AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Audio theory, Setup and Chat › Is there a reason why audio looks out of synch on my new TV?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Is there a reason why audio looks out of synch on my new TV?

post #1 of 26
Thread Starter 
Sorry if this is not the right discussion board for this question, but back in July I bought a brand new Samsung Smart TV that is 1080P 120Hz. The model number is s6100.

Anyway, no matter what I try, the dialog coming out of the center channel has a habit of looking out of synch with the lip movement, while the sound effects are fine. I thought it might have been the disc, but it has happened on nearly every movie I watch, and calibrating the tv has not fixed the issue. Does anyone know what is going on and how I fix this?
post #2 of 26
Yes. Video processing in TVs often results in the picture being out of sync with the audio. See if your TV has a "game" mode. Set it to that, don't worry about the picture changing, and see if it is more in sync now.

As to fix, your processor/audio equipment likely has an audio delay setting. Go into that menu and change it and see if you can get it in sync. It is very common to have to do this to get good sync.
post #3 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Kain View Post

no matter what I try, the dialog coming out of the center channel has a habit of looking out of synch with the lip movement

There are many causes of sync problems with TV broadcasts, and this article explains it in detail:

http://mixonline.com/post/features/audio_late_future/

Note that the video it usually ahead, at least that's the case when I notice this on TV. So delaying the audio would only make the problem worse. (Though this should not be an issue with DVDs or Blu-rays etc.)

--Ethan
post #4 of 26
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ethan Winer View Post

There are many causes of sync problems with TV broadcasts, and this article explains it in detail:
http://mixonline.com/post/features/audio_late_future/
Note that the video it usually ahead, at least that's the case when I notice this on TV. So delaying the audio would only make the problem worse. (Though this should not be an issue with DVDs or Blu-rays etc.)
--Ethan

Yeah, I don't watch tv broadcasts. I am referring to the audio on BDs and DVDs.
post #5 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Kain View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ethan Winer View Post

There are many causes of sync problems with TV broadcasts, and this article explains it in detail:
http://mixonline.com/post/features/audio_late_future/
Note that the video it usually ahead, at least that's the case when I notice this on TV. So delaying the audio would only make the problem worse. (Though this should not be an issue with DVDs or Blu-rays etc.)
--Ethan

Yeah, I don't watch tv broadcasts. I am referring to the audio on BDs and DVDs.



I have no problem with TV audio. For my hi-def TV I do have to use the audio delay feature built into by Bluray player to get the lip sync right for DVD and Bluray. As I recall I need to use 50 ms of audio delay.
post #6 of 26
If the delay is consistent and the audio precedes the video you may be able to fix it with either a setting on the TV or your AV receiver as advised above..

If it's random, you are just seeing the sloppiness in today's TV broadcast industry. And then who fault is it really? The production facility, the duplicator, the network, the local station, the cable or satellite company? Any of these can induce lip sync errors these days.

Most of it is caused by the MPEG (or other) compression and re-compression processes. When we had analog distribution chains and even early uncompressed digital systems, these lip sync problems were rare. Today they seem to be the norm!
post #7 of 26
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by J_Palmer_Cass View Post

I have no problem with TV audio. For my hi-def TV I do have to use the audio delay feature built into by Bluray player to get the lip sync right for DVD and Bluray. As I recall I need to use 50 ms of audio delay.

Where do I go to access this audio delay feature? I use the PS3 for my BD viewing. And my receiver is a Pioneer Elite.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Glimmie View Post

If the delay is consistent and the audio precedes the video you may be able to fix it with either a setting on the TV or your AV receiver as advised above..
If it's random, you are just seeing the sloppiness in today's TV broadcast industry. And then who fault is it really? The production facility, the duplicator, the network, the local station, the cable or satellite company? Any of these can induce lip sync errors these days.
Most of it is caused by the MPEG (or other) compression and re-compression processes. When we had analog distribution chains and even early uncompressed digital systems, these lip sync problems were rare. Today they seem to be the norm!

Once again, I do not watch anything broadcasted over tv as I do not have cable. Everything I watch is either on disc, streamed, or downloaded.
post #8 of 26
Broadcast tv doesn't necessarily mean cable, it can still be over the air and can make a difference as the video is directly part of the tv rather than an outside source and how that's routed and being processed.

In your Pioneer's manual there should be a listing for how to find your lipsync or audio delay adjustment feature.
post #9 of 26
Streaming and internet download? I would expect these sources to be the worst in terms of lip sync. Far too many encoder/decoder incompatabilities with streaming technology.
post #10 of 26
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Glimmie View Post

Streaming and internet download? I would expect these sources to be the worst in terms of lip sync. Far too many encoder/decoder incompatabilities with streaming technology.

Except I don't have any problems with either of those. It only does it on BD discs. Not every time, but it will do it for like 5 minute spurts. And usually it is only lip movements, as sound effects will still be synched.

Of course, this receiver was not really worth the $800 I paid. There seems to be little bass out of it no matter how high I turn up my subwoover.
post #11 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Kain View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by Glimmie View Post

Streaming and internet download? I would expect these sources to be the worst in terms of lip sync. Far too many encoder/decoder incompatabilities with streaming technology.

Except I don't have any problems with either of those. It only does it on BD discs. Not every time, but it will do it for like 5 minute spurts. And usually it is only lip movements, as sound effects will still be synched.

Of course, this receiver was not really worth the $800 I paid. There seems to be little bass out of it no matter how high I turn up my subwoover.

I'd return the bd player or replace if it performs inconsistently.

The sub setup sounds off, and the settings for your avr/sub you don't specify. What are the details of settings on the sub, in your avr and what you did to setup the sub overall?
post #12 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Kain View Post

Except I don't have any problems with either of those. It only does it on BD discs. Not every time, but it will do it for like 5 minute spurts. And usually it is only lip movements, as sound effects will still be synched.
Did you try setting the TV to game mode as I suggested? If it works, I can explain why smile.gif.
post #13 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by lovinthehd View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Kain View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by Glimmie View Post

Streaming and internet download? I would expect these sources to be the worst in terms of lip sync. Far too many encoder/decoder incompatabilities with streaming technology.

Except I don't have any problems with either of those. It only does it on BD discs. Not every time, but it will do it for like 5 minute spurts. And usually it is only lip movements, as sound effects will still be synched.

Of course, this receiver was not really worth the $800 I paid. There seems to be little bass out of it no matter how high I turn up my subwoover.

I'd return the bd player or replace if it performs inconsistently.

The sub setup sounds off, and the settings for your avr/sub you don't specify. What are the details of settings on the sub, in your avr and what you did to setup the sub overall?

The symptoms given above are extremely unusual.

Typically, lip synch from BD players is off consistently unless the actual video has problems. The usual situation is that the audio leads the video which most modern receivers can correct.

Our perception of lip synch is much more critical with dialogue than sound effects. Maybe that is what is going on.

Receivers generally can provide excellent bass response unless there is a problem with the selection, room, positioning or adjustment of the speakers.
post #14 of 26
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by lovinthehd View Post

I'd return the bd player or replace if it performs inconsistently.

It is a PS3 that is 2 years old. I cannot really just replace it. In fact, it was fine until I got a new tv this past summer.
Quote:
The sub setup sounds off, and the settings for your avr/sub you don't specify. What are the details of settings on the sub, in your avr and what you did to setup the sub overall?

I plugged it in to the receiver and turned on the power button.
post #15 of 26
I have a PS3 not quite 2 years old. Never an issue. You sure it's not the source media? Did you try adjusting for delay in the AVR?

As to your sub, what sub is it and what input to the sub are you using?
post #16 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Kain View Post

It is a PS3 that is 2 years old. I cannot really just replace it. In fact, it was fine until I got a new tv this past summer.
Which is what I have been trying to tell you smile.gif. The TV has video processing. It attempts to de-interlace and inverse telecine the video to get back to 24p for movies. It does this by analyzing the picture and depending on what it sees, it changes what it does to generate a progressive frame image. And when it does this, it can change the amount of time it takes for the video to reach the screen. Now, it is not supposed to be broken this way but sadly, that is the nature of the animal sometimes. Mistakes in how the video is encoded causes this problem to show up on some titles and some parts of a title and not others.

Try a couple of things:

1. Set PS3 to 1080p24. Connect it directly to the TV first, bypassing the AVR. Play the part that has the problem and see if it is still there. If it is not, then try it through the AVR as that box also attempts to screw around with the video. If it is still there try #2 below

2. Set your TV to game mode as I suggested. Game mode is designed for low latency and it likewise removes the video processing. It also screws up the picture so you don't want to use it permanently but for now, will produce a new data point on what could be wrong.

If you are unwilling to try things as suggested please say so and I will go ahead and try to confuse someone else and not you. biggrin.gif
post #17 of 26
Thread Starter 
It still does it occasionally, but it only does it every few movies I watch and only for a few minutes.

Amirm, I wanted to ask though, if I plug the PS3 directly into the tv, how am I going to get the best lossless audio out of my receiver? Can it still detect DTS-HD and Dolby True HD even if it is not directly plugged into the receiver?
post #18 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Kain View Post

I plugged it in to the receiver and turned on the power button.

This is probably why your bass is non existent. Im betting your receiver isnt seeing your sub, your +/- setting in the receiver is off, or some combo of the two.
post #19 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Kain View Post

Sorry if this is not the right discussion board for this question, but back in July I bought a brand new Samsung Smart TV that is 1080P 120Hz. The model number is s6100.
Anyway, no matter what I try, the dialog coming out of the center channel has a habit of looking out of synch with the lip movement, while the sound effects are fine. I thought it might have been the disc, but it has happened on nearly every movie I watch, and calibrating the tv has not fixed the issue. Does anyone know what is going on and how I fix this?

Dr. Kain, take a look at the Pioneer remote control. Perhaps you will see "lip sync", and you can make the adjustment on the fly. I would be very surprised if the receiver didn't have this. Please state what model number the receiver is.

Are you processing the audio from..."out" of the disc player...to "in" on the receiver. Some people are "out" of the TV to "in" on the receiver...(ARC/ audio return channel).
HDMI or optical/toslink hook up?
post #20 of 26
The VSX-60, one of the smaller Pioneer Elite's does in fact have "lip Sync". From my experience, this is not a problem created by the networks or the TV, but an audio delay that happens as a result of the signal traveling through components and passing from one component to another. I don't really know the real answer...LOL. We shall wait to see what the Dr's model number is.
post #21 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Espo77 View Post

The VSX-60, one of the smaller Pioneer Elite's does in fact have "lip Sync". From my experience, this is not a problem created by the networks or the TV, but an audio delay that happens as a result of the signal traveling through components and passing from one component to another. I don't really know the real answer...LOL. We shall wait to see what the Dr's model number is.

Correct even the 5x series Elites have it.

The fact is, there are MANY reason why lip sync issues can occur. For example, it is well known that Directv has lip sync issues with NBC, Nat Geo, and a few other channels. Directv hasnt come out and said it, but its a common enough discussion on their boards its considered a known issue. Then there are as you mentioned hardware issues. Which is more prevalent? Who knows. But there are many reasons for lip sunc issues.
post #22 of 26
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by blackangst View Post

This is probably why your bass is non existent. Im betting your receiver isnt seeing your sub, your +/- setting in the receiver is off, or some combo of the two.

Would that have any to do with my receiver saying Dial Norm +4 for BDs and Dial Norm -5 for DVDs?

And there is no button on my remote called Lip Synch. As for model, it is a VSX-30.

As for set up, I have TV HMDI going into the Receiver with HDMI going from the Receiver into my DVD player, BD player, and PS3.
post #23 of 26
DIalnorm has nothing to do with bass levels specifically. It is intended to allow automatic adjustment between different movies that have different average dialog levels (dialog normalization) so they all sound about the same loudness, at least in the dialog. It's metadata in the digital stream, and 4 (or -4, depending on how the particular device displays it) is basically the default value. Not always used on Dolby encodes, available but essentially never used for DTS (as I understand it).

If you have not atke nsteps to set your subwoofer's output to balance with the other speakers, it's possible the sub needs more signal from the receiver to get to the right level.

But if like many you listen well below "reference" things may sound bass shy, because of how humans' ears work. Equal loudness curves show that (very, very roughly) if you turn a movie down by 6 dB, the bass will sound like it's been turned down by more like 12 dB, because our ears are less sensitive to bass . . . . Some folks use a "house curve" (bass boost) to deal with this, some rely on software solutions in their receivers, and others just live with it (like pertty much everybody did until maybe 10 years ago or so). The old-fashioned "loudness" controls on some stereo devices are intended to get at this issue, too . . .
post #24 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Kain View Post

Would that have any to do with my receiver saying Dial Norm +4 for BDs and Dial Norm -5 for DVDs?
And there is no button on my remote called Lip Synch. As for model, it is a VSX-30.
As for set up, I have TV HMDI going into the Receiver with HDMI going from the Receiver into my DVD player, BD player, and PS3.

The VSX-30 has a "10 frame delay" lip sync...whatever that means...it will in fact allow you to make this adjustment. Do you have "monitor out" from the rear of the receiver connected to the TV so that you can view the on screen menu?
post #25 of 26
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Espo77 View Post

The VSX-30 has a "10 frame delay" lip sync...whatever that means...it will in fact allow you to make this adjustment. Do you have "monitor out" from the rear of the receiver connected to the TV so that you can view the on screen menu?

Yes, I'm able to see the menu on the tv screen. That is how I test the speakers and sub to make sure they are plugged in.

BTW, I guess I should clarify what I mean by no bass. When I first moved into my new apartment and used Batman Begins as my test, I had this nice bass sound from every little thing in the movie. It sounded very rich. When I go to watch the movie now, I don't get anything like that outside of the parts with explosions and stuff. Hell, I just watched the first 3 Harry Potter movies and outside of a few specific scenes, it seemed like nothing was coming out of my sub.
post #26 of 26
Um.....hey Doc, what happened to the lip sync issue?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Audio theory, Setup and Chat
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Audio theory, Setup and Chat › Is there a reason why audio looks out of synch on my new TV?