Quote:
Originally Posted by B.H. 
Even as HD cameras become common in field reporting, there will still be times when file footage that was shot in 4:3 may be used.
The networks have been flanking 4:3 video presented during ther newcast (e.g. - Nightly News) with graphic backgrounds for some time - at least for as long as I've had my HDTV (about 2-1/2 years). I believe The Y-town stations should be able to follow with same style for their local newcasts, now in HD, but I wouldn't expect them to be responsible for the network feeds of 4:3 video.
Yet, outside of the national newscasts, perhaps there isn't a sufficient volume of 4:3 video on network feeds for the networks, themselves, to bother with it. Seems like it's mostly commercials that appear in 4:3, but they also seem to be fewer, as we move forward in time.
WRT to stretching a 4:3 image to fill a 16:9 screen, I wasn't saying the stations are doing that (and did not know that any of them ever did), but I'm not sure if all HDTV sets allow the user to turn off automatic picture formatting (stretching) as my set does. If not, frequently going from 16:9 to stretched 4:3 video and back would be very annoying - at least to me.

Even as HD cameras become common in field reporting, there will still be times when file footage that was shot in 4:3 may be used.
The networks have been flanking 4:3 video presented during ther newcast (e.g. - Nightly News) with graphic backgrounds for some time - at least for as long as I've had my HDTV (about 2-1/2 years). I believe The Y-town stations should be able to follow with same style for their local newcasts, now in HD, but I wouldn't expect them to be responsible for the network feeds of 4:3 video.
Yet, outside of the national newscasts, perhaps there isn't a sufficient volume of 4:3 video on network feeds for the networks, themselves, to bother with it. Seems like it's mostly commercials that appear in 4:3, but they also seem to be fewer, as we move forward in time.
WRT to stretching a 4:3 image to fill a 16:9 screen, I wasn't saying the stations are doing that (and did not know that any of them ever did), but I'm not sure if all HDTV sets allow the user to turn off automatic picture formatting (stretching) as my set does. If not, frequently going from 16:9 to stretched 4:3 video and back would be very annoying - at least to me.
Agreed 100%. I'm not talking about flanking 4:3 network feeds or commercials. I don't think I've ever seen anybody do that, except syndicated shows that flank their own commercials during their show. I'm talking about how the Cleveland stations flank 4:3 file footage during newscasts, the national newscasts flank file footage, but WKBN/WYTV is not. As I said before, they were flanking the space left behind their newscasts when they ran election results, and that's what I'd like to see them do behind their 4:3 footage during the newscast.








I have a HDTV set (Pioneer) connected via OTA antenna, and I've never seen any "stretching", aside from when a station presents something stretched. But they don't do that anymore. I don't think my TV has that setting.









