AVS › AVS Forum › Gaming & Content Streaming › Networking, Media Servers & Content Streaming › Dilemma: Blu-ray, NAS or HTPC
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Dilemma: Blu-ray, NAS or HTPC

post #1 of 3
Thread Starter 
Howdy folks,

I've been a long time reader here on AVS, and it has certainly be helpful; now I have a dilemma though, and thought asking the most experienced people in the world what I should do. We recently renovated our living room and I purchased both a Panasonic TX-L47DT50 and a Bose CineMate 1 SR. Until now, I had various blu-rays laying around, and numerous movies stored on my NAS (an old 1 slot Synology diskstation) in various qualities ranging from HDTV copies (made myself.) and copies of blurays in 720p and 1080p. (The 1080p ones taking up a lot of space at about 15GB/movie) The copies on the NAS were served via DLNA and the actual discs went in my PS3.

I decided I wanted to have uniformity and invest in either blu-ray discs of all movies I want OR a new NAS with more storage and the power to serve 1080p without hiccups OR a HTPC to do the same. Since the new television is of high quality, I wouldn't want any less than 1080p. So my question is; what would be the best way of doing things whilst keeping the cost as low as possible?

I can buy my blu-rays off Zavvi, which'll make them cheaper than buying them here in Belgium but it would still be 10€/disc at minimum and I'd have to see where I can store the boxes. - Buying a new Synology disc station with a little bit of processing power will quickly run me 400€ and more, but it is energy efficient and does not take up a lot of space. Last but not least, a HTPC is generally bigger, more power consuming and at least as expensive as the NAS. (+ I'd have to educate myself in all the HTPC stuff, but that should be easy enough by just reading on this forum.)

Thanks already for reading and answering, I really appreciate it! P.S: If I posted in the wrong board, I'm sorry, I didn't see a better suiting one. <3
post #2 of 3
I understand that you want to keep cost down, but as you've mentioned before BD rips take a lot of space. BD rips' size will depend on the type of movie. In my collections BD rips size are between 15 GB to 35 GB, and this is a main movie only ripped to M2TS format.

The part that is going to cost you more money won't be the disk. It will be the hard drives. I've got 10TB of storage, and got approximately about 3.5 TB left. I've got over 300 BD movies, and a large amount of DVD and TV Shows as well. I ended up building an UnRaid server with old parts I had laying around. It was cheap to built, but I had to buy more drives. I only had two 2TB hard drives. I ended up buying 4 more 2TB hard drive at $100 dollars each, which set me back $400 over time. It cost me about $150 to build my UnRaid server. So, I've spend a total of $550 dollars, but my UnRaid server streams movies to all my media players at the same time, and I don't have any issues with it.

If I had the money, I would of gone with Synology, but they are expensive. I would of had to spend over $2000 dollars with Synology.

Building your own NAS / Server will be cheaper. You can also built a HTPC with XBMC, but in my opinion that will require more work.
post #3 of 3
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by GusGus748s View Post

I understand that you want to keep cost down, but as you've mentioned before BD rips take a lot of space. BD rips' size will depend on the type of movie. In my collections BD rips size are between 15 GB to 35 GB, and this is a main movie only ripped to M2TS format.
The part that is going to cost you more money won't be the disk. It will be the hard drives. I've got 10TB of storage, and got approximately about 3.5 TB left. I've got over 300 BD movies, and a large amount of DVD and TV Shows as well. I ended up building an UnRaid server with old parts I had laying around. It was cheap to built, but I had to buy more drives. I only had two 2TB hard drives. I ended up buying 4 more 2TB hard drive at $100 dollars each, which set me back $400 over time. It cost me about $150 to build my UnRaid server. So, I've spend a total of $550 dollars, but my UnRaid server streams movies to all my media players at the same time, and I don't have any issues with it.
If I had the money, I would of gone with Synology, but they are expensive. I would of had to spend over $2000 dollars with Synology.
Building your own NAS / Server will be cheaper. You can also built a HTPC with XBMC, but in my opinion that will require more work.
Thank you for your answer! Currently my BD rips are in .mkv format with DTS audio and Dutch subtitles left in. I don't think I'll quickly have 100+ movies regardless of what method I end up using, but the storage will indeed cost a lot. If I was to go with a NAS, I would go with Synology though, if only because I had such a great experience with it. I could get a two-slot NAS with 2x4TB drives which would last me long enough. (I hope.) Looking at the prices here in Belgium, that would be 400€ for the NAS itself and another 400€ for the hard drives. 800€ is a lot to spend, but if it would be sufficient for the next couple years, I guess it would be worth it. A HTPC sounds nice, but is perhaps a tad overkill for my needs.

So I'm really left with either buying and keeping all blu-rays and find a way to store them without the misses killing me OR investing heavily in a NAS, with a DIY one being a cheaper option over Synology. Buying and keeping the blu-rays gives me the issue that I'll have to wait a couple months till it is available at Zavvi or in Belgium though. The NAS has the advantage that I don't have to run down and get the disc if I want to watch a movie upstairs but it is a lot more work. I'll also have to look into what formats / containers to use, as not everything is as .mkv friendly as I would wish.

Thanks for your input though, I'll have to look around if I can get an as nice experience with a DIY NAS/server than with the Synology.
Edited by Jeutie - 7/18/12 at 1:30am
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Gaming & Content Streaming › Networking, Media Servers & Content Streaming › Dilemma: Blu-ray, NAS or HTPC