AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Surround Music Formats › SACD and DVD-A Differences?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

SACD and DVD-A Differences?

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
Is it just me or does it seem that most SACD releases tend to sound better than most DVD-A titles?

I know this is a very subjective inference as it depends on how well a particular title was mixed, etc.,..

However, I find many of the SACD's I own tend to come across beautifully balanced with very rich clean sound, while the majority of the DVD-A's (I own) usually exhibit good sound quality with poor distribution of surround levels (poor balance).

I can always count on a new SACD title bringing the best out of my system even when set at a conservative, or moderate, level. While many times I have to go into the speaker-level menu to off-set something to get the proper balance for DVD-A's. I'm using a brand-new Denon DVD-3930CI universal player which is very revealing.

I own many SACD titles by:
Elton John- very good
Steely Dan- very good
James Taylor- very good
Nora Jones- very good
Peter Gabriel- very good
John Coltrane, "Love Supreme" (stereo)- decent sound quality, poor mix.

DVD-A titles:
Beatles, "Love"- very good
Joni Mitchell, "Both sides Now"- good sound, poor mixing.
Billy Cobham, "Spectrum"- poor mixing
Grover Washington, "Wine Light"- very good
Fleetwood Mac, "Rumors"- very good
Miles Davis, "Tutu"- good
Others I've returned (probably 8 or 10)- good sound quality, poor mixing
post #2 of 5
i have good and bad of both i think it has everything to due with
how and who produces it or how it is remastered.
post #3 of 5
I have excellent sounding discs in each format so I think it is more the mixing/mastering choices than the format. Some universal players are better with one format or the other, though higher end Denon gear is usually well balanced in that regard.
post #4 of 5
Thread Starter 
thanks guy's for your input. You're probably right, the mixing is the difference.
post #5 of 5
SACD seems to usually sound better than DVD-Audio for the most part due to its DSD 1 bit system.

In DSD the low and mid frequencies have much better dynamic range than CD, then at the highs the dynamic range decreases dramatically, equivalent to raising the db in the highs which could explain why SACD would sound more detailed than DVD-Audio.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Surround Music Formats
AVS › AVS Forum › Audio › Surround Music Formats › SACD and DVD-A Differences?