DVD+R didn't work BUT DVD-R worked fine? Why?

post #1 of 8

11/7/12 at 4:32am

Thread Starter

45 Posts. Joined 9/2008
Select All Posts By This User

I have a Toshiba DVD recorder hooked to my WII console to sometimes record games. I have BOTH DVD-R and DVD+R discs. When I record using the DVD+R, there is no sound after the disc is finalized............IF I use the DVD-R, everything is fine. Is there a reason for not being able to use +R in my DVD recorder?

Reply

post #2 of 8

11/7/12 at 9:20am

4,478 Posts. Joined 12/2007
Location: Pacific Northwest.
Select All Posts By This User

Quote:

Originally Posted by mark40511

I have a Toshiba DVD recorder hooked to my WII console to sometimes record games. I have BOTH DVD-R and DVD+R discs. When I record using the DVD+R, there is no sound after the disc is finalized............IF I use the DVD-R, everything is fine. Is there a reason for not being able to use +R in my DVD recorder?

Toshiba DVD Recorders and DVD Players manufactured by Toshiba don't support DVD+R media formats.

Toshiba began transitioning to Funai manufactured DVD Recorders around the beginning of 2006. Toshiba branded Funai manufactured DVD Recorders support DVD-R and DVD+R media formats.

While the DVD+R formats began entering the marketplace in the mid-2000s, the DVD Forum, a consortium of manufacturers and other interested parties, first officially recognized the DVD+R formats on 25 January 2008.

Reply

post #3 of 8

11/7/12 at 11:06am

Thread Starter

45 Posts. Joined 9/2008
Select All Posts By This User

Yes thanks! It's weird. It accepts the DVD+R blank disc......It gives the record time available depending on record mode, and when you press record, it works as normal. Then it finalizes successfully. But, unlike DVD-R, when it's finished finalizing and the menu loads, there's an extra "title" in the menu that's blank.......

Oh well. It's about four or five years old.....Good to know.

Thanks for responding.

Reply

post #4 of 8

11/7/12 at 4:16pm

4,081 Posts. Joined 12/2004
Location: High Desert, California
Select All Posts By This User

If it's four to five years old, has it always done this, or is this a new failure mode?

Many recorders are really finicky about the disks that they like, and the ones that they don't. I have figured out that my Panasonic DVD recorders like T-Y -R blanks, and that is all I purchase. If you find a format and manufacturer that your recordder likes, use it. While some machines claim that they will use any type and brand of disk, they definitely use some more effectively than others.

Just go with what works.

Reply

post #5 of 8

11/8/12 at 5:13am

Thread Starter

45 Posts. Joined 9/2008
Select All Posts By This User

Honestly - I think it's always done it with DVD+R...........but a lot of time goes by and I don't use the DVD recorder to record, and since I have both types of media I grab one and forget, then I realize my DVD recorder does this with DVD+R............Brand has never mattered. As long as its DVD-R...........I'm not sure what that extra title is when it's done finalizing and then menu comes up.........What happens is the DVD will play, but some chapters have no sound, while others do............I'm just try to remember never to use +R.

The Toshiba DVD recorder is Model # SE-R0265 and I'm guestimating that it's approx five years old. It still works great. KNOCK on wood! I would guestimate that it has recorded about 900 hours or so.

Reply

post #6 of 8

11/8/12 at 1:59pm

4,081 Posts. Joined 12/2004
Location: High Desert, California
Select All Posts By This User

That extra blank title has been brought up and discussed here in the past, but since I only have Panasonic DVD recorders, and they don't do that, I didn't pay too much attention to those threads. If the search function worked well these days, I'd suggest you do a search on the issue, but since it doesn't...

Maybe someone here will remember those discussions and report back.

Reply

post #7 of 8

11/8/12 at 2:53pm