or Connect
AVS › AVS Forum › Blu-ray & HD DVD › Blu-ray Software › The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey - Page 12

post #331 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by RWetmore View Post

Does anyone know of the extended cut of the movie will be split over 2 disks?

It would appear so, though they could easily fit the film on a single BD-50. I'll be interested in seeing the bitrate analysis and breakdown so that we can determine if they gave it a healthy bitrate or if they just broke it up between two discs to keep it in line with the LOTR films.
post #332 of 357
It's the same as with the theatrical cut - the 3D version is split into two discs, while 2D version is on single disc.
post #333 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by Johnny Vertigo View Post

It's the same as with the theatrical cut - the 3D version is split into two discs, while 2D version is on single disc.

That's somewhat disappointing, as the bit rate on the theatrical release was quite low (only around 20 mbps). Though it seems there was plenty space for a much higher video bit rate. Not sure what the deal was there.
post #334 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by RWetmore View Post

That's somewhat disappointing, as the bit rate on the theatrical release was quite low (only around 20 mbps).
Well, that's typical for most Warner releases, right?
post #335 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by RWetmore View Post

Does anyone know of the extended cut of the movie will be split over 2 disks?

Since it's coming from a studio not known for using high bitrates even when they would help, I would say... no.
post #336 of 357
So, does anyone know if this new Extended edition actually has good LFE? Or is it exactly like the theatrical blu-ray?
post #337 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by XxDeadlyxX View Post

So, does anyone know if this new Extended edition actually has good LFE? Or is it exactly like the theatrical blu-ray?

From the The New Master List of Bass in Movies with Frequency Charts thread:

adAoaGg.gif
post #338 of 357
Wow, that is quite a difference in the low end!
post #339 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by desertdome View Post

From the The New Master List of Bass in Movies with Frequency Charts thread:

adAoaGg.gif

So where is the trade in program for those of us (who care) who got screwed out of the low end on the first release? mad.gif
post #340 of 357
after very disappointing theatrical/extended lotr releases, i've resigned myself to less than stellar/non-purchase quality
br tranfers from jackson/warner.
post #341 of 357
I cancelled my EE pre-order. As much as I want this, I can't bring myself to pay $39.99 (3D version) for one movie. I'll eventually get it, but its going to have to be on a sale of some sort. Am I the only one that thinks they priced this insane?
post #342 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by jruser View Post

I cancelled my EE pre-order. As much as I want this, I can't bring myself to pay $39.99 (3D version) for one movie. I'll eventually get it, but its going to have to be on a sale of some sort. Am I the only one that thinks they priced this insane?

It will probably go down to $29.99 for the holidays, right before or just after the next film hits in December.
post #343 of 357
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by jruser View Post

I cancelled my EE pre-order. As much as I want this, I can't bring myself to pay $39.99 (3D version) for one movie. I'll eventually get it, but its going to have to be on a sale of some sort. Am I the only one that thinks they priced this insane?

You get 9 hours of appendices.9 hours.

As LexInVA mentioned the price will go down without a doubt. But as usual, consider what you're buying: a 3D movie, a 2D movie and an insane amount of extras. I agree it's not cheap, but it's way more than just a movie in 3D.
post #344 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by Morpheo View Post

You get 9 hours of appendices.9 hours..
9 hours of appendices + 3 hours commentary. If only every big movie (Avengers, Man of Steel) got this type of extras...
post #345 of 357
So the extended edition is only 13 minutes longer? I don't have the regular edition. Will it be worth it to get the extended?
post #346 of 357
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by tienvg View Post

So the extended edition is only 13 minutes longer? I don't have the regular edition. Will it be worth it to get the extended?

It's really not surprising that the Hobbit EE is actually much shorter by comparison than any of the LOTR EEs, when we consider the original novel from which it's being adapted. That said, I only speak for myself, but if I hadn't already bought the regular version, I would go without an hesitation for the EE. I don't think 13 minutes can affect the overall film that much but you still get the original movie with 13 minutes of bonus footage wink.gif …and as we already said above, an indecent amount of extra material.

I'm getting it too (although I have the regular version) so I'll have all the extended editions from both trilogies. Maybe for The Desolation of Smaug I'll wait for the EE before purchasing (and I don't care for 3D so I'm going with the 2D versions).
Edited by Morpheo - 11/3/13 at 2:28pm
post #347 of 357
If anything, the director's cut should have trimmed a lot of the fat (including the entire Radagast sequence). Unlike LOTR and even the EE's, The Hobbit felt bloated in its theatrical cut (like Jackson's version of King Kong). I don't know if I could take even 30 seconds of extra footage. Now granted, The Desolation of Smaug, at least in the trailers, looks a damn sight better than the first part.
post #348 of 357
post #349 of 357
Does the best buy extended 3d steelbook exclusive come with the 2D version also? It's hard to tell on their website.

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/hobbit-an-unexpected-journey-blu-ray-3d/2450018.p?id=2762149&skuId=2450018#tab=overview
post #350 of 357
No, it does not include the 2D disc; which also means no audio commentary.

Best Regards
KvE
post #351 of 357
Best Buy has $25 for the 2D extended and $60 for the 3D extended. Blah! There's also a re-release of the theatrical cut coming at the end of the month, probably with some sort of movie money/ticket discount thing.
post #352 of 357
Walmart has the 2D extended for $20.
post #353 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by jruser View Post

I cancelled my EE pre-order. As much as I want this, I can't bring myself to pay $39.99 (3D version) for one movie. I'll eventually get it, but its going to have to be on a sale of some sort. Am I the only one that thinks they priced this insane?

I'm with you on this one. I cannot justify $40 for one movie, regardless of the amount of extras.

Quote:
Originally Posted by LexInVA View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by jruser View Post

I cancelled my EE pre-order. As much as I want this, I can't bring myself to pay $39.99 (3D version) for one movie. I'll eventually get it, but its going to have to be on a sale of some sort. Am I the only one that thinks they priced this insane?

It will probably go down to $29.99 for the holidays, right before or just after the next film hits in December.

I'll wait for a $29.99 price or the eventual trilogy boxset. I wants the 3D version...
post #354 of 357
If the 2D version wasn't $20 at Wal-Mart, I would've passed on it. To be honest, I got it mainly for the extras. As an aspiring filmmaker, I love watching that stuff. Besides, I do plan to watch the EE before I go see The Desolution of Smaug in December.
post #355 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by Big Brad View Post

If the 2D version wasn't $20 at Wal-Mart, I would've passed on it. To be honest, I got it mainly for the extras. As an aspiring filmmaker, I love watching that stuff. Besides, I do plan to watch the EE before I go see The Desolution of Smaug in December.

i'm curious if the $20 Walmart version has all the extras. according to some online sources, the "walmart exclusive" dvd version has 2 dvd's instead of 5, so it's missing many of the extras. there's speculation that the "walmart exclusive" blu ray (as it's listed on walmart.com) might be missing things as well.
post #356 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by agnathra View Post

i'm curious if the $20 Walmart version has all the extras. according to some online sources, the "walmart exclusive" dvd version has 2 dvd's instead of 5, so it's missing many of the extras. there's speculation that the "walmart exclusive" blu ray (as it's listed on walmart.com) might be missing things as well.

looks like theonering.net got confirmation about the various EE versions out there, and the walmart BD is fine (although the walmart EE DVD is incomplete):

http://www.theonering.net/torwp/2013/11/09/81977-warner-provides-information-on-hobbit-auj-extended-edition-targets-dec-1st-for-target/#

There are three products currently available at retailers nationwide:
* 5-disc Blu-ray 3D + Digital HD UltraViolet
* 3-disc Blu-ray + Digital HD UltraViolet
* 5-disc DVD + Digital UltraViolet

Please note that Target will have the Blu-ray and DVD available on December 1st.

In addition to the national product, several retailers have unique product offerings as follows:

Amazon.com
* 3-disc Blu-ray + Digital HD UltraViolet with Bilbo/Gollum Statue
* 5-disc Blu-ray 3D + Digital HD UltraViolet with Bilbo/Gollum Statue

Wal-Mart
* 2-disc DVD including Extended Edition Feature Film and Special Features “The Company of Thorin,” and “Durin’s Folk: Creating the Dwarves”

Best Buy
* 4-disc Blu-ray 3D Steelbook:
- Disc 1: Blu-ray 3D Extended Edition Feature Part
- Disc 2: Blu-ray 3D Extended Edition Feature Part 1
- Disc 3: The Appendices Part 7
- Disc 4: The Appendices Part”
post #357 of 357
Quote:
Originally Posted by tienvg View Post

Does the best buy extended 3d steelbook exclusive come with the 2D version also? It's hard to tell on their website.

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/hobbit-an-unexpected-journey-blu-ray-3d/2450018.p?id=2762149&skuId=2450018#tab=overview

It does NOT come with a 2D version which I found out after opening it up. Luckily I like steelbooks so I still wanted it but I can't watch it as I don't have a 3D TV.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Blu-ray Software
AVS › AVS Forum › Blu-ray & HD DVD › Blu-ray Software › The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey