Originally Posted by spf781
If I remember correctly, this was the website that had that bogus "T2" Blu-Ray review before the disc came out this past summer. Apparently, the person "reviewing" the disc just put a bunch of B.S. in his review, people here called him on it (and were right), but he stood by his lie. The site's owner had to come on here and apologize for the whole debacle.
I'm pretty sure that UpcomingDiscs was the site.
EDIT: I was right. It is this site.http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showt...5&highlight=T2
Hey cut me some slack here...I started after
whatever this T2 controversy. Sounds interesting though...I like controversy!!
. Besides my first Blu Ray review of Click
gave it a less than biased 3.5/5 on video.
When Jeremy hired me on at UpcomingDiscs
, there was no talk of bolstering up video / audio scores. Or anything of the sort. HD DVD guys may not like my opinions, but when it comes to puttnig my name on a review, you can rest assured it is an honest take of what I see. If you have seen my DVD reviews stickied in the DVD Forum over the last 2 years, I call 'em like I see 'em. I can assure that BD bias will not permiate my reviews. Read the review, watch the movie and see for yourself. I know many buy discs on what they read in reviews, and I am not going to BS the folks here into buying crappy transfers if they look bad!
In all seriousness, th Brothers Grimm
picture is gorgeous and right up there with some of the better HD DVDs. It is not perfect but it is pretty damn close. The audio is friggin' phenominal..and many here no I am a bass fanatic!!
I have Blu Ray versions of Kung Fu Hustle, Monster house, Silent Hill, and Haunted Mansion
coming up. I am ONLY reviewing Blu Ray titles. But I do own a HD-DVD player as well....so I can compare. As a side, I do have HD DVD of Aeon Flux
that I am slated to do as well... so watch for that!!