I played with it quite a bit tonight and can't seem to get the picture smooth without softening it. The HD looks acceptable, but still no "wow factor". SD is pretty disappointing. I've got the internal ATSC tuner as well as a Sony STB/DVR (also ATSC) and I get the same subpar SD picture quality. I ran the HQV test disk tonight and this set fails a few of the tests. The failure that stands out the most is the "jaggies" test. Failed miserably. The HD DVE tests look really good. So, if I'm watching 720p or 1080i material, it looks pretty good. Anything less than HD resolution is not so good. I'm really surprised I'm not seeing what everyone else it seeing. Maybe Hondo is right. I just have to get used to the DLP "look".
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fragster 
Thanks for the honest review, Dlhope! I have been in the same boat as u....current owner of the 57s500 Hitachi that I have no issue with at the moment but its the reflections and the bulkiness that made me start considering DLP's.
I was looking at the 65" Toshiba but from your review, non-HD picture quality seems less than par compared to the Hitachi and most of my programming is SD though I also own a HD-A2 player for HD movies.
I know the Hitachi's have a fantastic scaler that up-scales lower resolutions to 1080i native and hence why even my regular DVD's always looked good but it appears the Toshiba may be somewhat lacking in such a scaler.
Hmmm.......so my search goes on :-(
Frag

Thanks for the honest review, Dlhope! I have been in the same boat as u....current owner of the 57s500 Hitachi that I have no issue with at the moment but its the reflections and the bulkiness that made me start considering DLP's.
I was looking at the 65" Toshiba but from your review, non-HD picture quality seems less than par compared to the Hitachi and most of my programming is SD though I also own a HD-A2 player for HD movies.
I know the Hitachi's have a fantastic scaler that up-scales lower resolutions to 1080i native and hence why even my regular DVD's always looked good but it appears the Toshiba may be somewhat lacking in such a scaler.
Hmmm.......so my search goes on :-(
Frag






























