New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Surge Protectors

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
I am wondering the difference between some features I saw on some different surge protectors. I see monster has different stages of clean power; clean power, HD clean power, Stage 1, Stage 2, etc. There there are some other brands which talk about the same idea but refer to a db rating. 80 db etc. Which is better and why? I have no clue what the difference is and I want to be educated.
post #2 of 6
What do you hope to accomplish?
post #3 of 6
Thread Starter 
Well if 80db is just as good as stage 2 then that makes a difference. I'm really just more curious how to compare the two ideas of db and stages
post #4 of 6
I will repeat my question. What do you hope to accomplish? Surge protection? Noise reduction? They are two different things.

FWIW when you see things like "80 dB" they are probably talking about noise reduction. The question you need to answer for yourself is "Do I need powerline noise reduction?" I and many others here don't think we need it. The power supplies in most electronic gear are very good at making sure that power line noise does not significantly affect the proper operation of the gear.

Monster's "stages" are IMHO a little more than a way of confusing consumers. There is no industry standard for what capability is in what stage, so it is impossible to compare between manufacturers unless you look at what is actually included.

As far as surge protection goes, the primary things that are relevant are the UL 1449 3rd Ed. Voltage Protection Rating (VPR) and the maximum surge current the device will handle. The lower the VPR, the better. Just keep in mind that just about all electronic devices are inherently immune to surges up to at least 600V. And if you are considering a point-of-use surge protective device, the maximum surge current rating isn't an issue for name brand devices, except as a measure of potential life time, because the worse case expected surge is only about 90J.

I guess I should mention that the need for surge protection is highly over-hyped, filtering even more so.

And BTW having surge protection on your AC lines is not necessarily sufficient to prevent damage from surges. All conductive paths into your gear, like cable, antenna, LAN, phone line, etc. also need to be appropriately protected.
post #5 of 6
Thread Starter 
My largest concern is getting my best picture quality so I don't want to be at risk with interference. Thank you for your knowledge
post #6 of 6
OK, so what you are really interested in is not surge protection but power conditioning, which covers things like filtering and voltage regulation. As I said previously, the power supplies in your gear are quite good at rejecting noise on the AC line that might affect your audio/video experience. They are also designed to operate properly on a range of input voltages. So, unless you experience extreme voltage swings, like one might find in a third world country, IMHO you probably don't need anything.

Is there something about your current video experience that makes you think that it is less than optimal?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home