Quote:
Originally Posted by Joseph MAK 
A while ago, I reported that there wasn't Green Push from my 981HD.
This was my experience until I put up the AVIA's Gray Bars!
First, just let me detail my set up:
I have my 981HD connected to a Mits HC3100 DLP front projector, through HDMI and S-video connections. I also have a Panny RP82 player connected to the HC3100 through Component and S-video connections. Each connection was calibrated in Colour, Brightness, Contrast, using AVIA. It turned out the calibrated settings for all the sources (981HD's HDMI, 981HD's S-video, RP82's Component, RP82's S-video) were all the same.
Colour Temperature in the HC3100 was set to 6500K for all sources. Then I examined the AVIA's Gray Bars. The result was Gray Bars from the 981HD's HDMI output looked GREENER than the other 3 outputs. Gray Bars from 981HD's S-video, RP82's Component and RP82's S-video outputs looked the same to my naked eyes. Indeed, the Grayscale output from these three sources looked closer to 6500K.
720P and 480P HDMI outputs looked the same. No differecne at all, both have Green Push.
Now, I suspect indeed there is something wrong in the HDMI connection: Either the 981HD's HDMI output has Green Push or the Mits HC3100's HDMI input exaggerates the Green. Since I don't have other DVD players with an HDMI output, I am not able to track down whether the 981HD or the HC3100 is the culprit.
I am asking other 981HD owners to compare Gray Bars output from the 981HD's HDMI and S-video connections. Do you see Green Push from the HDMI's output as compared to its own S-video output.

A while ago, I reported that there wasn't Green Push from my 981HD.
This was my experience until I put up the AVIA's Gray Bars!
First, just let me detail my set up:
I have my 981HD connected to a Mits HC3100 DLP front projector, through HDMI and S-video connections. I also have a Panny RP82 player connected to the HC3100 through Component and S-video connections. Each connection was calibrated in Colour, Brightness, Contrast, using AVIA. It turned out the calibrated settings for all the sources (981HD's HDMI, 981HD's S-video, RP82's Component, RP82's S-video) were all the same.
Colour Temperature in the HC3100 was set to 6500K for all sources. Then I examined the AVIA's Gray Bars. The result was Gray Bars from the 981HD's HDMI output looked GREENER than the other 3 outputs. Gray Bars from 981HD's S-video, RP82's Component and RP82's S-video outputs looked the same to my naked eyes. Indeed, the Grayscale output from these three sources looked closer to 6500K.
720P and 480P HDMI outputs looked the same. No differecne at all, both have Green Push.
Now, I suspect indeed there is something wrong in the HDMI connection: Either the 981HD's HDMI output has Green Push or the Mits HC3100's HDMI input exaggerates the Green. Since I don't have other DVD players with an HDMI output, I am not able to track down whether the 981HD or the HC3100 is the culprit.
I am asking other 981HD owners to compare Gray Bars output from the 981HD's HDMI and S-video connections. Do you see Green Push from the HDMI's output as compared to its own S-video output.
JM, you say "Colour Temperature in the HC3100 was set to 6500K for all sources". Rather than doing a proper grayscale calibration, adjusting RGB gains and offsets on all inputs using a colorimeter to get D65 accuracy, you are relying on an internal HC3100 "feature". This could be one problem.
When comparing the HDMI and analog outputs from other players, I see tiny hints of color in the Avia bars on ALL the players. This is mostly due to poor grayscale tracking in the display. But the 981's HDMI output can shift the tints to different bars (possibly related to macroblock-enhance). A better test, is to use the gray ramp patterns. (Unfortunately, the Avia gray ramps are pretty ugly - DVE's ramps are much cleaner). In these ramps, you can clearly see the effects of minor color banding from all of your players, and how that banding shifts around with different player outputs. The 981 does not make the gray ramp green on my displays.
Gary
















