AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › LCD Flat Panel Displays › Official Sony W3000 Series Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Official Sony W3000 Series Thread - Page 5

post #121 of 3234
Image is on behind XMB.
post #122 of 3234
Fry's at Downers Grove in Illinois had 40" W3000 and V3000 next to each other, showing some dolphin movie clip, played from a computer. The V3000 was taking the computer input through HDMI--I don't think the V2500 could do this. Both looked very nice, but both also had severe false contouring problems. This was seen in the underwater scenes where there was light shining down from the water surface. This was a little surprising because I would think that with 10-bit color, that false contouring would not be a problem. Perhaps it was a problem with the mastering of the DVD rather than with the displays..... There also seemed to be a red-push on flesh tones, but perhaps this could be removed with more tuning of the settings than I had time to do. (Fry's has the remote controls attached with velcro on the side of each display, for your convenience.)

They also had the 46" XBR2, V2500, and V3000 next to each other, all playing the movie Ice Age. There was something very wrong with the XBR2 as it looked dimmer than the other 2 displays, even at the brightest setting. I tried to adjust the V2500 and V3000 to the same settings, but it is clear that these are very different displays, or at least the numerical values of the settings are very different. At the same setting levels, the V2500 looks much blue-er than the V3000. I do not know which of these 2 displays had a more accurate color because Ice Age is a cartoon. The colors on the V3000 looked slightly better.

I didn't have time to explore further, so I am eager to hear other people's impressions.

My bottom line is that I would be very happy to own any of these displays. None are perfect, but all are very good. I wouldn't consider any display other than a SONY because of SD performance.
post #123 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by sanction1 View Post

Fry's at Downers Grove in Illinois had 40" W3000 and V3000 next to each other, showing some dolphin movie clip, played from a computer. The V3000 was taking the computer input through HDMI--I don't think the V2500 could do this. Both looked very nice, but both also had severe false contouring problems.

I think you have a bad test design for the false contouring.... from a computer your get 16 million colors from even the best video cards. The 10 Bit on the Sonys/Samsungs are supposed to be able to output billions of colors. I would look to see if you see the issue with a different source input
post #124 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by Netjoy69 View Post

It's a CLOUDY day in Miami!

I just purchased the 46W3000 for my bedroom, and was very excited until I turned the TV on and saw the cursed clouds everyone talks about. The cloud patches are very large and can easily be seen when changing inputs or channels, however, I have not noticed them during regular programming. I am very dissapointed, since the TV on display in the store had very even backlighting.

I will be returning this TV tomorrow for another unit.

How was this transported to your house....what angle was the LCD...sitting up in a mini van....or flat in back of truck or whatever. How long was the car ride to your house....how bumpy the road?

You can see why am asking.....wondering if a means of transporting can cause damage to the display resulting in clouds
post #125 of 3234
I think the W runs its internal clock at 120hz so that it can show 24p, but doesn't do the interpreation between 60p frames to make a 120p image. That is why it doesn't have motion flow. That is just my guess, based on the fact that it has the 24p movie mode that the SonyStyle guy is not a fancy 3:2 pull down.

The SonyStyle guy also bemoaned the changing spec pages on the website.

I ordered a 46W3000 from Curcuit City last Sunday, and 45 minutes later my wife went into to labor. Twelve hours later and a little girl that came a month early, I didn't have time to pick it up till Thursday and till Friday late to set it up.

It is about an inch wider than a V2500, based on specs. It was bit bigger than what my wife expected, and it was really close to going back for a 40inch model. I also bought a S300 BD player and three movies. I've only watched two. "Open Season" and "Black Hawk Down". I just tried a few scenes in BHD to test it out. The scene where the helicopters start their initial attack almost made my wife puke b/c of motion sickness; NICE!

"Open Season" was for my 2 year old. You know you have something when he sees it and goes "Cool" and "Nice". Every single twig and strand of fur can be seen.

HD cable thru Comcast is hit or miss. Local ABC channel, most watched by the wife, touts their HD all the time, but looks like crap usually. Some of the other HD channels are awesome. I watched some baseball and tennis and didn't see much problems with streaking or such. Almost makes me want to watch hockey on TV again.

The S300 and W3000 do a good job showing regular DVDs. Not BD quality, but pretty darn good.

I thought I saw some clouds, but it was when I just got the TV, I have not seen them since. I almost think it may be becuase the set was not warmed up, or maybe even reflections from the other room.

Vivid is just too hot for me, standard isn't bad. I've set up Custom 1 between Vivid and STD,with more mpeg and other processing. Cimema is nice for regular DVDs or anything that is too harsh in the other options. I was getting a lot of jaggies and harsh angles with Vivid, plus it is just too bright.

To me it is all about signal. If it is getting a 1080 signal, it just straight rocks. Less than that it does OK, and I know, we don't all live in a 1080 world. The worst is stuff thru Comcast HD cable, upscaling sometimes is a bit odd, plus the switch of 4:3 to zoom-wide that I have set to automatically happen sometimes doesn't. I have a feeling that I'm going to set up the customs for 1) True 1080Hd, 2)Regular DVDs 3) SD stuff over the HD cable.

I have to give Sony a cheer and a jeer. Jeer for a thin manual for the TV and Player. Cheers for making the TV pretty easy to use out of the box, yet be fairly customizable thru some deeper menus. HDMI is awesome, my wife freaks on cables, so that is helping bunches. Unless I had read these forums, I don't think I would have found all the things you can tweak, since I wouldn't have known to look for them.

Even my wife grudingly agrees that it has a great picture and looks good. We'll know more today when we see how "General Hospital" looks.

Mark
post #126 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by tombaker View Post

How was this transported to your house....what angle was the LCD...sitting up in a mini van....or flat in back of truck or whatever. How long was the car ride to your house....how bumpy the road?

You can see why am asking.....wondering if a means of transporting can cause damage to the display resulting in clouds

If they are going to be this tempermental, Sony needs to say that they have to e shipped upright, not just suggest it. The retailers shouldn't load them into cars flat either.

I have a buddy that worked at UPS, do you have any idea what happens to stuff in there? Never ship anything that says "Condoms" or "Sunglasses" on it unless it is fully insured.

Mark
post #127 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by SonyPointGuy View Post

I ordered a 46W3000 from Curcuit City last Sunday, and 45 minutes later my wife went into to labor. Twelve hours later and a little girl that came a month early, I didn't have time to pick it up till Thursday and till Friday late to set it up.

Congrats!!!!!
post #128 of 3234
Congrats, can you play your BD movies in 1080p24 direct mode output to the W and compare if it makes any difference than 1080p60 mode when you get a chance?

Thanks.

Quote:
Originally Posted by SonyPointGuy View Post

I think the W runs its internal clock at 120hz so that it can show 24p, but doesn't do the interpreation between 60p frames to make a 120p image. That is why it doesn't have motion flow. That is just my guess, based on the fact that it has the 24p movie mode that the SonyStyle guy is not a fancy 3:2 pull down.

The SonyStyle guy also bemoaned the changing spec pages on the website.

I ordered a 46W3000 from Curcuit City last Sunday, and 45 minutes later my wife went into to labor. Twelve hours later and a little girl that came a month early, I didn't have time to pick it up till Thursday and till Friday late to set it up.

It is about an inch wider than a V2500, based on specs. It was bit bigger than what my wife expected, and it was really close to going back for a 40inch model. I also bought a S300 BD player and three movies. I've only watched two. "Open Season" and "Black Hawk Down". I just tried a few scenes in BHD to test it out. The scene where the helicopters start their initial attack almost made my wife puke b/c of motion sickness; NICE!

"Open Season" was for my 2 year old. You know you have something when he sees it and goes "Cool" and "Nice". Every single twig and strand of fur can be seen.

HD cable thru Comcast is hit or miss. Local ABC channel, most watched by the wife, touts their HD all the time, but looks like crap usually. Some of the other HD channels are awesome. I watched some baseball and tennis and didn't see much problems with streaking or such. Almost makes me want to watch hockey on TV again.

The S300 and W3000 do a good job showing regular DVDs. Not BD quality, but pretty darn good.

I thought I saw some clouds, but it was when I just got the TV, I have not seen them since. I almost think it may be becuase the set was not warmed up, or maybe even reflections from the other room.

Vivid is just too hot for me, standard isn't bad. I've set up Custom 1 between Vivid and STD,with more mpeg and other processing. Cimema is nice for regular DVDs or anything that is too harsh in the other options. I was getting a lot of jaggies and harsh angles with Vivid, plus it is just too bright.

To me it is all about signal. If it is getting a 1080 signal, it just straight rocks. Less than that it does OK, and I know, we don't all live in a 1080 world. The worst is stuff thru Comcast HD cable, upscaling sometimes is a bit odd, plus the switch of 4:3 to zoom-wide that I have set to automatically happen sometimes doesn't. I have a feeling that I'm going to set up the customs for 1) True 1080Hd, 2)Regular DVDs 3) SD stuff over the HD cable.

I have to give Sony a cheer and a jeer. Jeer for a thin manual for the TV and Player. Cheers for making the TV pretty easy to use out of the box, yet be fairly customizable thru some deeper menus. HDMI is awesome, my wife freaks on cables, so that is helping bunches. Unless I had read these forums, I don't think I would have found all the things you can tweak, since I wouldn't have known to look for them.

Even my wife grudingly agrees that it has a great picture and looks good. We'll know more today when we see how "General Hospital" looks.

Mark
post #129 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by quyen51 View Post

Congrats, can you play your BD movies in 1080p24 direct mode output to the W and compare if it makes any difference than 1080p60 mode when you get a chance?

Thanks.

Between the new TV, player, and baby I haven't had time to figure out how to flip that back and forth.

How do I know if a movie is encoded 24p?
How do you flip from 60 to 24?

Mark
post #130 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by SonyPointGuy View Post

Between the new TV, player, and baby I haven't had time to figure out how to flip that back and forth.

How do I know if a movie is encoded 24p?
How do you flip from 60 to 24?

Mark

The remote on your S300 BD player has a button called "Video Format" that you can cycle through to select the output resolution 1080p24 (direct), 1080p60, etc. You might also have to go to the setup on your BD player and turn 1080p24 from Off (default) to ON.
post #131 of 3234
I purchased a KDL46W3000 at Fry's. I had to lay it flat on its back in the back of the car for about 5 minutes to get it home. Initial reaction was the colors are great but way to saturated in vivid mode. I set up a custom mode to make it more natural looking. I am still working on getting it right as it had too much green in the blacks. Otherwise black level is nice and inky. I turned the backlight down to 3 to tame the brightness. During the day I saw what I thought was a cloudy area near the upper right corner of the screen. When it got darker it became more apparent. It seems to be the only area affected. In HD mode with HDMI connected the picture is sharp and nearly noise free as I expected. I have not determined if I will return it due to the cloud. Perhaps I will wait to see what others report and how bad the problem seems to be. Overall I am impressed with the picture quality and function of the TV but am certainly disappointed in the cloud I see.

Bruce
post #132 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by WaldorfSalad View Post

You seem determined to try and convince everyone (in other threads also) that the clouding problem is fixed at the factory level when if fact the jury is still out because there have been so few reports of good and bad sets so far. The clouding problem is in the way the LCD panels are manufactured, not how the TV is brought home from the store. Every TV gets transported some way or another, whether it be from the factory to the store, or the store to the home either by the customer or the store delivery people in their truck.

Actually I could not find a clear distinct explanation of what causes clouding ...until I posted it and other members have confirmed it. I have read through literally hundreds and hundreds of postings about clouding. A large panel held flat and vibrated, (ie back of solid axil leaf spring frame rail Truck) can cause stresses on plastic frames that could cause clouding. Panels are shipped standing tall as the packaging is designed, until the consumer or a bad shipping company becomes involved. Do you disagree? If you are now saying you can not mess up a LCD via transporting....I will just give up on you.

No one has viewed clouds on the W V and S in stores, while seeing clouds on an XBR2 in a store in not a rarity. I am not trying to convince anyone of anything....other than people buying new TV should not be in fear of clouds....if you buy a set, and it has them....return it.
post #133 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by bweimer View Post

I purchased a KDL46W3000 at Fry's. I had to lay it flat on its back in the back of the car for about 5 minutes to get it home.
Bruce

Well 5 minutes in a car is not gonna mess it up....just wanted to excluded the....well I drove it 10 miles up the dirt road, back up to my farm...scenario.

My suggestion, if I may, is first decide if you are keeping it just as the Model first, do you want this one, or do you want to get a peak at the Samsung 71s. After you decide if this Sony is for you....then return it for a haze free one. No point to return for the cloud if you don't want the full TV.

As everyone who has looked at the displays has not seen clouds, there is no reason to settle.
post #134 of 3234
I am very happy with the set except for the cloud. I got a good deal, too.

Bruce
post #135 of 3234
Could you possibly post pictures of it? Exactly how bad is it? Most LCD's on the market today (hell even my computer monitor) have a little clouding often times. I'm not saying it's acceptable and I'm not here to start an argument, I would just like to see how it actually is. Thanks in advance.
post #136 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by tombaker View Post

As everyone who has looked at the displays has not seen clouds, there is no reason to settle.

Are you on drugs? There are 3 people on this thread alone who have taken the set home and seen clouds....but yet you say everyone has not seen clouds.

Can we start calling you "tom baker the cloud expert"?
post #137 of 3234
clouds? does it really matter? unless you see them while actually watching content what's the big deal if you only see them while flipping between inputs or on a blank screen?
post #138 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by CGIM5804 View Post

clouds? does it really matter? unless you see them while actually watching content what's the big deal if you only see them while flipping between inputs or on a blank screen?

That's true,I will be more worry if there is a problem with the tv's Hdmi handshake.
post #139 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by tombaker View Post

How was this transported to your house....what angle was the LCD...sitting up in a mini van....or flat in back of truck or whatever. How long was the car ride to your house....how bumpy the road?

You can see why am asking.....wondering if a means of transporting can cause damage to the display resulting in clouds

I took the TV home in back of my Mazda5, laying flat with the screen facing up. I drove like a granny and was careful to avoid bumps during the 2.5 mile trip Today, I exchanged the defective TV with another 46W3000, which I took home in a similar fashion. The replacement unit has very minor clouding in the lower left corner, but it is so subtle, that I can live with it.

The good news is it that the clouds do not affect TV viewing
post #140 of 3234
Quote:


clouds? does it really matter?

Ye$. The$e are expen$ive TV$
post #141 of 3234
300 comes out tomorrow.

Prepare for GLORY!

Or should it be "Prepare for Gory!"

The God's wished it that my 46W3000 and the 300 would come out within a week of each other!

Leonidas wannaB
post #142 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by CGIM5804 View Post

clouds? does it really matter? unless you see them while actually watching content what's the big deal if you only see them while flipping between inputs or on a blank screen?

It matters if you notice it....and if you look back some of the historical clouding on XBRs....you can not call it anything other than a defective or manufacturing BLEEM item.

On my Sony there was a slightly bright corner that went away after the first week....it was minor at the start and it reduced itself over time. Sounding similar Netjoy69 2nd unit. Right now when I switch inputs the black is black and still being driven by the backlighting....and fully uniform across 40" 46'' is a harder goal.

With all the talk about disposable HDTVs now by Polaroid and others, there is no shame in buying a Sony, and returning it for clouding. Clearly they can build them without the issue. Sony does want long term customers, and happy customers sell more TVs for them.

And every TV returned for a real issues, will get price lower for another customer who will either not care, or not care because the price is lower....or they refurb.

But if you are watching the opening to Star Wars and notice the Milkyway, where the milkway should not be....take it back....done
post #143 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by georgeorwell View Post

Are you on drugs? There are 3 people on this thread alone who have taken the set home and seen clouds....but yet you say everyone has not seen clouds.

Can we start calling you "tom baker the cloud expert"?

George you can use any type of wordspeak to describe me you choose. Not a single person has said....I went to look at the W and V and StoreX and the display unit had clouds. Every sample on display was not remarked on as anyone seeing clouds. So we know that on a reasonable sample across multiple cites, that units are produced as being cloud free.

Anyone wanting these sets, can buy them and have a reasonable expectation they will be without clouds. If there is an issue they can return the set. You can go and look at the last generation of XBRs and you have high odds of seeing clouds on the display unit.

since you asked.....
post #144 of 3234
I just don't think you can make the statement that you can "buy them with a reasonable expectation that they will be without clouds." You don't know that. Where is your data? Maybe you can, maybe you can't....time will tell. Maybe you should start a poll thread asking the question of people that actually buy the 3000 whether they have clouds, that will give you far better data.

Personally, I'm going to put much more value on the review of someone that has taken the set home and tried it, especially for something like clouds (which are masked by ambient light, particularly in places like Store X).
post #145 of 3234
so does anyone who has this tv sticking with it? and am contemplating jumping on it
post #146 of 3234
A week and a half on my 46W and no clouds.

Martinez,

I don't think I am going to stick with it. I am not happy with the clarity of the TV or the color. It is too orange/yellow. I fixed it the best I can with the white balance but I am still not happy. Vivid is the only mode that has good clarity and that is too "hot".
post #147 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by georgeorwell View Post

I just don't think you can make the statement that you can "buy them with a reasonable expectation that they will be without clouds." You don't know that. Where is your data? Maybe you can, maybe you can't....time will tell. Maybe you should start a poll thread asking the question of people that actually buy the 3000 whether they have clouds, that will give you far better data.

Personally, I'm going to put much more value on the review of someone that has taken the set home and tried it, especially for something like clouds (which are masked by ambient light, particularly in places like Store X).

There's no point arguing with an internet "expert", George. He has made all kinds of "absolute" and authoritative statments like that Sony's are clearly better than all sets from all other manufacturers, that no W sets have clouds, etc, etc, etc. Even if some of these statements are generally true, there is no way you can state them in such absolute terms.

Hopefully, forum readers are smart enough to spot misinformation when they see it. I'm with you, though, in that I have a desire to try to call people on BS so that someone else isn't misinformed. But what can you do?
post #148 of 3234
check out overview on this link guys. Do you find any thing wrong?

http://www.cdw.com/shop/products/def...px?EDC=1259772
post #149 of 3234
Quote:
Originally Posted by malikriz View Post

check out overview on this link guys. Do you find any thing wrong?

http://www.cdw.com/shop/products/def...px?EDC=1259772


What is a mac warehouse? Their price is lower than on the cdw main page. Why is that?

ohh i see it says 46 and 52 at the same time. They messed it up. I just called and the guy said they would correct it.
post #150 of 3234
Georgeorwell....i know you have tried the W3000 and after having it decided that for yourself the V2500 was a better product, namely that the colors on modes other than vivid were more realistic and that the set menu was also clearer. Another poster also mentioned colors were a concern on the W series, so i wouldn't want to jump for the W series and regret it afterwards.

Have you had experience in the showrroms with the V3000? I assume it is very close to the W3000 except that it uses a different DRC so maybe that makes a difference. Maybe the menu is clearer?....i don't know just asking.

I have a chance to pick up either a V2500 or a V3000 in a 46" for the same price through a contact (~2K), given the choice would you still pick up the V2500 or go for the V3000 line?

I'm in Canada and the showroom did not have the V3000 in a display as of yet. I know the V3000 is the new model for the V2500 so don't wish to wait too long as they will probably stop making the V2500 series at some point, also the reviews on the V2500 are very positive (minus clouding early sets) and we should all know what we would get with that product. However seeing the price i can get both sets for are identical i am hesitant to not get the newer set.

Anyone here purchased & reviewed the V3000 set?? That would help out tremendously......please.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: LCD Flat Panel Displays
AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › LCD Flat Panel Displays › Official Sony W3000 Series Thread