Quote:
Originally Posted by mdavej 
No IR remote sensor, big, slow, noisy, complicated, power hog, wrong shape/size for a rack, practically no streaming apps, mediocre DVD upconversion. Just getting a logitech adapter is $50US, which is half the cost of an entire stand-alone player and more than many used players. But since you already have a PS3, you already know all of this.
Can't think of a good reason TO get a PS3 instead of a stand-alone in this day and age. Can't even think of a reason to spend $200 on a stand-alone player.
(My opinion will probably not be very popular in this thread).

No IR remote sensor, big, slow, noisy, complicated, power hog, wrong shape/size for a rack, practically no streaming apps, mediocre DVD upconversion. Just getting a logitech adapter is $50US, which is half the cost of an entire stand-alone player and more than many used players. But since you already have a PS3, you already know all of this.
Can't think of a good reason TO get a PS3 instead of a stand-alone in this day and age. Can't even think of a reason to spend $200 on a stand-alone player.
(My opinion will probably not be very popular in this thread).
Well I don't see a problem with missing IR in PS3 because if you get PS3 blu-ray remote controller it works via bluetooth and it is excellent and no need to point it towards player. I've used that remote so long that I can use it in total darkness.
This Slim model does not look big to me. It is often equal or a bit slower than my Panasonic standalone player (40 vs 50 seconds) but in some titles the PS3 is a lot faster. Slim models are not that noisy either. I don't see what is complicated in PS3, once you check couples of settings it works like any standalone player. I don't think power consumption is any problem especially with current Slim models. I just got one and measured it myself and it is only around 70w. It is about the same as old fashion light bulb. in my opinion DVD upconversion is pretty nice but it definitely has different look than many standalone player that use simplier scaling algorithms. Some peoples say it is much better than standalone player. In PS3 they are using more sophisticated edge adaptive scaling method which needs powerful cpu.
I ended up getting another PS3 for my main blu-ray player because it is so nice to use, it has very fast interface, it supports every title and is updated frequently and blu-ray image is as good as it can be (there are only few players that do everything right and the PS3 is one of them).










![Vantage Point (+ BD Live) [Blu-ray]](http://cdn.avsforum.com/d/d0/50x50px-ZC-d07db017_B0018CWW3C-51A2X6F7wXL.jpeg)









. No, you do not need one. Check post 2 in the FAQ thread for setup.


