Tivo2Go - How does it compare?  

I don't know where you saw the 2 gigs in 10-15 minutes. It's more like a gig an hour. That's one of the many complaints about TTG, it's slow transferring files. Some contend it's the DRM that slows it down, but whatever it is, it's not nearly as fast as a Replay can tranfer files.

The DRM is another problem. The files are unique to the machine, and can be traced back to that machine. They also require a password each time the file is played, and only work with WMP10. Like most forms of encryption, it can be cracked. You don't have to deal with any of this with Replay files.

A third problem is the only supported authoring software is Sonic's, which sucks. Unless you 'clean' these files of the DRM, your stuck with this, and have to shell out $50 for the 'privilege.

Finally, assuming you have endured the slow transfers and cracked the DRM, you're still stuck with a file that is NOT DVD compliant. This means each file has to be transcoded, a long and quality reducing process. The Replay's medium quality files are compliant, and require *no* transcoding of the video if you use the right software.

And forget about anything even close to DVArchive for Tivo. It's just not possible for a myriad of reasons, one being the Tivos sub-par networking that doesn't support true streaming of video.

*you must be on a wireless network, because I can download a 1 hour med. show in about 20 minutes on a wired network.