Quote:
Originally Posted by kasif@ 
For the last couple of weeks, I saw lot's of different B&W 5+1 combination alternatives. I know these are very much related with like and budget but still I wonder which set below will have "internally" more harmony?
Dealer suggestion: 683, 685, HTM62, ASW610XP
User's preference: 683, 686, HTM61, ASW610
B&W web page suggeswtion1: 683, DS3, HTM61, ASW610XP
B&W web page suggestion2: 684, 686, HTM62, ASW610

For the last couple of weeks, I saw lot's of different B&W 5+1 combination alternatives. I know these are very much related with like and budget but still I wonder which set below will have "internally" more harmony?
Dealer suggestion: 683, 685, HTM62, ASW610XP
User's preference: 683, 686, HTM61, ASW610
B&W web page suggeswtion1: 683, DS3, HTM61, ASW610XP
B&W web page suggestion2: 684, 686, HTM62, ASW610
I agree with the posts above. 683 is better than 684 for floorstanders, while 685 is better than 686 for front bookshelf. If you decide 683, get the HTM61 for better match. Period.
For the subs and surrounds, it boils down to personal preference. Some choose B&W for subs since they find it musical and wants an all B&W set. But some movie enthusiasts choose other brands since for the same price, there are other subs that goes lower than B&W in terms of bass. It's not critical to choose subs of the same brand unlike choosing the front and center which must be of the same brand and series for seamless integration. So it's B&W musical subs vs. other brand movie subs that go very low... no right or wrong choice.
For the surrounds, decide first if you want dipole (DS3) or bookshelf (685 or 686). If you can afford DS3, have a big room to fill, have side walls to hang them, and want movie-like experience, go for DS3. But if you prefer accurate and localized sounds, don't want to spend much on surrounds and have no walls to hang DS3, then bookshelves are the way to go. Next step is choose between 685 and 686. If you'll use it strictly for surrounds only, choose 686. But if you have plans to use it for main someday, choose 685. Besides 685 are easier to resell than 686 in my opinion only. The difference in sound coming out of 685 and 686 when used as surrounds are not that noticeable... but it's a different story if you'll use it as main. The consensus here is 685 is a better bookshelf speaker than 686. So at the end of the day, there's no right or wrong choice...it's a matter of preference and tastes. Even B&W, in its 800 series manual, acknowledges the conflicting opinions about the choice of surround speakers which is the reason why they manufacture many types so that consumers may choose which one suit their taste: DS8 (dipole/monopole on wall), 805S (monopole on stands) and SCM8 (monopole on wall). You may want to check this out: http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=898287
Remember, despite the opinions of many here, there's no right or wrong choice. It's all a matter of personal preference. Good luck mate!


























