or Connect
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Home Theater In A Box › Energy Classic Take 5.1 without Receiver
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Energy Classic Take 5.1 without Receiver

post #1 of 19
Thread Starter 
Hello,

I am a newbie. I have LCD46C650 TV. I am fond of FullHD content so focus of my requirement is Movies, other video content.

I am thinking of connecting my TV with Energy Classic Take 5.1 or similar system. Can i connect it directly to the TV or i need a receiver in between ?

Please advice.

Best Regards
Amit
post #2 of 19
No, you'll need an avr or integrated amp with those speakers (but an avr is usually cheaper way to go for multichannel)
post #3 of 19
Thread Starter 
Hello loveinthehd

Thanks.

I just formulated 3 cases for my TV LN46C650.
.

Below are the things i am trying to achieve

1) Have 5.1 sound when playing any movie from TV ( Input source is from setup box)
2) Have 5.1 sound when playing any movie via Allshare ( input source can be any all share device on network)
3) Have 5.1 sound when playing any movie via USB

However, the manual of TV has confused me.. It appears that my TV doesnt decode 5.1 .

http://downloadcenter.samsung.com/content/UM/201009/20100906130822796/[LC650-ZA]BN68-02541A-04Eng.pdf




iven this information, what can i put in between the TV and Speaker so that i can get 5.1 sound for all the 3 cases i mentioned ?
G
please advice.

Thanks
Amit
post #4 of 19
TVs are stereo devices. So, no they don't decode except from their own internal tuners or Smart TV apps. As noted in the other thread where you posted the same issue, you need a receiver. The set top box would be plugged into the receiver for audio, not to the TV. Most sets do not pass encoded multichannel audio from external devices. I doubt you'll have much luck getting 5.1 in the other two scenarios if you use the TV as the acquisition device. You may have better luck getting a receiver with networking and a USB input.
post #5 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by airan View Post

Hello loveinthehd

Thanks.

I just formulated 3 cases for my TV LN46C650.
.

Below are the things i am trying to achieve

1) Have 5.1 sound when playing any movie from TV ( Input source is from setup box)
2) Have 5.1 sound when playing any movie via Allshare ( input source can be any all share device on network)
3) Have 5.1 sound when playing any movie via USB

However, the manual of TV has confused me.. It appears that my TV doesnt decode 5.1 .

http://downloadcenter.samsung.com/content/UM/201009/20100906130822796/[LC650-ZA]BN68-02541A-04Eng.pdf




iven this information, what can i put in between the TV and Speaker so that i can get 5.1 sound for all the 3 cases i mentioned ?
G
please advice.

Thanks
Amit

Like Bislander says, you would plug your set top box (assuming it has 5.1 capability of course) into the avr tthen to the tv from the avr as most TVs will only output multichannel through an optical output to your avr and even then often only for OTA (over the air broadcast) content. Allshare is just another brand name for HDMI-CEC, and not all brands play together well, what source would you have that has 5.1 content? USB into the tv may not play back other than in 2.0. Stop thinking about your tv as the central unit and start thinking about an avr as being the central unit. On a computer you wouldn't look to route every peripheral through a monitor directly would you?
post #6 of 19
Thread Starter 
Thanks Guys,

So one thing is clear .>I need a receiver. Can you suggest something ~$250 which works like

(1) a good receiver
(2) has networking support specially for DLNA
(3) has USB Plug and play for all popular audio and video formats
post #7 of 19
Saw in another thread the Pioneer 1022 on sale at Amazon for that price. http://www.amazon.com/Pioneer-VSX-1022-K-7-Channel-Receiver-Network/dp/B007O5ATC8 You'll have to determine the extent of the usb capabilities, not sure what they are.
post #8 of 19
Thread Starter 
Thanks lovinthehd,

I checked and it doesn't play USB videos. Only Audio. God, i dont want to add a player just when my TV can play every damm content via USB.

I will do more research on

1) Can TV give 5.1 out while playing video via USB
2) Can TV give 5.1 out while playing video via DLNA.

If above 2 are true, then i can go with any receiver.

Thanks.
post #9 of 19
Thread Starter 
Some more update.

I tried the following

1) Play 5.1 sound movie via USB on my TV. When i go to settings -->Sound Settings --> Bottom of Menu --> SPDIF Audio Output Format --> Default is PCM. Click on Left arrow and it changes to 'Dolby Digital' (5.1 ch)

2) Same for playing movie with 5.1 over DLNA.

Does it implies that TV can output 5.1 sound when playing via USB and DLNA ?.

Thanks
Edited by airan - 3/27/13 at 5:58am
post #10 of 19
Not necessarily. All TVs can do DD when the source is their own internal tuners or apps they acquire themselves. But, that doesn't mean they can pass through DD or DTS from external devices. Most cannot. If the manual doesn't make that clear, and it may not, try contacting customer support for your TV or posting the question in the Display forum.
post #11 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by airan View Post

(3) has USB Plug and play for all popular audio and video formats

I have never seen a receiver that decodes video, doesn't mean it doesn't exsist but don't hold your breath.

It seems like you have a work around with your TV pushing DD or DTS when using DLNA as a source...

This is exactly why I think TVs should have stayed dumb.
post #12 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by airan View Post

Some more update.

I tried the following

1) Play 5.1 sound movie via USB on my TV. When i go to settings -->Sound Settings --> Bottom of Menu --> SPDIF Audio Output Format --> Default is PCM. Click on Left arrow and it changes to 'Dolby Digital' (5.1 ch)

2) Same for playing movie with 5.1 over DLNA.

Does it implies that TV can output 5.1 sound when playing via USB and DLNA ?.

Thanks

That's what it implies, doesn't the manual confirm?
post #13 of 19
Thread Starter 
To Lovinthehd : Manual is silent on this part. Manual only talks about Tuner and HDMI INPUT.

Anyways, GOOD NEWS ..I confirmed with a buddy (very very trusted source). TV Tuner Decoding, USB decoding and streaming decoding ( Exclude Samsung Apps like Hulu or Netflix) pass via same decoder. Apps can be doing their own magic ..so he couldnt comment about Apps part.

in Nutshell, if the content has DD, the SPDIF OUT menu option will allow to select DOLBY..and SPDIF will give DD output.

Great ..Saves me from buying another PLAYER BOX

Thanks a lot guys.
post #14 of 19
Quote:
in Nutshell, if the content has DD, the SPDIF OUT menu option will allow to select DOLBY and SPDIF will give DD output.

I think the jury is still out on that assumption. I can believe tuner and streaming can do DD 5.1 but not sure about USB.

I'm sure you'll confirm once you get your new receiver connected.
post #15 of 19
Recently bought Energy Take 5.1 and Marantz NR1403.
Fanatastic setup used in my home office.
Sounds as good as my larger Klipsch/Marantz systems.
Highly recommend Marantz AVR's
post #16 of 19
Thread Starter 
Out of curiosity.. does it have any power source ?

I am thinking of buying it from US ..but the voltage in US is 110V but here it is 220V.

Please advice.
post #17 of 19
speakers translate just fine as they are passive. most receivers have a 220v 110v switch
post #18 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by airan View Post

Out of curiosity.. does it have any power source ?

I am thinking of buying it from US ..but the voltage in US is 110V but here it is 220V.

Please advice.

The Take sub I have is 120V (the normal US voltage), and no switch for 220.
post #19 of 19
Thread Starter 
Thanks guys ..That means i can safely buy speakers from US and Sub Woofer from here only smile.gif..

Still will save me at least $300
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Home Theater In A Box
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Home Theater In A Box › Energy Classic Take 5.1 without Receiver