AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › DVD Recorders (Standard Def) › Compare DVR, DVD Recorder
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Compare DVR, DVD Recorder

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
What's the difference really? Is it just that a recorder can also play DVDs? BTW can a recorder also play CDs? Are DVRs only used to record and then replay television?
post #2 of 8
Thread Starter 
I guess zippychimp's post partially answers the question.
post #3 of 8
DVRs can't make a recording to a DVD, whereas DVD Recorders can.

Some DVD Recorders don't have a hard drive, whereas a DVR must.

Many DVRs can record High Definition content, whereas no current DVD Recoder can.

Most DVRs come with some kind of subscription/rental fee (subscription for TiVo-like DVRs, rental fee for cable company DVRs), whereas DVD Recorders do not have such ongoing costs associated with them.

By the way, most if not all DVD Recorders can play CDs. But to me this (and even playing DVDs) is not a useful distinction since one can simply buy a player to make up any deficit in that area. But one cannot buy something that will add to a DVR the capability to record DVDs (except of course a DVD Recorder, and even then not in High Definition).
post #4 of 8
To supplement the above:

DVRs are best when you want to time shift TV programs.

DVD recorders are best when you want to keep TV programs.

Since I do a some of each I have both a DVR and a DVD recorder.
post #5 of 8
Get the best of both worlds and get a DVD/HDD, which is a DVD recorder with on-board hard drive (DVR). You can time shift TV, or record programs, edit them if needed (ie cut out commercials), then burn them to a disc. Mine comes with a FREE on-screen tv guide similar to Tivo except there's no fee to use it! How can you not love all that?
post #6 of 8
Similar to Tivo, but the guide info is not anywhere near as detailed (based upon other threads here), and the TV Guide On Screen is flaky for many people... and you certainly don't get the various features of Tivo (season passes).

don't get me wrong, I have a Toshiba XS32 to augment my Tivos.. but as far as reliability and interface they definitely aren't a Tivo... (I got it because it allows me to edit recordings before burning to DVD, which the Tivo/dvd recorder combos didn't allow.)
post #7 of 8
I agree with mattack's assessment. Electronic programming guides on HDD DVD recorders are very useful (I have Panny recorders with TVGOS and have not recently experienced the programming glitches that plagued the earlier units) because they simplify programming and automatically fill in titles on recordings, but they certainly are not equivalent to TIVO programming features. OTOH they ARE free...
post #8 of 8
My Panny ES25 sits ontop of my replayTV 5000 the pair are near perfect together time shift to my DVR then record to DVD with my DVD Recorder.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: DVD Recorders (Standard Def)
AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › DVD Recorders (Standard Def) › Compare DVR, DVD Recorder