AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › DIY Speakers and Subs › My First Ever DIY Sub
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

My First Ever DIY Sub - Page 5

post #121 of 231
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by saabracer23 View Post

Tune lower, you don't want that huge knee and you don't want to add any boost. If you use a plate amp you'll want to tune right around the roll off of the amplifier. Otherwise you could have issues with over excursion.

Dan

Using the amp's parametric EQ to cut that freq would help even that knee out, correct?
post #122 of 231
Unibox doesn't exactly agree with Bass Box Pro 6. 3.33cu-ft box / 25Hz tune

19Hz HPF:


no HPF:


FWIW, a 19Hz HPF just barely keeps driver excursion in check with a 25Hz tune.

What diameter is your port?
post #123 of 231
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stereodude View Post

Unibox doesn't exactly agree with Bass Box Pro 6. 3.33cu-ft box / 25Hz tune

19Hz HPF:


no HPF:


FWIW, a 19Hz HPF just barely keeps driver excursion in check with a 25Hz tune.

What diameter is your port?

2.265" x 2
post #124 of 231
Quote:
Originally Posted by mfrey0118 View Post

2.265" x 2
You're going to have serious problems if that's really the diameter of the ports you're using. With the 19Hz HPF in play you're looking at >70m/sec air velocities at 24Hz with 500W.
post #125 of 231
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stereodude View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by mfrey0118 View Post

2.265" x 2
You're going to have serious problems if that's really the diameter of the ports you're using. With the 19Hz HPF in play you're looking at >70m/sec air velocities at 24Hz with 500W.

Bro, this is why I started this thread, because I don't know squat.

What do you suggest?

Also, if anyone could take the time to answer my questions in POST #145 I sure would be grateful.
post #126 of 231
Quote:
Originally Posted by mfrey0118 View Post

Bro, this is why I started this thread, because I don't know squat.
What do you suggest?
2 4" ports or a single 6" port is about where you want to be IMHO, but they'll be hard to fit in the box. Twin 4" diameter ports need to be ~30" long (each) for a 25Hz tune. A 20Hz tune is even worse with twin 4" diameter ports @ ~48" long . "Small" high output ported boxes that are tuned low is challenging.
post #127 of 231
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stereodude View Post

2 4" ports or a single 6" port is about where you want to be IMHO, but they'll be hard to fit in the box. Twin 4" diameter ports need to be ~30" long (each) for a 25Hz tune. A 20Hz tune is even worse with twin 4" diameter ports @ ~48" long . "Small" high output ported boxes that are tuned low is challenging.

Hmm...I wonder then if it would just be better to go KISS method and do sealed for now...since I can get all my cuts with room for mistakes from one MDF sheet, that makes it not too bad if I need to build another one.
post #128 of 231
Quote:
Originally Posted by mfrey0118 View Post

I have the industrial strength spray adhesive (8 freakin' bucks at HD) for the carpet, is that sufficient?
Sufficient for holding carpet on, probably. Gluing the box together, no. To glue the box together use wood glue.
Quote:
I figure that, barring any room correction which would require a cut, I can set boost eq to 22hz at like +3db and .5 Q to get a little more and it should sound pretty good, right?
I'm possible to say. right now.
Quote:
What kind of paint do I use for PVC ports?
I would suggest using flared Precision Ports that are already black.
Quote:
Using DAP Fast Dry Acrylic Latex Caulk Plus Silicon for joint sealers is that good or would going with hot glue be better?
I would probably recommend caulk / silicon over hot glue.
Quote:
Wood putty for screw holes, correct?
If you're carpeting the box, it doesn't matter unless they're visible under the carpet.
Quote:
Do I need to sand at all if I'm just going to use carpet on the outside?
The spray adhesive might stick better if the outside surface is a little rough, but it might not be necessary. You could test using some scraps of the carpet and wood.
Quote:
Can I use MDF to brace joints or is solid wood recommended?
MDF is fine for bracing.
Quote:
Can I get away with just one crossbeam? If so, which direction? From side to side?
Hard to say since it's not clear what you mean by crossbeam. What are the dimension of your planned box?
Quote:
What should be the order of my steps?
Something like Cut, glue, screw, wait, seal, wait, assemble, test, disassemble, carpet, final assembly
Quote:
Does flush mount make an audible difference from face mounted?
For a sub, it doesn't matter.
Quote:
Should I glue in between each piece or just seal the box after I screw it together?
You should glue in between each piece. The glue is largely what end up holding the box together. The screws largely hold things in place while the glue dries.
Quote:
When do I put the carpet on, before or after the box is put together, etc?
After.
Quote:
I don't want to, like, put the box together and glue it only to find I need to brace all the joints...
bracing isn't to reinforce the joints. It's to reduce panel resonances. The joints don't need bracing the large unsupported open spaces in the middle of the panels do.
post #129 of 231
Thread Starter 
Thanks, stereodude.

By "crossbeam" I mean running my 1 x 4 from inside wall to parallel inside wall to reduce flexing. Can I get away with just one beam and if so, from what side to what side (i.e. front to back, side to side, top to bottom)?
post #130 of 231
Here is a link to my build http://www.avsforum.com/t/1432689/my-epic-12-build

You can mimic the build, easy way to get a long port in the box.

Dan
post #131 of 231
Thread Starter 
What's a good, simple idea for the grill? Can I just make one out of leftover MDF and some neodymium magnets without having to order anything special?
post #132 of 231
Quote:
Originally Posted by mfrey0118 View Post

  • I have the industrial strength spray adhesive (8 freakin' bucks at HD) for the carpet, is that sufficient?
  • I figure that, barring any room correction which would require a cut, I can set boost eq to 22hz at like +3db and .5 Q to get a little more and it should sound pretty good, right?
  • What kind of paint do I use for PVC ports?
  • Using DAP Fast Dry Acrylic Latex Caulk Plus Silicon for joint sealers is that good or would going with hot glue be better?
  • If hot glue, is there a difference in glue sticks or will any stick work?
  • Wood putty for screw holes, correct?
  • Do I need to sand at all if I'm just going to use carpet on the outside?
  • Can I use MDF to brace joints or is solid wood recommended?
  • Can I get away with just one crossbeam? If so, which direction? From side to side?
  • What should be the order of my steps?
  • Does flush mount make an audible difference from face mounted?
  • Should I glue in between each piece or just seal the box after I screw it together?
  • When do I put the carpet on, before or after the box is put together, etc?

*Spray adhesive is fine for carpet. Spray the box and the back of the carpet. Let it sit for 3-5 min, then apply the carpet to the box. Overlap seams and trim using a utility knife and straight edge.
*I paint the ports w/ rustolium prof rattle can paint
*Use PL Premium adhesive for the joints and you won't need to seal. It's an expanding glue and very forgiving if your cuts are not perfect.
*Screw holes don't need to be filled if you are using carpet. When I do fill them I use bondo...or pl premium if the tube is already open.
*I don't sand if covering in carpet. I will use a plane to knock down any uneven edges.
*MDF is good for braces. I've never used boards. MDF is more stable. I don't brace corners. Corners are the strongest part of the box anyway.
*One beam across, one vertical, one strip about 2" high as a spine against the back wall of the box since you can't tie it to the baffle. That's a minimum. Every panel should be braced to reduce resonance. Ideally a brace every 8-10".
*Cut panels, rout holes, glue & screw, brace, carpet, line, install driver.
post #133 of 231
Also, for ported boxes I line the box w/ mattress topper from Wal-Mart. I think the full size bed topper is $10 vs $18 for a bag of poly quilting from the fabric store. Don't use pollyfill pillow stuffing in a ported box.
post #134 of 231
Thread Starter 
Ok so for the grill I think Im just going to make a 1.5" wide frame out of my leftover MDF and use black grill cloth and N48 1/2" x 1/16" neodymium magnets glued both to the box front and grill. I guess I'll order some of the cheaper black spikes from PE.com for the feet.

Can I staple the grill cloth with a staple gun or should I just go ahead and use adhesive?
post #135 of 231
Quote:
Originally Posted by mfrey0118 View Post

Ok so for the grill I think Im just going to make a 1.5" wide frame out of my leftover MDF and use black grill cloth and N48 1/2" x 1/16" neodymium magnets glued both to the box front and grill. I guess I'll order some of the cheaper black spikes from PE.com for the feet.
Can I staple the grill cloth with a staple gun or should I just go ahead and use adhesive?

Sounds like a good plan.

There are 2 types of grill cloth at PE last I checked. One is a 3D weave made with nylon strands. This one needs to be stretched with a good bit of tension across the frame and stapled on the back. I've used this product to restore a guitar cab and it looks good and is durable. However, it does have a classic 60's radio/ Marshall guitar cab look and probably isn't what you want unless durability is your primary concern.

The other, cheaper type is more like a modern home speaker grill. It's a lighter weight, more fabric-like material. Again, staple it on the back of the frame using a little tension to keep the fabric tight. In either case a little glue along the cut edge of the fabric may help keep it from fraying.
post #136 of 231
Thread Starter 
post #137 of 231
Thread Starter 
Here's some pics...







Cutting the square was the hardest part, as all we had to work with was a powered hand saw...as you can see it is definitely rough but the good thing is the amp has a massive gasket almost an inch thick which easily covers the errors.

As I said, I'm going with the KISS method, since I have no experience, either with carpentry or home made subs, so for now i'm going sealed. However, I have the sub high enough on the front to allow for up to two 5" ports to be installed below the speaker in the future, should I want to do that. Got the box put together, braced and sealed and grill frame cut. Today, glue the carpet on mount sub and amp and see how she sounds. Got grill mesh, magnets, and spikes coming in the mail.

Will take more pics this evening...
post #138 of 231
Hi Mfrey,

Since your now in the build stage, starting a new thread or having a Mod change title might get more visibility......

Lookin good so far!
post #139 of 231
Thread Starter 
OK, here's some more pics. Couple of notes:

I screwed up using the router and circle jig. You can see a divot on one side of the sub cut out. Fortunately, again, the Epic has a very big gasket and it easily covered the error.

The front is a bit rough because I'm making a grill later this week when my parts come in.

The back is a bit rough because it's the back and most likely I won't be facing the sub towards the corner. If I do end up having it face the corner for better acoustics, I'll cross that bridge when I come to it.

This thing is big and freakin' heavy. My elbows are burning from moving it around so much tonight. Can't wait to hear it. I'm probably going to play around with it a little tonight but not sub crawl or calibration...that'll be tomorrow evening. I'll probably run a 30hz sine wave on a loop overnight to break it in a bit.

So here's my home made sub with zero home theater or box building experience...











post #140 of 231
Nice! Put a couple pillows in there!
post #141 of 231
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by NicksHitachi View Post

Nice! Put a couple pillows in there!

I've got 2 lbs of polyfil in there...is that enough?

This thing is STIFF out of the box...but I can already really tell the difference. I can feel the pressure differential in my ears sitting at my computer in the kitchen part of the open room on low notes playing Bass Mechanik CDs at low volume. Could never hear that from the Onkyo.
post #142 of 231
Quote:
Originally Posted by mfrey0118 View Post

I've got 2 lbs of polyfil in there...is that enough?
This thing is STIFF out of the box...but I can already really tell the difference. I can feel the pressure differential in my ears sitting at my computer in the kitchen part of the open room on low notes playing Bass Mechanik CDs at low volume. Could never hear that from the Onkyo.

Hey buddy... Been following your thread from the beginning. Banter, lively discussiom and all.

Just wanted to say good job and I think ultimately you will like going sealed in the end.

About your polyfill question. 1lb (bag) per cuft has always been a standard rule of thumb (sorry, I can't find my old reference).

I didn't read any mention that you did some inital freeair testing before installing your driver in your cabinet. Not a huge deal, just a preference of mine.

One thing to keep in mind is that I've heard several TC Sub owners mention that you should potentially gain some output after the suspension lossens up a bit from inital breakin.

Hey, so... Ultimate end goal? Now that you've built, let's re-asess. You good with everything?
post #143 of 231
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by popalock View Post


Hey buddy... Been following your thread from the beginning. Banter, lively discussiom and all.

Just wanted to say good job and I think ultimately you will like going sealed in the end.

About your polyfill question. 1lb (bag) per cuft has always been a standard rule of thumb (sorry, I can't find my old reference).

I didn't read any mention that you did some inital freeair testing before installing your driver in your cabinet. Not a huge deal, just a preference of mine.

One thing to keep in mind is that I've heard several TC Sub owners mention that you should potentially gain some output after the suspension lossens up a bit from inital breakin.

Hey, so... Ultimate end goal? Now that you've built, let's re-asess. You good with everything?

Oh ok, thanks man. The volume should be close to 3.3 cubic feet, so I'll need another 1.3 lbs.

Ultimate end goal? ha...I'm just gettin' started! I left enough room below the sub for two ports up to about 4 or 5 inches in diameter, in case I want to go ported.

Good with everything? Tough question. I'll put it this way...for my first ever attempt at doing this while not really knowing what I'm doing? Yeah, I'm satisfied with the results. But next time I'll make a much cleaner, more professional looking box with like vinyl or something...plus better cuts on the circles and squares...and I think I'll try triangle wedges next time...

Man, I can see why people charge so much to do this...it's a lot of work, especially when you're like me and have to do it in the hot south florida sun, 90+ degress and suffocating humidity...I'm beat! tongue.gif
post #144 of 231
you did wire the coils in series, right?
post #145 of 231
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by LTD02 View Post

you did wire the coils in series, right?
Yeah. Wire from positive terminal on first coil to negative on second coil, then wire from negative terminal of first coil and positive terminal of second coil to amp.
Edited by mfrey0118 - 10/11/12 at 5:16am
post #146 of 231
great. that is how it should be set up.

i was reading back through the thread and saw that you asked a question about wiring a 1 ohm load to your amp and that would be a bad idea.
post #147 of 231
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stereodude View Post

You're going to have serious problems if that's really the diameter of the ports you're using. With the 19Hz HPF in play you're looking at >70m/sec air velocities at 24Hz with 500W.

Can either you or someone else please explain the science of port velocity, and how ports affect the sound based on their size and length? I am slowly learning about how to use WinISD but all of this talk about port velocity and optimal port size and shape, I am confused. Could you please explain this?
post #148 of 231
Quote:
Originally Posted by Martycool007 View Post

Can either you or someone else please explain the science of port velocity, and how ports affect the sound based on their size and length? I am slowly learning about how to use WinISD but all of this talk about port velocity and optimal port size and shape, I am confused. Could you please explain this?
As air velocities in the ports increase you get boundary layer turbulence (audible chuffing). If you continue to increase the velocities the port past the point of chuffing you will get core turbulence and compression. When that happens the port no long acts like a port and the and the box no long acts like the models predicts.

This page / program gets into things further.

With the sort of giant sonosubs you're looking at building you can use 8" sonotube for the port and keep the air velocities low enough to where you shouldn't have any audible problems.
post #149 of 231
Wow, that went quick. Looks good for a first timer. cool.gif
post #150 of 231
Thread Starter 
Well, I've got some ground loop hum going on...soon as I disconnected the cable line from the system it stopped. It's not bad though, I can only hear it when the sub is not active and with my ear up to the cone...Does the hum degrade performance noticeably if it isn't loud? I've got a Monster HTS2000, if I run the cable through there will that take care of it? Will I suffer any loss of PQ?

Also, is there a way to ensure that I make my grill to stand out far enough so the surround/woofer cone does not touch it during high excursion? Can I calculate that with xmax?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: DIY Speakers and Subs
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › DIY Speakers and Subs › My First Ever DIY Sub