AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › DIY Speakers and Subs › SEOS Surround Build
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

SEOS Surround Build - Page 3

post #61 of 170
Bessy and Jorgensen make great clamps.

I've got about 16 Jorgensen pipe clamps in the garage.
post #62 of 170
Quote:
Originally Posted by Java View Post

Can you shoot a link on the 4-pack? $20 is a great deal. I'll add it to the instructions.
Thanks!

It was a while ago that I bought them and it had 4 of the 12" clamps instead of the one linked above, but that one works also. Those Bessey K-body clamps are nice, but IMO you should target the beginners with your videos and instructions. I believe LTD02 mentioned people watching the videos out of curiosity and you could "sell" them on the idea of flat packs when they see how easy it is, not to mention advertising for the DIY cause. cool.gif
post #63 of 170
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spec4 View Post

It was a while ago that I bought them and it had 4 of the 12" clamps instead of the one linked above, but that one works also. Those Bessey K-body clamps are nice, but IMO you should target the beginners with your videos and instructions. I believe LTD02 mentioned people watching the videos out of curiosity and you could "sell" them on the idea of flat packs when they see how easy it is, not to mention advertising for the DIY cause. cool.gif

Those are a little small given the box is around 19" tall and 14.5" wide.

I got some 24" quick grip clamps: http://www.lowes.com/pd_122229-281-2021424N_4294936478__?productId=1205993&Ntt=clamps

A bit pricey (got those on sale and also borrowed another 24" set), but are quick and easy.
post #64 of 170
Thread Starter 
Bondo Hell

I forgot how much I hate this phase. wink.gif

I'm sure there is a better way to do this, but I use bondo filler to create an even seem around the box. One step I should have done was to sand down the mdf before I started bond. In many cases, with the tight fit of the flat packs, I could have created a pretty even seem with sanding the mdf, with minimal bondo. But I didn't realize that until later.

Experienced finishers please weigh in, but from my noob adventures in my first build, I found that bondo works better than wood filler. Mainly it seems to lay down better and has less pits and holes in it. I'm sure I did something wrong, but I found with plain wood filler, as I sanded down the filler, I got pits/holes in the final layer and had to lay another layer. I got some of that with bondo, but much less.

As far as bondo, yes, this is the stuff used on cars. From what I read it works great with MDF. A word of warning is to play around with how much hardener to use and use smaller amounts of filler. If you use the "recommended" amount, it will dry very fast. If you are good with this stuff, that's fine. You can sand it in 30 min. But, if you are noob like me, that gets tough to get the filler spread out right, so I dialed back the hardener a bit. Takes longer to dry, but it easier to work with.

Once the bondo drys, use a rough grit to knock down the first layers and then when you are down to level (can't feel the filler edge) shift to finer grit. At least for me, even with a half sheet orbital sander, it takes me a long time to sand it down. And it takes a couple of times (filler/sanding) to get it right.

Bondo


Bondo Phase. This is the second round of filler. You can see I already sanded down one layer and laid the next layer down.


Post Sanding. This is the bottom of the box. This one is pretty smooth.


Minor Fix. This is the other bottom that has a small pit that needs to be filled.

Edited by Java - 11/22/12 at 12:44pm
post #65 of 170
Quote:
Originally Posted by smokarz View Post

The $20 is a sale price.
Might not last long.
Here's the link
http://www.lowes.com/pd_409558-281-1851480_0__?productId=4009979&Ntt=irwin+clamp&pl=1&currentURL=%3FNtt%3Dirwin%2Bclamp&facetInfo=

I was at Lowes yesterday and saw a bunch of these packs ready for holiday shoppers. I was also at home depot and they have a similar, but I think slightly beefier pack of four Irwin clamps for $25 as a holiday special purchase.

-Max
post #66 of 170
Quote:
Originally Posted by maxcooper View Post

I was at Lowes yesterday and saw a bunch of these packs ready for holiday shoppers. I was also at home depot and they have a similar, but I think slightly beefier pack of four Irwin clamps for $25 as a holiday special purchase.
-Max



I was in HD this morning to pick up a few generators for the family.

For BF, they have 4x 12" pack for $19.99. I passed since they're too short.
post #67 of 170
Oh man I feel for you Java. That is the worst part. You feel like there is no progress yet tons of work. What kind of finish are you planning?
post #68 of 170
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by tuxedocivic View Post

Oh man I feel for you Java. That is the worst part. You feel like there is no progress yet tons of work. What kind of finish are you planning?

Nearing the end...

I'm just going with flat black like the fronts. I would say I want to have them "blend in" to the side walls, but at 19" x 14.5" these are not going to blend easy. rolleyes.gif
post #69 of 170
Thread Starter 
Priming Done

All done with the priming phase. BTW, I decided that a video is pretty much useless for this phase since it doesn't really show you much versus photo's.

The key to this phase is sanding between coats. I used a rattle can primer and it still left a rough texture. Hand sand the surface until smooth. This also lets you fix and paint rolls.

Primer Used.


Before primer. All sanded down.


1st Coat of Primer


Some Issues. Don't know if you can see this, but there are some pits in some of the bondo.


Solution. I found this thread and it turned me to using glazing. It's found at a auto parts shop.


Glazing. Here's the glazing before sanding. It was thicker than I expected and started drying pretty quick, but worked out ok.


Sanded. It sanded very easy compared to the base bondo.


Final Primer Coat. A storm started blowing in so I rushed this a bit...

Edited by Java - 11/23/12 at 2:59pm
post #70 of 170
Very nice. I have a love hate relationship with bondo. Can the glaze replace it completely or is it just for small touch ups?
post #71 of 170
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by brian6751 View Post

Very nice. I have a love hate relationship with bondo. Can the glaze replace it completely or is it just for small touch ups?

Thanks. From what I read in that thread I found, you still need a base of "regular" bondo.
post #72 of 170
Thread Starter 
Crossover Check



I jumped the gun a bit from a posting perspective. I shot the crossover build video, but its a super long bore-fest, so I got some editing ahead of me...

I wanted to post this crossover check video to see you all opinions. The first board seems to check out OK. It reads around 4 ohms. Seems a bit low. My mains showed about 6 ohms. Tux?

On the second board, I had two failure points. One the LF board, I had a bad capacitor. Note to self and all, double check all the components you get from PE as soon as you get the. Too late for a return for me.

On the HF board, it looks like I had a bad solder joint on the first inductor. Kind of strange though, since I twisted all of the leads. Solder is more of a glue than a conductor in my case.

Thoughts?

Edit: I updated the above youtube video with a corrected goof on board one (swapped in/out) and the fix on board two.
Edited by Java - 11/25/12 at 5:06pm
post #73 of 170
What kind of solder did you use?
post #74 of 170
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Face2 View Post

What kind of solder did you use?

Rosin core from Rat Shack.

post #75 of 170
Java, the measured impedance of the cross over with a basic DMM should be the same as the woofer plus a little bit for the DCR of the coils. In other words, something sounds wrong. Not sure how though.
post #76 of 170
Java is going to be a professional speaker assembler when all is said and done!
post #77 of 170
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by tuxedocivic View Post

Java, the measured impedance of the cross over with a basic DMM should be the same as the woofer plus a little bit for the DCR of the coils. In other words, something sounds wrong. Not sure how though.

Are you saying it should be higher than 8 ohms? My main build with the 2512 (8 ohms) all came in around 6 ohms. I assume that it's because of the addition of the CD (in parallel?) the total speaker resistance falls to 4 ohms and then the crossover resistance adds some back. Make sense?

Did you check your boards resistance?

Thanks
post #78 of 170
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Erich H View Post

Java is going to be a professional speaker assembler when all is said and done!

Then I would starve... wink.gif
post #79 of 170
No not 8 ohms. The tweeter doesn't count because it has a cap in front. So the resistance from that circuit goes to infinity. So we're left with the woofer circuit, unless there is a problem with the tweeter circuit. The woofer circuit is a 4th order electrical, so you should be measuring two coils and a woofer in series. That would be DCR + DCR + Re. About 0.5+0.5+5.4=6.4ohms.

Ill watch the video.

You showed me your cross over proof before this started, so I'm not sure what's going on. I'll look at your old email.
post #80 of 170
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by tuxedocivic View Post

No not 8 ohms. The tweeter doesn't count because it has a cap in front. So the resistance from that circuit goes to infinity. So we're left with the woofer circuit, unless there is a problem with the tweeter circuit. The woofer circuit is a 4th order electrical, so you should be measuring two coils and a woofer in series. That would be DCR + DCR + Re. About 0.5+0.5+5.4=6.4ohms.
Ill watch the video.
You showed me your cross over proof before this started, so I'm not sure what's going on. I'll look at your old email.

Thanks, Tux. I warned you that I was still a noob at this. wink.gif

The 6.4 ohms sound spot on for my mains. If memory serves, I was hitting around 6.3 on those.
post #81 of 170
I think I found it. Your second board looks right, but not your first. Email coming.
post #82 of 170
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by tuxedocivic View Post

I think I found it. Your second board looks right, but not your first. Email coming.



Eagle eyed Tux found my goof. I reversed the "in and out" on the HF board for the test. Per below, now that I fixed my dumb a** mistake, the resistance is spot on at 6.4 ohms. The boards are fine, but but I goofed on the test set up...

post #83 of 170
Thread Starter 
Fixed & Tested



I fixed the bad solder joint on board two and even without replacing the "bad" capacitor, the board "passed". Right at about 6.5 ohms.

I'm thinking my "testing" just the capacitor may be flawed. You can test a resistor, but is resistance a good test of a capacitor? There's a gated thing going on, rights.

Anyway, all is good on the crossover front. I updated the video with these fixes and also replace the test on board one with the "right" test. wink.gif

I'm also going to replace the earlier post with this update video and delete the old one from youtube so there is no confusion.
post #84 of 170
Just wanted to say thank you for your efforts in documenting this. With these kits the crossover is the only intimidating factor. This makes that part much less so. Great work. I know how much time this takes and I appreciate it. I'm not building these right now but may in the future. I'm sure there are many folks benefitting now though.
post #85 of 170
Also Brian, if a builder can post a photo, many guys here are willing to eyeball the cross over and guide newbs. If that helps.
post #86 of 170
Quote:
Originally Posted by brian6751 View Post

Just wanted to say thank you for your efforts in documenting this. With these kits the crossover is the only intimidating factor. This makes that part much less so. Great work. I know how much time this takes and I appreciate it. I'm not building these right now but may in the future. I'm sure there are many folks benefitting now though.

Ditto - well said.

Nice work Java!
post #87 of 170
Thanks for making the videos. I feel more confident that I could build these after watching. The only thing that I have concerns about is the x over.
post #88 of 170
I'm hoping to find someone to make completed crossovers for about $10 or less. If I got the real crossover board, they would be $10 or less. But the end user would still have to solder them together. So it might make sense to find someone willing to completely do these on a thin sheet of wood for about that price.

The issue is that they really should be local to cut down on shipping. I might be able to teach my sister how to do it, or maybe a friend. I'm not sure I would have that much time right now. But we'll see.
post #89 of 170
I think the crossover is one of the most fun parts, so you may consider at least having an option of supplying just the parts... Maybe even a high quality option with air core coils and polystyrene caps or whatever is en-vogue these days!
post #90 of 170
Quote:
Originally Posted by AI Limited View Post

I think the crossover is one of the most fun parts, so you may consider at least having an option of supplying just the parts... Maybe even a high quality option with air core coils and polystyrene caps or whatever is en-vogue these days!

I hadn't thought about the xover being the fun part, since I've been cobbling stuff together and letting the smoke out of things since I was a youngster. But I could see how someone who hadn't done a lot of electronics tinkering would get a kick out of building their own.

Maybe a "crossover assembly kit" would be a good thing to add to the site. It could include zip ties, hookup wire, terminal blocks, etc. All the stuff that a tinkerer would have on hand but a noob would have to go out and buy. Maybe even include pieces of pegboard or thin plywood to assemble the components onto.

A set of tools for xover assembly might be a good addition too.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: DIY Speakers and Subs
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › DIY Speakers and Subs › SEOS Surround Build