For me it was a very solid "Meh". No season pass, I might tune in if bored and not in the mood for anything I have DVRd, but that is unlikely. Holmes came off as a hyperactive child, I did not buy Miller as Holmes for an instant. Hate the tats, actors should really think 4 times before doing that to themselves, big turn off for me.
I have to agree about the BBC production, it does not get better than that. Can't wait to see how they come back from the ending.
Holmes as written by Arthur Conan Doyle was hyperactive and sometimes drug addled. Brilliant, yes, but also unstable and often decidedly unpleasant. I thought Elementary's writers captured all of this nicely. Showing Holmes warts and all has been a big part of the BBC Sherlock's magic so I think the elementary showrunners made a good decision in not making Holmes too much of a hero.