Originally Posted by Fettastic
36 out of 42 AVSers agree, DVDTalk is full of crap.
Really? That's what the poll is asking? Why don't you show me where it says that?
I'd also like to know whether you told people to vote before or after they've turned the Sharpness on their TV all the way to the maximum like you do?
Take that how you want. And how did I refer to DVDTalk as a "single entity"? I said "your site" as in, "the one you work for". Was that somehow confusing?
Many people review for DVDTalk. There are over 50 reviewers on staff. We don't always all share the same opinion.
So clean your own house before complaining about mine. As I recall you were argued vehemently that Sleepy Hollow was a reference title. You and Gary are pretty much alone on that score. Would that qualify you as "a complete joke" and "ridiculous"? Hey, your words, not mine.
I never argued that Sleepy Hollow was a "reference title", whatever that's supposed to mean. What I may have argued is that it looks the way that it's supposed to. When I reviewed it
, I gave it 3.5 stars out of a possible 5, a rating of "very good". That still seems fair to me and I stand by it, regardless of whatever hair-brained opinions you may have about it.