The problem I find with both of these discs on the Floyd material is missing the other partner.
Roger did a great job on tour with the Floyd tunes - when people heard we was not going to do just his solo material, ticket sales picked up and the tour was a bigger success than it might have been otherwise.
But on every guitar solo, and a couple of vocal parts, I yearned for David Gilmore.
The Gilmore video and the PF video "Pulse" suffer from the reverse - I miss Rogers voacals and bass lines.
Live 8 rectifies this to a degree, and the overdubs are apprciated, as is James Guthrie's mix. I ran out of room on my ReplayTV so I deleted the original Live 8 MTV re-broadcast once the DVDs came out. I don't miss it.