the QDEO only.
It is too bad the CE AVR's has become a race to see how many logos you can paste onto the box.

I hope Onkyo comes through for those that are bothered by the 24P issue.

I ordered a Yamaha RX-A820. I never owned any of their products.

- Rich
post #4256 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by AVRams View Post

Freshdecay

Don't forget to press RECEIVER (as a source on the remote) when using your remote to control receiver functions. ..
Don't change the sub distance. Your sub has probably a DSP which delays the signal.
Distance in Audyssey is actually "time" (messured in the time domain).

When whatching Blu-ray then I'm using straight decode Dolby Digital/DST bitstream. Don't forget to set your BD player to bitstream also.
If you have a 7.1 (or larger) system the you should try Audyssey DXS or NEO X modes.
I'm using DD TV Logic when watching TV, and DD Music or Stereo (2.1) for music.
Is all down to your own preferences:)))

Thanks mate. Ended up working that out with the remotre control/recevier button. smile.gif

Encountered a lip syncing issue last night from the ps3 but resolved that with 220ms delay.
Hopefully that doesn't mess the sync up with all inputted devices.

Is there a way I can play my xbox, with the sound from network/USB also playing? i.e Play two devices at once?
post #4257 of 7323
For those that would like to see what the 24p bug looks like, I've attached an example video of the problem. I took a 23.976 fps test file (posted earlier in this thread) and ran it through my professional video editing system and output at 24.00 fps. As expected every 1000 or 1001 frames (approx 41 seconds) there is a frame repeat. It is very subtle, which is why I believe some don't notice it, but it it certainly not how the 818 output should be. The attached video is an excerpt of a longer test video and clearly has its frame labeled 1000 repeat twice, just like it would show on the 818 main output. You'll see a very fast stop and go effect.

skip_example.zip 393k .zip file
post #4258 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by EHUFF View Post

For those that would like to see what the 24p bug looks like, I've attached an example video of the problem. I took a 23.976 fps test file (posted earlier in this thread) and ran it through my professional video editing system and output at 24.00 fps. As expected every 1000 or 1001 frames (approx 41 seconds) there is a frame repeat. It is very subtle, which is why I believe some don't notice it, but it it certainly not how the 818 output should be. The attached video is an excerpt of a longer test video and clearly has its frame labeled 1000 repeat twice, just like it would show on the 818 main output. You'll see a very fast stop and go effect.

skip_example.zip 393k .zip file

Any chance I could get both source videos from you?
post #4259 of 7323
The source for the test files was posted earlier in this thread and the link can be found here:

http://www.avsforum.com/t/1367468/himedia-hd900b-full-3d-media-streamer-realtek-1186-based/1140#post_21685294
post #4260 of 7323
Quote:
Originally Posted by EHUFF View Post

For those that would like to see what the 24p bug looks like, I've attached an example video of the problem. I took a 23.976 fps test file (posted earlier in this thread) and ran it through my professional video editing system and output at 24.00 fps. As expected every 1000 or 1001 frames (approx 41 seconds) there is a frame repeat. It is very subtle, which is why I believe some don't notice it, but it it certainly not how the 818 output should be. The attached video is an excerpt of a longer test video and clearly has its frame labeled 1000 repeat twice, just like it would show on the 818 main output. You'll see a very fast stop and go effect.

skip_example.zip 393k .zip file

Verified. For those wanting to do the same, the easiest way (assuming you don't see it) is to use a video player that supports frame stepping (e.g. MPC-HC) and advance through them.

Thanks for doing this.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Receivers, Amps, and Processors
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Receivers, Amps, and Processors › Onkyo TX-NR818 "official" owner's thread discussion