AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › Digital Projectors - Under $3,000 USD MSRP › PLV-Z4 Tweak Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

PLV-Z4 Tweak Thread - Page 2

post #31 of 1081
Thread Starter 
Okay, messed around with this for a while, have a close solution.

90% of the EE applied on the Z4 around text etc is because of the Transient Enhancement in the advanced menu.

This defaults to setting L1 when you dial in the preset, which provides a huge jump in EE, no matter how you set the sharpness.

Ofcourse every time you set a preset initially this is on by default!

Turn if off set sharpness to -6 and things are a lot better. Not absolutely 110% perfect but down to a level that is tiny and I would deem not effecting the picture.

The last miniscule bit must be a bit of processing but it really is dead and buried now as far as I'm concerned.
post #32 of 1081
Thread Starter 
Spent way too many hours on this thing last night ...

Everything seems a compromise, you get a better black level - you see the iris moving, you get better contrast - your gamma is odd.

I was starting to get really annoyed last night as I began to play with the LIVING setting once again and I discoverd a couple of things.

1) The bulb has dimmed quite a lot now.

2) Reading D65 onto the spyder produced odd results that were too yellow - maybe an effect of the DI.

Cutting a long story short, I've come up with a nice round of settings based on LIVING.

The only prerequisite seems to be with the Z4 to get a good black level and reasonable contrast you must take the manual Iris down somewhere to -50 or so and the picture is quite dim when used in conjunction with the AUTO lamp iris, but if you have the manual Iris higher say -25 the picture is just too washed out.

D65 LIVING updated Settings 26/10/05

Unfiltered

Contrast Ratio ? not measured

Preset: LIVING

B: -4
C: +5
Sat: -2 to 0 (set with AVIA etc)
Tint: 0
Color temp: Low1
R: +7 (down from +9)
G: 0
B: -1
Sharpness: -6
Lamp: Low (A1,A2 adds 100-200 CRs)
Gamma: 0
Lens Iris: -50 to -40 (you will need a dark room)

Lamp Iris: AUTO
Auto Black Stretch: off
Contrast Enhancement: off
Transient: Off (DOUBLE CHECK, MAIN CAUSE OF EE!)

Gain R: +4
Gain G: +2
Gain B: -5
Offset: R -15
Offset: G -15
Offset: B -5
Gamma R,G,B 0,0,0

HDMI: L2 for pc levels using VMR, re-calibrate brightness for L1 (video levels and overlay output)

+ves Sharp in-frame contrast, black level good, Iris not so troublesome

-ves Quite a dim picture, Gamma a little odd, a bit noisy, colour balance still a bit wrong somewhere ... but getting there.


LIVING v CREATIVE CINEMA, well living produces much better in-frame contrast and a brighter peak white. CC definately has a less harsh gamma and rolls off nicer into shadows. The Iris dances about less in Living, but again you can still see it move occasionally.

The above settings are looking good, if a bit orangy-red but they are definately improved offer my initial CC settings.

There are that many things to tweak I keep messing up something so it's a bit two steps forward one step back.
post #33 of 1081
Thanks for blazing the trail ROne. I expect my Z4 hopefully early next week, and look forward to joining you
post #34 of 1081
Thanks for the info ROne. Your continued effort is much appreciated by us. Hopefully we'll be able to chime in and maybe help you out a bit when we all get our Z4's. You've made a great start though.
post #35 of 1081
ROne,

Thaks for your hard work trying to ge the bes picture from the Z4.

I realize that you are trying to get the best contrast and deepest blacks.

Did you use the Color Management screen at all to adjust the color abnormalities (too yellow) you report?

Shelly
post #36 of 1081
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by shelly View Post

ROne,

Thaks for your hard work trying to ge the bes picture from the Z4.

I realize that you are trying to get the best contrast and deepest blacks.

Did you use the Color Management screen at all to adjust the color abnormalities (too yellow) you report?

Shelly

It's looking like too much contrast really shifts the color balance.

I am messing with it it now, though color management is perhaps not the tool of choice just yet ...
post #37 of 1081
rone, you got any new settings for us?
post #38 of 1081
Thread Starter 
Yes, I will put them up tonight.
post #39 of 1081
ROne sorry if I missed this but what type screen are you running?
post #40 of 1081
Quote:
Originally Posted by ROne View Post

Yes, I will put them up tonight.

SWEET...!
post #41 of 1081
rone, i would like to hear your opinon of how the z4 compares with the z3... what do you think? is it a huge difference? worth the upgrade or not?
post #42 of 1081
Thread Starter 
Unfiltered

Contrast Ratio 1350:1

Preset: LIVING

B: -3
C: +6
Sat: +2
Tint: 0

Set your own of the above unless you are on HDMI then they should be close if you have same hardware as myself.

I am pegging SAT back again, set as per AVIA i just don't like it, because I think it changes due to lamp and iris configurations.

Color temp: Low1
R: +10
G: -1
B: -8
Sharpness: -6
Lamp: A1 (for bright image, doesn't effect black level)
Gamma: -1
Lens Iris: -40 (you will need dark room)

Lamp Iris: AUTO
Auto Black Stretch: off
Contrast Enhancement: off
Transient: Off (DOUBLE CHECK, MAIN CAUSE OF EE!)

Gain R: +2
Gain G: +3
Gain B: -5
Offset: R -15
Offset: G -13
Offset: B -6
Gamma R,G,BA 0,0,0

HDMI: L2 for pc levels using VMR, re-calibrate brightness for L1 (video levels and overlay output)

+ves Everything above IRE 40 now D65 without lumps and bumps. Gamma tracking spot on 2.23

-ves still a bit noisy, colour balance gives weird readings below IRE 40, looking into this ...

Very happy with these settings, spent ages with the smart and spyder trying to iron out those odd readings.

There is still some weirdness from IRE40 and below, I get two different readings from the x on the colorimeter, it appears to be fluctuating. Maybe this is the effect of the auto-iris?

EXTRA TIP: if you're got NO ambient light then you can afford to bang that iris right down to the -50s, and put that adaptive lamp mode on and will give you a superb depth: without light control though the low iris mode will appear way too dark. That's why I settled at -40 as a good compromise.
post #43 of 1081
Hi ROne

interesting settings there, I will try them out as soon as it's dark outside (right now, it's about 10 am....)

I discovered some interesting settings on the web - would you mind testing them against YOUR settings and give me your impression, how they work with your equipment?

I copied them from the following website:
http://www.avbuzz.com/audio-video/20...o-z4/index.htm

Settings based on Creative Cinema Mode

Brightness +3
Contrast -3
Color +4
Tint 0
Gamma +1 (he set it to +1 to have a bit more detail in the shadows)
Color temp. Mid
Red 0
Green 0
Blue 0
Gain R -5
Gain G -9
Gain B +3
Offset R -15
Offset G +15
Offset B -2
Gamma R +5
Gamma G -5
Gamma B -3
Lamp Iris Auto
Auto black Stretch, Contrast enhacement and Transient improvement all off

So, would you mind trying out these settings and report back? I will do so with your settings and compare them in my system (Oppo 971H, 2.40m wide motorized 1.2 gain screen)

Joerg
post #44 of 1081
thank you very much rone.
these settings look interesting.

like dvdr i'll check them out this evening.
post #45 of 1081
Hi ROne
could not wait until tonight - closed the shutters....

I tried both your Creative- and Living-based settings (Living is "lebendig" in the German menue and not the very last entry in the menue, "lebhaft", which could be something like "vivid", right?)

With my Oppo 971h the Living settings are way off towards heavy sunburn in faces, I loose a lot of detail in dark scenes (in LOTR, the heavily black clouded skies in the background are loosing all detail, just a black "soup" - as we say in Germany). Your creative-based settings are better in that regard, but flesh-tones are more into the red-ish as well.
Seems to be, that with your HTPC/Video-card you do really need extremely different values than I with my DVD-player over HDMI....
So: if you try out my values, you should end up with some sort of blue-ish/green-ish tint, wouldn't you?

Thanks for posting those findings anyway, it's always great to have people with measuring equipment take the time and try to share their findings!!!!!

Joerg
post #46 of 1081
Thread Starter 
I'd already tried the settings from avbuzz and they were way off for me.

The creative settings are slightly more tolerable to set-up and forgiving.

The living settings to create a very dark black, but the gamma is present an correct in terms of shadow detail.

Also bear in mind, my HDMI is set-up for L2, you may be on L1 for video output from HDMI - this definately shifts colour balance with the different contrast setting and would explain your crushed black.
post #47 of 1081
ROne

I'll experiment a bit further and try the L2 setting.

Again: thanks for providing all the information! I'm not critisizing, just reporting back After all, we all have different gear to feed the Z4....

Joerg
post #48 of 1081
Thread Starter 
DVDr, somebody has the same problem with the reds over on AVforums UK.

Here is my post:

I should imagine you should be on L1 (video levels) and you calibrate your own B+C and see what happens, I've got a feeling that my L2(pc levels) are different to the L1 set-up you should have.

If the contrast is driven to hard it will skew color balance towards green therefore a compensation is made to increase red, if the contrast was served up on L2 when it should be L1 for you 720p DVD players then this could cause incorrect colour balance.

For the record my settings are for HDMI Radeon 9600 HTPC using VMR 9 set on HDMI L2.

It's the contrasts different positioning relative to the input that is the problem.

As contrast goes up - red needs to be boosted, so if your contrast is not as high as mine then red will be over boosted.
post #49 of 1081
Thread Starter 
I am not completely happy with saturation, I have lowered it again to which makes it out of target with AVIA but I think it looks better. I suspect there is some variable at play with the different lamp modes that can effect it.

I have set it a +2 till I can find out why it's okay in the charts but a bit hot in movies.

I've quickly gone through the presets again and still staying with living, the others just don't have the same depth.
post #50 of 1081
Hi Guys,
My dvd player is the Denon 3800, its best out puts are component, what sort of picture quality should I expect to see from the Z4, I have a light controlled room and my wife and I are only interested in watching movies and HD TV.

Regards Peter
post #51 of 1081
ROne. Are you saying you can actually se the iris chagning with the picture on the screen? This doesnt seem to be an issue with the Z3. Am I missunderstanding something?
post #52 of 1081
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by maxse View Post

ROne. Are you saying you can actually se the iris chagning with the picture on the screen? This doesnt seem to be an issue with the Z3. Am I missunderstanding something?

The Z3 only has a manual iris.

The Z4 has this and an auto control lamp iris - which can confusingly be made manual as well (though it doesn't close down as much when in manual)

The manual iris serves a purpose though - that is to reduce or increase the overall light output. The auto lamp iris (on the Z4) dynamically changes between scenes, and yes on some presets you can see it move.
post #53 of 1081
Quote:
Originally Posted by ROne View Post

I am not completely happy with saturation, I have lowered it again to which makes it out of target with AVIA but I think it looks better. I suspect there is some variable at play with the different lamp modes that can effect it.

I have set it a +2 till I can find out why it's okay in the charts but a bit hot in movies.

I've quickly gone through the presets again and still staying with living, the others just don't have the same depth.

when i tried your settings with the high SAT the picture was also way too hot for me.
didn't you also had tint at +4 first?
because everything also looked too yellowish for me with these settings.

the only movie that looked kind of good for me with these settings was finding nemo

i'll try your revised living settings this evening.

btw: i have the same oppo player as dvdr does, but i also checked with my HTPC giving me the same results in terms of color.
post #54 of 1081
Thread Starter 
Yes - the tint controls and colour were as per AVIA, and they were too much.

What DVD software are you using? Overlay or VMR?

It does look like that even at D65 (and with my latest settings it's extremely close 40IRE and above) there is some weirdness acting out. I've not a clue what ...
post #55 of 1081
Thread Starter 
It was nothing to do with the colour balance - its the colour decoder which i naturally assumed to be perfect through HDMI, and after testing all inputs its the same across the board. Too much red and green saturation, not enough blue.

The best and most satisfactory way to cure this is to use the colour management feature of the advanced menu.

Basically this allows you to remap how the colour is distributed.

All you need to do is load up a good screen with a close-up face on it that looks too orange-red, a nice clear outdoor shot. Select the colour management tool from the menu, the screen will freeze - then a target will appear - pick an area of the flesh tone depress the okay button you will then get a further menu which allows you to adjust the colour of that particular tone. I would suggest you lower the colour level a couple of notches and you will sea the skin tone come back to a natural level.

Have a mess with it - don't forget to store it within your preset. It also allows you to AB it. It works great!

You can then set overall saturation as you require.

This looks to be a problem with all presets on all inputs.
post #56 of 1081
Is there a PDF version of the Z4 manual available anywhere? It's not showing up yet at the Sanyo website (should be soon as they have all other projectors' manuals there and the Z4 now appears in the products section).
post #57 of 1081
Quote:
Originally Posted by ROne View Post

It was nothing to do with the colour balance - its the colour decoder which i naturally assumed to be perfect through HDMI, and after testing all inputs its the same across the board. Too much red and green saturation, not enough blue.

The best and most satisfactory way to cure this is to use the colour management feature of the advanced menu.

Basically this allows you to remap how the colour is distributed.

All you need to do is load up a good screen with a close-up face on it that looks too orange-red, a nice clear outdoor shot. Select the colour management tool from the menu, the screen will freeze - then a target will appear - pick an area of the flesh tone depress the okay button you will then get a further menu which allows you to adjust the colour of that particular tone. I would suggest you lower the colour level a couple of notches and you will sea the skin tone come back to a natural level.

Have a mess with it - don't forget to store it within your preset. It also allows you to AB it. It works great!

You can then set overall saturation as you require.

Thanks for the info, ROne.

I have been asking about the color management system all around, even emailing some reviewers, but nobody seems to have touched it, nor knew anyting about it.

Reading the manual, it seemed like the perfect fail-safe in case other color adjustments did not get you where you wanted to go.

Is the Sanyo Z4 the first projector to have a color management system in addition to the usual rgb and gamma adjustments? Did the Z3 have his feature?

Shelly
post #58 of 1081
Thread Starter 
Shelly - I do remember you asking about it but i thought I would not need to mess with the saturation - again the Z3 didn't need any messing in this area with HDMI.

It wasn't on the Z3.

Where Jeremy had to fix the red push with an attenuator on the Z3 via component, and then later the service menu you can now do it in menu.

I could so with some clues how to use it properly though - so far I used the colour decoder check to check for imbalance in the saturation of the primaries.

But I found best to eyeball flesh tones, it's relatively easy to bring flesh tones in - though for my money they shouldn't be out under HDMI.
post #59 of 1081
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jay Mitchosky View Post

Is there a PDF version of the Z4 manual available anywhere? It's not showing up yet at the Sanyo website (should be soon as they have all other projectors' manuals there and the Z4 now appears in the products section).


Here is the only place it has been found. Not even on Sanyos website yet.

http://www.audiogeneral.com/Sanyo/PLV-Z4_OM.pdf
post #60 of 1081
Thanks!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › Digital Projectors - Under $3,000 USD MSRP › PLV-Z4 Tweak Thread