or Connect
AVS › AVS Forum › Gaming & Content Streaming › Networking, Media Servers & Content Streaming › XBMC supports Bluray Menus - buggy as hell though
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

XBMC supports Bluray Menus - buggy as hell though

post #1 of 20
Thread Starter 
The new XBMC nightly seems to support Bluray menus. Its extremely buggy from what I can tell it works on very limited bluray menus. I tested it on my mac with the nightly build. Dave mathews bluray worked. Highschool of the dead blurays worked. I'm attempting to test some of the few hundred blurays I have.

Someone else test it and let me know if its working for you.
post #2 of 20
I am willing to test it but I have no idea how. If it works on windows and you can provide a link let me know.
Just to get my head around if we assume this works on the pc/mac will this work in xbmc media players? What about cinavia?
post #3 of 20
I'd guess this is related to the work on libbluray that VLC has been doing, they've had experimental Blu-ray menu support in their builds for a while now.

Cinavia is completely neutered as XBMC is open source software with no DRM to worry about. Arm XBMC based media players on how they handle BD menus will have to be a wait and see.
post #4 of 20
Thread Starter 
Here is a link to the nightly builds.

http://wiki.xbmc.org/index.php?title=Development_builds

I used the one for os X, but i'm sure the Windows one also has it. It won't load some menus at all, but its a great start. Can't wait for this to work perfect but that of course may take years. As i said though some menus on some movies won't even show up.
post #5 of 20
Definitely a start in the right direction. I am sure it will take time to really work out any bugs and some content may not be viewable (a license may be required for BD Live stuff I believe I have seen mentioned). I know as well the upcoming Dune is supposed to run XBMC with full BD menu support, so hopefully that means more developers are involved getting it to work properly
post #6 of 20
Awesome! I love XBMC.
post #7 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by dbone1026 View Post

Definitely a start in the right direction. I am sure it will take time to really work out any bugs and some content may not be viewable (a license may be required for BD Live stuff I believe I have seen mentioned). I know as well the upcoming Dune is supposed to run XBMC with full BD menu support, so hopefully that means more developers are involved getting it to work properly

Way back in the days of Dune 3 Base, I talked with someone who markets the Dune line in the USA and one of the first things I mentioned was it would be far better a unit if it supported XBMC. The menuing is so "raw" that it wont appeal to the average users wanting a slick media player. I have the Dune 3 Base unit with a 2 gig drive inside. The unit worked well but now it is semi-retired in favor of my Oppo Bdp 103. If Dune comes out with a player that matches somewhat the output of the Oppo and has XBMC, I'm back in the game with Dune products.

I still recommend Dune products to friends who are just starting out with digitizing their media library and those that took my advice are extremely happy with Dune products other than the menu system. One of the things I mentioned was the idea of separates which of course (probably not by my suggestion) came to be with the smart units. This was a nice move on Dune's part. Now if we have XBMC with ability to read full BD menus as well, they will have the media server killer.
post #8 of 20
I actually wanted full blu ray menu support, but with cinavia i decided to convert everything to mkv now im quite happy (a ton of work though). Do alot of people still like their menus? When I asked on the htpc area almost nobody was using full iso's or folders anymore.

I guess it would be nice to have but i really have not used menus anymore in months.

The only thing I wish they would implement is native resolution support, its ready but the creator fought with xbmc developers, and now its just sitting. I am looking to buy a new pioneer avr which includes the marvell qdeo kyoto g2 chip the same chip in oppo's new bluray players, but it wont be of much use until its implemented.

And 3d mkv's (not sbs) support would be nice to.
post #9 of 20
Thanks watchy for the link. I am extremely impressed with it. I only tried 3 or 4 blu-rays but had no problem with the menus.
I installed over teamviewer. You have to hit Alt+Enter after you launch xbmc to enter windowed mode or else you just get a black screen.
I then installed the xbmc remote app on my iphone and used that to control everything. After the scraping was done (via teamviewer) the remote worked flawlessly displaying movies sorted by date with the year and score next to them including cover art etc.
Hit play and away it goes, can select subtitles, etc. but the button layout is clumsy.
I will see if I can make it select the right resolution..
In terms of scraping/ui this is about a 1000 years ahead of my crappy ntv550.
I did not test hd audio as I was not using the onboard audio (my standalone graphics doesn't support it).
I also tested Blu-ray 1:1 folder rips, no dvds, etc.
If anyone has any questions let me know or better yet install it yourself, doesn't take more than a couple of minutes to have it up and running.
I am retyping the link by watchy:
http://wiki.xbmc.org/index.php?title=Development_builds
and this is what the remote app look like:
http://wiki.xbmc.org/index.php?title=Official_XBMC_Remote/iOS
post #10 of 20
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by 720p View Post

Thanks watchy for the link. I am extremely impressed with it. I only tried 3 or 4 blu-rays but had no problem with the menus.
I installed over teamviewer. You have to hit Alt+Enter after you launch xbmc to enter windowed mode or else you just get a black screen.
I then installed the xbmc remote app on my iphone and used that to control everything. After the scraping was done (via teamviewer) the remote worked flawlessly displaying movies sorted by date with the year and score next to them including cover art etc.
Hit play and away it goes, can select subtitles, etc. but the button layout is clumsy.
I will see if I can make it select the right resolution..
In terms of scraping/ui this is about a 1000 years ahead of my crappy ntv550.
I did not test hd audio as I was not using the onboard audio (my standalone graphics doesn't support it).
I also tested Blu-ray 1:1 folder rips, no dvds, etc.
If anyone has any questions let me know or better yet install it yourself, doesn't take more than a couple of minutes to have it up and running.
I am retyping the link by watchy:
http://wiki.xbmc.org/index.php?title=Development_builds
and this is what the remote app look like:
http://wiki.xbmc.org/index.php?title=Official_XBMC_Remote/iOS

If your looking for a dedicated box to run XBMC on, I suggest a Intel NUC. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16856102002
It can bitstream audio to an AVR and play full Bluray images perfectly. I put a 120gb SSD in mine along with 8gigs of ram and its perfect. Once bluray menus get better i'll be using this instead of a mix of my Dune and this for everything.
post #11 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by watchy View Post

If your looking for a dedicated box to run XBMC on, I suggest a Intel NUC. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16856102002
It can bitstream audio to an AVR and play full Bluray images perfectly. I put a 120gb SSD in mine along with 8gigs of ram and its perfect. Once bluray menus get better i'll be using this instead of a mix of my Dune and this for everything.

What SSD did you use, and what RAM? How does it handle full BR rips? What about 3D Blu-Ray ISOs, if you've done them?
post #12 of 20
Thread Starter 
I'm using 120gig Muskin. Seems to work great. I got 8gig Crucial Sodimms. I just got a 3D Tv but I havent tested it. I got a lazy eye and can't see 3d so it never was very important.

It handles full bluray rips perfect.
post #13 of 20
I dont know why people are saying it has menu support. I just threw something like 10 blu-rays at it with menus that work fine on my neotv 550, and the only one that had any sort of menu support (i.e. for all of them it detected the menu and let me choose it, but generally just skipped to the feature). And for the one that it did work, it only gave the initial "Disney language" choice menu, and then when it went to previews, I lost the picture (though it was displaying subtitles).

I'd say that menu support isn't close to being viable. I wish it was, if/when xbmc gets good blu-ray menu support it will make android media center boxes somewhat future proof (as long as they have the proper oomph)
post #14 of 20
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by thetoad View Post

I dont know why people are saying it has menu support. I just threw something like 10 blu-rays at it with menus that work fine on my neotv 550, and the only one that had any sort of menu support (i.e. for all of them it detected the menu and let me choose it, but generally just skipped to the feature). And for the one that it did work, it only gave the initial "Disney language" choice menu, and then when it went to previews, I lost the picture (though it was displaying subtitles).

I'd say that menu support isn't close to being viable. I wish it was, if/when xbmc gets good blu-ray menu support it will make android media center boxes somewhat future proof (as long as they have the proper oomph)

I never said the menu support was good or even useable, but its there on some blurays and nice to know its being worked on because of all the new players no longer supporting menus.
post #15 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by watchy View Post

I never said the menu support was good or even useable, but its there on some blurays and nice to know its being worked on because of all the new players no longer supporting menus.

oh, I strongly agree with that. hence my last sentence.
post #16 of 20
So you are saying when loading a movie, even if it's saved in ISO or Folder Structure with menus, it just loads the main feature? I oftentimes think it'd be nice to keep menus, but i NEVER access them...
post #17 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by jch1 View Post

So you are saying when loading a movie, even if it's saved in ISO or Folder Structure with menus, it just loads the main feature? I oftentimes think it'd be nice to keep menus, but i NEVER access them...

It gives you a prompt, you can choose from what it thinks is the title stream, a list of streams on the disc or display menus.

Alpha 1 of XBMC 13 is now out, though the nightly builds might be more cutting edge the prompt on BD's is in this version too.
post #18 of 20
it basically acts the same as everything else based on libbluray, it loads what it thinks is the main feature. not guaranteed to be it though.
post #19 of 20
Did you try a 3D BluRay iso yet?

I'm sold on this as soon as 3D BluRay iso playback is confimed by someone....
post #20 of 20
I've always been a fan of XBMC and though I only use it with my computer monitor, I look forward to the day I can hook up a Mac Mini to my 65" plasma, play bd ISO's, get HD audio. I may just have to bite the bullet and load Linux or MS crap on my Mac to get there.

XBMC team are amazing for what they give us all. I hope some makers of media boxes will try to work with them (such as DUNE) to get XBMC working with their offerings.

In the meanwhile, I'll play around with bd offering listed here and see how things progress.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Gaming & Content Streaming › Networking, Media Servers & Content Streaming › XBMC supports Bluray Menus - buggy as hell though