Finally catching up here after months of crushing hours at work.
Amanda Brown is absolutely amazing, as is Nicholas. Agreed on Melanie - that is one weird voice - IMO she should never have made it onto the show.
I like Terry M. I'm a rock guy, and pull for him, but I just didn't care for his rendition of Don't Stop Believin'. I can't pinpoint it but something just wasn't right with that. That said, I've been pulling/voting for Michaela Page - she's a impressive little rocker chick!
The one no one has pointed out is Jose Castillo. In his own element (El Rey), he shines brilliantly. But when I've heard him sing on pop/rock tracks in past shows, he's just downright awful - worse than your average karaoke singer IMO. WHY is he still around?