This is what I am starting to conclude myself, that there are conditions in which the Y/C separation is insufficient to prevent it. However, what I am describing is noticeable enough, I think, to be visible even on an SD tube set. The following link provides a suggestion that could explain this:
http://www.michaeldvd.com.au/Article...sDotCrawl.html
This one particular cartoon dvd I have (my torture test) appears fairly low budget, so it may be inherent in the source, passing though s-video, but filtered out through composite. This link could also explain the artifact seen on the 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment logo at the very opening of ep2, as well as other various logos appearing on other dvd's I have seen. But, do they really pull these logos from composite masters? Anyway, I'm sure I'm not the only one growing bored with the topic. If I try anything in conclusion, it will be to see if the torture test passes with a component input, and perhaps A/B the composite/s-video into my old SD tube set.
Updated 1-31-07...
I have found that my "problem" source dvd's have displayed dot crawl not only on my SD tube set, but also on the A2000's component and HDMI inputs. Thus, it is inherent in the source. The A2000 comb filter is capable of filtering it regardless of where it originates, and the other inputs simply ignore it. I suppose the only thing I cannot explain at this point is the occasional dot crawl seen on SD cable, since it is comb filtered, but it is very rare and, therefore, not a concern.
http://www.michaeldvd.com.au/Article...sDotCrawl.html
This one particular cartoon dvd I have (my torture test) appears fairly low budget, so it may be inherent in the source, passing though s-video, but filtered out through composite. This link could also explain the artifact seen on the 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment logo at the very opening of ep2, as well as other various logos appearing on other dvd's I have seen. But, do they really pull these logos from composite masters? Anyway, I'm sure I'm not the only one growing bored with the topic. If I try anything in conclusion, it will be to see if the torture test passes with a component input, and perhaps A/B the composite/s-video into my old SD tube set.
Updated 1-31-07...
I have found that my "problem" source dvd's have displayed dot crawl not only on my SD tube set, but also on the A2000's component and HDMI inputs. Thus, it is inherent in the source. The A2000 comb filter is capable of filtering it regardless of where it originates, and the other inputs simply ignore it. I suppose the only thing I cannot explain at this point is the occasional dot crawl seen on SD cable, since it is comb filtered, but it is very rare and, therefore, not a concern.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Feirstein 
S-Video was introduced to eliminate dot crawl on the existing tube display sets of the time when good color/brightness filters were not installed in home sets. But the introduction of S-Video did not eliminate all necessary filtering steps. With the introduction of huge sharp displays you are likely seeing some artificts associated with less than perfect filtering, even though the S-Video interconnect has eliminated most of the artifacts that were quite visible on smaller displays. Component interconnects eliminate the need for this additional filtering and thus eliminates the associated artificts produced by less than perfect filtering.
Richard.

S-Video was introduced to eliminate dot crawl on the existing tube display sets of the time when good color/brightness filters were not installed in home sets. But the introduction of S-Video did not eliminate all necessary filtering steps. With the introduction of huge sharp displays you are likely seeing some artificts associated with less than perfect filtering, even though the S-Video interconnect has eliminated most of the artifacts that were quite visible on smaller displays. Component interconnects eliminate the need for this additional filtering and thus eliminates the associated artificts produced by less than perfect filtering.
Richard.


















