Quote:
Originally Posted by kjgarrison 
I never meant anything to come across as a rant. It was, and still is, a simple question. Everything else coming from me has been an attempted explanation of why I asked the question in the first place. The question was: Did the firmware upgrade to fix an apparent problem with HQV testing that was acknowledged to be needed, and was promised by Gennum around June 2007, also get supported by Anthem and come out? Yes or no?
If you need to know why I ask before you can answer, then fine. Here's why. We watch a lot of HD DTV, which, as I am sure many of you know, is pretty noisy and is either 720p or 1080i. I am looking for an AVR that will scale 720p, deinterlace 1080i, and add noise reduction to these HD signals. The "usual" AVR contenders (Onkyo, Denon, Yamaha, Integra, etc.) do not do that. Most of the VP's in the HDTV's do not do this very well. I was told the higher end Anthem products do it well.
As to "real world" performance, I don't feel confident that I am capable of knowing it when I see it. I don't want to draw conclusions based on subjective opinions. I need something objective; a test. A test that is available, widely used, accepted, and reproducible.
I have already stated that it makes me suspicious that a chip maker produces the test that is supposed to evaluate the quality of competitors' chips. If there is an alternative test, I would love to know about it. So would, I imagine, the HD equipment reviewers at every magazine that I have thus far read, given that they seem to alwasys use the HQV tests to evaluate video and film deinterlacing & processing (among other tests of course, but none other for deinterlacing that I have seen.)
Today I found an Anthem dealer around 100 miles from where I live, and he agreed to a demo which will include "real world" DTV, hi def DVD viewing, and of course he invited me to bring the test discs. I'm hopeful that I will be able to see some "real world" improvement in DTV image quality AND see crystal clear deinterlacing of 1080i by the Anthem.
Thank you.

I never meant anything to come across as a rant. It was, and still is, a simple question. Everything else coming from me has been an attempted explanation of why I asked the question in the first place. The question was: Did the firmware upgrade to fix an apparent problem with HQV testing that was acknowledged to be needed, and was promised by Gennum around June 2007, also get supported by Anthem and come out? Yes or no?
If you need to know why I ask before you can answer, then fine. Here's why. We watch a lot of HD DTV, which, as I am sure many of you know, is pretty noisy and is either 720p or 1080i. I am looking for an AVR that will scale 720p, deinterlace 1080i, and add noise reduction to these HD signals. The "usual" AVR contenders (Onkyo, Denon, Yamaha, Integra, etc.) do not do that. Most of the VP's in the HDTV's do not do this very well. I was told the higher end Anthem products do it well.
As to "real world" performance, I don't feel confident that I am capable of knowing it when I see it. I don't want to draw conclusions based on subjective opinions. I need something objective; a test. A test that is available, widely used, accepted, and reproducible.
I have already stated that it makes me suspicious that a chip maker produces the test that is supposed to evaluate the quality of competitors' chips. If there is an alternative test, I would love to know about it. So would, I imagine, the HD equipment reviewers at every magazine that I have thus far read, given that they seem to alwasys use the HQV tests to evaluate video and film deinterlacing & processing (among other tests of course, but none other for deinterlacing that I have seen.)
Today I found an Anthem dealer around 100 miles from where I live, and he agreed to a demo which will include "real world" DTV, hi def DVD viewing, and of course he invited me to bring the test discs. I'm hopeful that I will be able to see some "real world" improvement in DTV image quality AND see crystal clear deinterlacing of 1080i by the Anthem.
Thank you.
No one is asking asking you to explain why you are asking, they are asking for specifics on the issue.
1) What is the test that supposedly failed?
2) What are the symptoms?
3) What are the video inputs caysing the issue?
Vaguely referring to a vague test with a vague date and vague fix is not helping you get an answer.
If you WANT answers you need to ask COMPLETE questions. Sometime ago some test maybe some fix is UNSATISFACTORY. You are wasting EVERYONE's time including YOURS.
Issue, dates, inputs, anomalies. No one here tracks other vendor tests and if you want an answer there is no way to answer without more info.























- Unless I keep it really specific to Anthem RS-232 details... 
