AVS › AVS Forum › 3D Central › 3D Tech Talk › Best Passive 3d Projector and a couple of 3d related questions
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Best Passive 3d Projector and a couple of 3d related questions

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
Hi,

I have watched a couple of 3d movies in theatres and loved them.

Recently when i was shopping for 3d i trialed a samsung 3d tv with active shutter and had the following issues immediately:

1. I could "see" and "feel" the working of active shutter glasses i.e. "flicker"
2. I could not perceive the 3d depth of the material being presented. I changed glasses but nothing. the sales guy tried my glasses and said he can "see" 3d. but nothing for me. zilch
3. two minutes into the demo and i had a headache.

Then i tried Lg 3d and bam I could "see" the 3d.

What i experienced is it possible or the material being shown on samsung did not give me depth perception.

Also what is the best Passive 3d projector under 5000 thousand available in the market.

Thanks
Hussain
post #2 of 8
Don't count out active shutter 3D untill you have seen it in a proper enviroment, not a BB show room. Any floresent lights flashing at 60hz will mess with the glasses. As far as I know no consumer passive 3D projector is on the market. You still need two projectors and a special silver screen that does not do well for 2D. RealD in theaters just has the active shutter on the projector instead of your glasses so it still is a flickering image. Find someone around you that has an active projector in a dark theater room and I think you will change your mind on a passive system. Although a passive system for $5000 is posible and can provide the best 3D there are other things to consider. As for a TV in a living room enviroment I agree passive is the way to go most of the time
post #3 of 8
Passive 3D for projectors is still new and not mainstream. Check this thread for starters:

http://www.avsforum.com/t/1407101/official-omega-3d-passive-projection-system-thread

Also, look up BlackShark in this forum. He has been an extremely knowledgeable and helpful poster on the topic of passive 3D projection.
post #4 of 8
Quote:
Originally Posted by hussain View Post

Also what is the best Passive 3d projector under 5000 thousand available in the market.

There are none. Runco, DPI, and LG all have models but they are very expensive. Are many people interested in ~$5K passive projectors?
post #5 of 8
Thread Starter 
ok so what's the cheapest possible passive 3d projector out in the market
post #6 of 8
If you have to ask then you know its out of your price range.

If you are serious about it then DIY.
You'll need a 3D/demuxer to split to separate L and R HDMI feeds
Two projectors of the same type
Filters, either polarized or Dolby type

If you go with polarized then you need a silver screen (which tend to hotspot easily with 2D viewing) or if you go with a Dolby type then you need color correction hardware boxes

so at this point just settle for active until there is demand that pushes passive 3D projection down.

I use a Sony HW30ES with active glasses. Sure it is not perfect but if you are worried about the flickering... it's not an issue if you don't have lighting on around the screen in a darkened room. Sure I see it if I turn on my sconces and look at them or if I focus my attention to a small LED in my field of view, but the reality is flicker is not an issue in a darkened environment which is the environment the projector was designed with to begin with.
post #7 of 8
post #8 of 8
That's a neat little gizmo, that claims it can use theater glasses. Anyone here who has tried it out and willing to give some feedback?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: 3D Tech Talk
AVS › AVS Forum › 3D Central › 3D Tech Talk › Best Passive 3d Projector and a couple of 3d related questions