AVS › AVS Forum › A/V Control & Automation › Home A/V Distribution › Grand Concerto Or Control4
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Grand Concerto Or Control4

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
I have been reading forums, posting to forums and trying to decide what system I want for a long time. Ultimately I need eight zones for music in my new home. At this point I do not want any home automation and I doubt I will really require it in the future. For sources I want my digital cable box that carries local radio stations and satelite radio. As well I want the CD player, iPod and my home music server.

Originally I was torn between the Grand Concerto and the Adagio. I liked that the Adagio had more power and built in tuners. Aparently Crestron has software the allows you to interface with a PC media server but not sure how well it works. I think it is called SW-WMC. The Grand Concerto has a nicer keypad in my opinion over the APAD, in both athetics and functionality, keeping in mind only user audio distribution. The lack of IR passthrough on the Adagio, the limit of six zones and the fact that it is difficult for a DIY to program turned me off that route.

So I was set on the Grand Concerto and almost bought it this past weekend when somebody introduced me to Control4. I was recommened to buy their amplifier with switching for eight pairs of speakers with 100 watts per channel. This is a lot of power, and I believe it supports ten inputs. Then the home theature peice which apparently integrates with my home PC to access all of my media files. Then for control I would have the remote that comes with the home theature control and two of the full color LCD keypads, one for each floor. I like that fact that you have a small LCD on the remote and the color interface on the keypads.

My house has already been wired to have a double gang keypad in all eight rooms with speakers. So, if I go the Control4 avenue I have to cover many of these up to put a central interface on each floor. I have not read much on Control4 here, which is what makes me a little eerie to go this route. It works out about the same price as the Grand Concerto and it allows me to access my media server. With the Grand Concerto I was planning on buying CasaTunes to interface with my media server, but it still does not allow you to select the song from the keypad. It does show you metadata on the keypad, pause, stop, skip forward and back all from the keypad.

Please everyone, help me out. What should I do? I want something sleek and budget is of a concern.

AudioGuy1000
post #2 of 5
Can I assume you want to DIY a little bit here? Future addition of video/security/HVAC and so on ?

I dont know if Control4 allows any DIY either.

I want something sleek and budget is of a concern

it sounds like you want a out of the box solution at first then maybe start tweaking? That is a tough one, I looked for a similar solution last year. I wanted Audio and Video distributed in my house to start with but without spending 25K+ there was no solution. Especially for me since all my video is stored on a network and not on individual DVDs anymore.

Anyways, I decided to go with CQC and do DIY from the start. Food for thought.

Good luck with your solution!
post #3 of 5
Thread Starter 
This is something I want to DIY. I may later on doing some lighting, but this would be at least five years down the road.

I like the remote for the Control4 and it seems pretty versatile. My biggest concern is the quality of the product. The Grand Concerto looks pretty cool, but I have not used the keypad interface to browse through a large list. I expect to put about 200 CD's worth of music on my server. With the APAD you can scroll through this list very quickly with the navigation wheel. I don't know that you can do this as effeciently with the Grand Concerto keypad.

AudioGuy1000
post #4 of 5
Control4 is not DIY
post #5 of 5
I'm going the control4 route and agree with the fellas here that its not DIY. If you're only planning distributed audio, then I would think that control4 might not be for you. good luck!

tum
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Home A/V Distribution
AVS › AVS Forum › A/V Control & Automation › Home A/V Distribution › Grand Concerto Or Control4