or Connect
AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Home Theater Computers › New media server... what hdd?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

New media server... what hdd?

post #1 of 14
Thread Starter 
Building a new PC that will function as both a PC and a media server. It will be based on a Z87 and i7 4770 and will use SSDs for OS and applications such as photoshop, videoredo, makemkv, EAC, handbrake, etc.
It also will be a media server for use over gigabyte LAN with boxeebox, dune and roku (plex). I am wondering which hdd's to use for this second purpose. In the past I have used WD greens w/o any problems really. Just wondering if another drive might be more suitable.

I know WD recommends the reds for NAS but would they also be preferred for use in a media server. Or does it matter... would any drive be fine?
post #2 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stephen Ash View Post

Building a new PC that will function as both a PC and a media server. It will be based on a Z87 and i7 4770 and will use SSDs for OS and applications such as photoshop, videoredo, makemkv, EAC, handbrake, etc.
It also will be a media server for use over gigabyte LAN with boxeebox, dune and roku (plex). I am wondering which hdd's to use for this second purpose. In the past I have used WD greens w/o any problems really. Just wondering if another drive might be more suitable.

I know WD recommends the reds for NAS but would they also be preferred for use in a media server. Or does it matter... would any drive be fine?

Go with the best price you can find. Don't forget external drives, the prices can be better than bare drives and you can gut them so you can install the hard drive in your server.
post #3 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by robnix View Post

Go with the best price you can find. Don't forget external drives, the prices can be better than bare drives and you can gut them so you can install the hard drive in your server.

Don't you void the warranty by doing this though?
post #4 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by lockdown571 View Post

Don't you void the warranty by doing this though?

I recently had a hard drive that I had gutted from an external go bad and they actually had me send it back to them outside of the case. They didn't want the case, power supply or anything at all.

The best part? They sent me an entirely new external hard drive with case and power supply.

So I think it varies but if you get a case that you can crack open easily just save it in case you need it later to send it back.
post #5 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stephen Ash View Post


I know WD recommends the reds for NAS but would they also be preferred for use in a media server. Or does it matter... would any drive be fine?

Green is also good for your purposes (unless you are going with hardware RAID). Many people disable head parking for better performance and longevity, however (how: create a bootable USB flash drive, copy WDIDLE3.exe there, boot in DOS, type in "wdidle3 /d", hit Enter, disconnect power, reconnect it. That's it). With Red, this is disabled by default.
Edited by renethx - 7/23/13 at 10:17pm
post #6 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by assassin View Post

I recently had a hard drive that I had gutted from an external go bad and they actually had me send it back to them outside of the case. They didn't want the case, power supply or anything at all.

The best part? They sent me an entirely new external hard drive with case and power supply.

So I think it varies but if you get a case that you can crack open easily just save it in case you need it later to send it back.

I've RMA'd a few WD Greens that I'd pulled from cases as bare drives. No mention during the process of the case at all.
post #7 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by assassin View Post

I recently had a hard drive that I had gutted from an external go bad and they actually had me send it back to them outside of the case. They didn't want the case, power supply or anything at all.

The best part? They sent me an entirely new external hard drive with case and power supply.

So I think it varies but if you get a case that you can crack open easily just save it in case you need it later to send it back.

+1. I've done rma with Hitachi and WD from externals I've cracked open.
post #8 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stephen Ash View Post

Building a new PC that will function as both a PC and a media server. It will be based on a Z87 and i7 4770 and will use SSDs for OS and applications such as photoshop, videoredo, makemkv, EAC, handbrake, etc.
It also will be a media server for use over gigabyte LAN with boxeebox, dune and roku (plex). I am wondering which hdd's to use for this second purpose. In the past I have used WD greens w/o any problems really. Just wondering if another drive might be more suitable.

I know WD recommends the reds for NAS but would they also be preferred for use in a media server. Or does it matter... would any drive be fine?

If your not running hardware RAID any drive can work.

What kind of performance do you want ? Is it important ? If not - green or RED are ok.

A 4TB Seagate is often cheaper per TB, 5900rpm, and quite a bit faster than WD 5400rpm drives. It uses less energy too.

I use the Seagate 7200.14 3TB in my server. Huge difference and improvements from WD green drives I replaced. I will never buy 5400 rpm drives again. They are not worth it IMO.

I used to be a WD fanboy for years using only WD products but these days I prefer modern Seagates and Hitachis for a variety of reasons.

Do you have a strong brand preference for WD ? Or are you willing to look at better performing drives from other MFG at cheaper prices ? That's really the big question.

If you don't care about maxing out your LAN network connection speed you can ignore me. If you want to maximize your performance and minimize your costs I'd check out some other options. RED or GREEN will create a bottleneck in your speed below you LAN capability while costing more. There is no difference in noise or heat compared to a 4TB Seagate either. The Seagate uses less power and has 1TB more capacity too.
post #9 of 14
Put your programs on the ssd. Put everything else on your hard drives (as you started in your original post). For this application any hard drive will work well for playback and storage so I would grab the best deal per gb that you can find.
post #10 of 14
What HD really depends on your server. What I mean is how many HD's can fit in your server? If you can only fit 10 or so drives I would be looking at 4TB only if you have more room or don't care about adding external enclosures then go straight $ /tb. I had recently upgraded my server from 10 drive case to the Norco 4224 and so I was only considering 4TB before but man does your disk space grow like a weed lol Good luck with whatever you decide.

-RobNY
post #11 of 14
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mfusick View Post

If your not running hardware RAID any drive can work.

What kind of performance do you want ? Is it important ? If not - green or RED are ok.

A 4TB Seagate is often cheaper per TB, 5900rpm, and quite a bit faster than WD 5400rpm drives. It uses less energy too.

I use the Seagate 7200.14 3TB in my server. Huge difference and improvements from WD green drives I replaced. I will never buy 5400 rpm drives again. They are not worth it IMO.

I used to be a WD fanboy for years using only WD products but these days I prefer modern Seagates and Hitachis for a variety of reasons.

Do you have a strong brand preference for WD ? Or are you willing to look at better performing drives from other MFG at cheaper prices ? That's really the big question.

If you don't care about maxing out your LAN network connection speed you can ignore me. If you want to maximize your performance and minimize your costs I'd check out some other options. RED or GREEN will create a bottleneck in your speed below you LAN capability while costing more. There is no difference in noise or heat compared to a 4TB Seagate either. The Seagate uses less power and has 1TB more capacity too.

No RAID.

Yes... I like performance... but favor reliability.

No preference for brand. I've used them all.
post #12 of 14
Which 2-4 TB drive operates at the lowest heat? I have a energy hogging, space heating 2 TB WD Black but I plan on building a new SFF PC that will serve as my download center, music player and organizer, and blu ray ripper. That WD Black won't do so I need something new.

EDIT: Nvm, I found this benchmark.
Edited by JackDiesel14 - 7/24/13 at 6:36pm
post #13 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stephen Ash View Post

No RAID.

Yes... I like performance... but favor reliability.

No preference for brand. I've used them all.

Seagate for the win.
post #14 of 14
Samsung drives (and a time machine to go back and buy them all up).

Seriously, you are getting fine advice here from other folks - for media server purposes just buy the best $/TB drive from any major vendor if you are not using hardware raid.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Home Theater Computers
AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Home Theater Computers › New media server... what hdd?