or Connect
AVS › AVS Forum › Blu-ray & HD DVD › Official AVS Blu-ray Disc Reviews › Jaws (Blu-ray) Official AVSForum Review
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Jaws (Blu-ray) Official AVSForum Review - Page 4

post #91 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Closet Geek View Post

Just to offer an unsolicited piece of nostalgia, I recall being at the now defunct Venture store with my mom when I was about nine years old asking her to buy the Jaws soundtrack for me. ON LP!!! eek.gif
What kind of kid asks his mom to buy the symphonic score of a movie staring a shark that scared the daylights out of most of the country AND listened to it virtually every night? Was I demented or are we bringing our kids up soft these days? biggrin.gif

I still have the original Jaws LP!! And yes, it scared me as much as the movie did!

Jeff
post #92 of 139
This is the reason we spend all that money on this hobby.
post #93 of 139
Wow, easily day one purchase. Thanks for the review!
post #94 of 139
Curious to know if anyone has picked this up yet.
post #95 of 139
Going on my lunch break today...gonna get the best buy "limited edition" kinda by default. There is little to no info- even on BB's- site about it though.

Go figure.

James
post #96 of 139
How many versions will be released today? Will BB have a different version? Last but not least, is it worth waiting a few months to see it going for $9.99 during the holiday season?
post #97 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by SLUDGE View Post

Last but not least, is it worth waiting a few months to see it going for $9.99 during the holiday season?

I'm not sure anyone can answer this question for you. I mean, who doesn't want to pay $10 for a BD but on the other hand, if you're a fan then you'll probably not mind going full boat on it (sorry, had to). I will not be waiting and picking up my copy this weekend.
post #98 of 139
I went to bluray.com and read some of the forums. The BB version is a digibook, 42 pages and is $24.99. Supposedly they are selling fast with only a few on the shelf. I dont think a book is worth an extra $5.
post #99 of 139
^Agreed. I'll take a look when I stop in, thanks.


James
post #100 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by emgesp View Post

The movie is a classic, but your review for the PQ and AQ is ridiculous. Don't let your love for this film cloud your judgement when it comes to evaluating the film on a technical level. The film doesn't look, or sound amazing. The studios did a decent job with the lousy 70's film stock source material they had to work with.

I thought the rating of 100 for both sound and picture was warranted.cool.gif
post #101 of 139
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by gbaby View Post

I thought the rating of 100 for both sound and picture was warranted.cool.gif

Greetings,

Glad to hear it gbaby.. smile.gif


Regards,
post #102 of 139
Yes, it looks amazing. A new standard for films of its era. If only the Star Wars OT Blu-Rays looked as great. I wish the documentaries were in better quality but that's my only quibble.
post #103 of 139
Nice Review, Ralph - been admiring your work for several years.

Just got back home and cant wait to pop this baby in. Rare that I get a blu ray opening day, but I just had to get this ASAP. I was born a few days after this came out and actually saw parts 2 and 3 before seeing this as a 10 year old. I actually was looking more forward to this than any theatrical release this year!
post #104 of 139
Watched this tonight. I think the PQ is fantastic, but it doesn't warrant a "100". Compared to other live action films that do warrant a 100, the difference is obvious. Calling it "100 for a film of its age" just doesn't hold water. Any standard for rating PQ has to be the same across all films, not different for older vs newer or anything else. I'd give it a 90-95 based on Ralph's criteria. The sharpness of image just isn't there for a 100.

That said, I agree with Spielberg that it probably looks better than it originally did in theaters.
post #105 of 139
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by rdgrimes View Post

Watched this tonight. I think the PQ is fantastic, but it doesn't warrant a "100". Compared to other live action films that do warrant a 100, the difference is obvious. Calling it "100 for a film of its age" just doesn't hold water. Any standard for rating PQ has to be the same across all films, not different for older vs newer or anything else. I'd give it a 90-95 based on Ralph's criteria. The sharpness of image just isn't there for a 100.
That said, I agree with Spielberg that it probably looks better than it originally did in theaters.

Greetings,

Thanks for sharing your impressions rdgrimes. Your input is always appreciated and I'm glad that you enjoyed Jaws in Blu...smile.gif


Regards,
post #106 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by rdgrimes View Post

Watched this tonight. I think the PQ is fantastic, but it doesn't warrant a "100". Compared to other live action films that do warrant a 100, the difference is obvious. Calling it "100 for a film of its age" just doesn't hold water. Any standard for rating PQ has to be the same across all films, not different for older vs newer or anything else. I'd give it a 90-95 based on Ralph's criteria. The sharpness of image just isn't there for a 100.
That said, I agree with Spielberg that it probably looks better than it originally did in theaters.

Huge, huge, fan of the film and I largely agree, which isn't a slight on anyone, just simply my opinion after fully digesting it on my Kuro yesterday. Wasn't really even "disappointed" either- I quite like what I saw and heard, overall.

To put it another way:

For its "ERA": PQ: 95 SQ: 92

For its "GENRE/OVERALL": PQ: 92 SQ: 87

In the audio dept, we've simply just come a helluva long way in the last 35+ years and for as great as the sound is in Jaws, let's face it, there are other films that are markedly more sonically rich, simple as that, really.


Just remember gang: it would a real boring existence if everyone agreed on everything.


James
Edited by mastermaybe - 8/15/12 at 5:56am
post #107 of 139
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by mastermaybe View Post

Huge, huge, fan of the film and I largely agree, which isn't a slight on anyone, just simply my opinion after fully digesting it on my Kuro yesterday. Wasn't really even "disappointed" either- I quite like what I saw and heard, overall.
To put it another way:
For its "ERA": PQ: 95 SQ: 92
For its "GENRE/OVERALL": PQ: 92 SQ: 87
In the audio dept, we've simply just come a helluva long way in the last 35+ years and for as great as the sound is in Jaws, let's face it, there are other films that are markedly more sonically rich, simple as that, really.
Just remember gang: it would a real boring existence if everyone agreed on everything.
James

Greetings,

It's what makes the world go around James. Great stuff...wink.gif


Regards,
post #108 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by rdgrimes View Post

Watched this tonight. I think the PQ is fantastic, but it doesn't warrant a "100". Compared to other live action films that do warrant a 100, the difference is obvious. Calling it "100 for a film of its age" just doesn't hold water. Any standard for rating PQ has to be the same across all films, not different for older vs newer or anything else. I'd give it a 90-95 based on Ralph's criteria. The sharpness of image just isn't there for a 100.
That said, I agree with Spielberg that it probably looks better than it originally did in theaters.

Glad I'm not the only one. Great transfer. Nothing but respect for Mr Potts.
post #109 of 139
Considering how "crummy" the OCN were, as described in the Restoration video, they did a great job in fixing things up. I also didn't notice excessive grain reduction as the "negativists" were claiming was going to happen. BUT, what i did notice, was a distinct lack of contrast in many of the outdoor shots. A little adjustment of the black level fixes the problem for these shots, but then you need to restore the black level for the remainder of the scenes. A little annoying. Can't figure out whether this was intentional or accidental.
post #110 of 139
Just finished it, and its spectacular. Had a great experience with DVDs but one thing that always bothered me for Jaws and other films set in water is you could usually see the pixelation and blockiness. Didnt see that here biggrin.gif

Im now curious as to how it sounds in mono. Been reading a lot and many home theatre fans complain older movies that were mono or stereo and then remixed to 5.1 are usually sub-par and actually hurt the sound design. Being relatively new to the audio side of home theatre, Im still developing my taste and I thought the sound in 5.1 (dont have a 7.1 setup) was awesome.

Based on what Ive been reading, I guess I should consider myself lucky to get the BB DigiBook version. A lot of reports of this edition being sold out and/or unavailable.

I cant get over how great this flick still is after all these years.
post #111 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by huskie2000 View Post

Just finished it, and its spectacular. Had a great experience with DVDs but one thing that always bothered me for Jaws and other films set in water is you could usually see the pixelation and blockiness. Didnt see that here biggrin.gif
Im now curious as to how it sounds in mono. Been reading a lot and many home theatre fans complain older movies that were mono or stereo and then remixed to 5.1 are usually sub-par and actually hurt the sound design. Being relatively new to the audio side of home theatre, Im still developing my taste and I thought the sound in 5.1 (dont have a 7.1 setup) was awesome.
Based on what Ive been reading, I guess I should consider myself lucky to get the BB DigiBook version. A lot of reports of this edition being sold out and/or unavailable.
I cant get over how great this flick still is after all these years.

Its the best shark film ever made. Nothing today still comes close its all crap ( regarding shark films ). I cannot wait till next week smile.gif
post #112 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Franin View Post


Its the best shark film ever made. Nothing today still comes close its all crap ( regarding shark films ). I cannot wait till next week smile.gif

Very true Fran! Did you ever catch a movie called "The Reef"??? I believe it's from your country. Very good one... used real Great Whites!
post #113 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by shamus View Post

Very true Fran! Did you ever catch a movie called "The Reef"??? I believe it's from your country. Very good one... used real Great Whites!

Yes I did that wasn't too bad actually I forgot about that one. I would of been the one staying on the boat smile.gif
post #114 of 139
Got the BB digibook. The look of this restoration is miraculous. And the movie, of course, is one of the greats.
post #115 of 139
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAM4UK View Post

Got the BB digibook. The look of this restoration is miraculous. And the movie, of course, is one of the greats.

Greetings,

cool.gif


Regards,
post #116 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by Franin View Post

Its the best shark film ever made.
One of the best films ever made, period.
post #117 of 139
Quote:
Originally Posted by SLUDGE View Post

I went to bluray.com and read some of the forums. The BB version is a digibook, 42 pages and is $24.99. Supposedly they are selling fast with only a few on the shelf. I dont think a book is worth an extra $5.


I got the DigiBook and proud to own it!! $5 is chump change for a jem like this.

I should have purchased another........... wink.gif
post #118 of 139
You made a great buy with the digibook as they are selling like hotcakes on ebay. I already saw one sell for $100! There are no digibooks available where I live. If I found one I would not open it and sell it when they become even more scarce. I ended up with the regular bluray for $18.99 at Costco.
post #119 of 139
I'll probably wind up there, too. For me, digibooks just waste space on the rack. I haven't looked at the Close Encounters or Taxi Driver books since first perusal.
post #120 of 139
Just ordered based on the fantastic review. Will be here Tuesday!!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Blu-ray & HD DVD › Official AVS Blu-ray Disc Reviews › Jaws (Blu-ray) Official AVSForum Review