Quote:
Originally posted by illumin8
...Overall, SD picture quality is slightly worse than watching on a non-HD digital cable box.
The A/D/A conversions in the STB probably degrade the PQ.
Other AVS Forum members have reported getting better picture quality on the analog channel tier by splitting the cable and running a leg of it to your TV, and using the TV's tuner for the analog tier. Of course then you lose the wonderful ad-filled guide.....
... The two local stations (ABC(?) affiliate and KTHV CBS affiliate) seem to be pass-through of the exact same signal you get from an OTA receiver. Of course KTHV is probably the best quality. I've always been very impressed with the HD programming on CBS.
ABC (as well as ESPN & eventually FOX) is 720p and CBS is 1080i. If your STB must convert 720p to 1080i for your set, there's may be some PQ lost in that conversion, too.
... ESPN-HD is really lousy. They are simply stretching SD material to a HD resolution (not sure if they're using 1080i, 720p, or 480p). Eventually they may broadcast some games in HD...
ESPN is 720p and has been broadcasting some games in HD. But they are stretching all 4:3 material to 16:9, which is a total joke. They're even stretching commercials during true HD game broadcasts. The true HD is rare for ESPN so far, but they will increase programming a lot as time goes on. The price may go up, too. Comcast told me ESPN-hd was a "free preview" right now. Others in the forum have been told the same thing.
...If you're already receiving digital cable it's especially a good deal because it won't cost you anything more per-month to swap your existing digital box for a Motorola 5100. If you're not getting digital cable there is a $5 a month box rental fee.
These are not the prices I was given. I was also told if I had cable, I could just come in, pickup the STB, and do a self-install. Just like DirecTV, if I called comcast back and got a different CSR, I would probably be told a different story.
I was told if you already had digital cable, the HD box was another $5 a month (in addition to the digital tier charge and additional STB charges for each TV). And if you only had analog cable and wanted to add the box just for High Def channels, the HD box was $10 more per month.
For 1 HD box, 2 additional SD boxes and the digital tier, comcast quoted me $32 a month more than D* charges, for less programming than I'm currently getting. That difference would pay for my D* system in less than 18 months.
Originally posted by illumin8
...Overall, SD picture quality is slightly worse than watching on a non-HD digital cable box.
The A/D/A conversions in the STB probably degrade the PQ.
Other AVS Forum members have reported getting better picture quality on the analog channel tier by splitting the cable and running a leg of it to your TV, and using the TV's tuner for the analog tier. Of course then you lose the wonderful ad-filled guide.....
... The two local stations (ABC(?) affiliate and KTHV CBS affiliate) seem to be pass-through of the exact same signal you get from an OTA receiver. Of course KTHV is probably the best quality. I've always been very impressed with the HD programming on CBS.
ABC (as well as ESPN & eventually FOX) is 720p and CBS is 1080i. If your STB must convert 720p to 1080i for your set, there's may be some PQ lost in that conversion, too.
... ESPN-HD is really lousy. They are simply stretching SD material to a HD resolution (not sure if they're using 1080i, 720p, or 480p). Eventually they may broadcast some games in HD...
ESPN is 720p and has been broadcasting some games in HD. But they are stretching all 4:3 material to 16:9, which is a total joke. They're even stretching commercials during true HD game broadcasts. The true HD is rare for ESPN so far, but they will increase programming a lot as time goes on. The price may go up, too. Comcast told me ESPN-hd was a "free preview" right now. Others in the forum have been told the same thing.
...If you're already receiving digital cable it's especially a good deal because it won't cost you anything more per-month to swap your existing digital box for a Motorola 5100. If you're not getting digital cable there is a $5 a month box rental fee.
These are not the prices I was given. I was also told if I had cable, I could just come in, pickup the STB, and do a self-install. Just like DirecTV, if I called comcast back and got a different CSR, I would probably be told a different story.
I was told if you already had digital cable, the HD box was another $5 a month (in addition to the digital tier charge and additional STB charges for each TV). And if you only had analog cable and wanted to add the box just for High Def channels, the HD box was $10 more per month.
For 1 HD box, 2 additional SD boxes and the digital tier, comcast quoted me $32 a month more than D* charges, for less programming than I'm currently getting. That difference would pay for my D* system in less than 18 months.


















