Quote:
Originally Posted by jcalabria 
I initially felt the same way with both my DV-980 and BDP-80 in conjunction with my Onkyo 876... older than yours, but still with a premium Reon scaler. Then I actually tested things. Turned out that the de-interlacing in the Mediatek chips was better than the Reon... less Moire issues.
All three of them were much better than any of the TVs (Samsung LCD, Panny plasma) I have had connected to that setup, so I ended up letting the Oppos handle the DVD scaling/deinterlacing and letting the Onkyo deal with the cable DVR. (Nice thing with the upper-end Onks is that you get to set that stuff per input rather than universally.)
The same may not hold true with the Marvell processor in your newer Onkyo but, if you really feel bad, you should test for yourself. The Oppo/Mediatek stuff does not do such a bad job.

I initially felt the same way with both my DV-980 and BDP-80 in conjunction with my Onkyo 876... older than yours, but still with a premium Reon scaler. Then I actually tested things. Turned out that the de-interlacing in the Mediatek chips was better than the Reon... less Moire issues.
All three of them were much better than any of the TVs (Samsung LCD, Panny plasma) I have had connected to that setup, so I ended up letting the Oppos handle the DVD scaling/deinterlacing and letting the Onkyo deal with the cable DVR. (Nice thing with the upper-end Onks is that you get to set that stuff per input rather than universally.)
The same may not hold true with the Marvell processor in your newer Onkyo but, if you really feel bad, you should test for yourself. The Oppo/Mediatek stuff does not do such a bad job.
Oh, absolutely--my prior machine was the Philips 5140, also a Mediatek chip, and I was very pleased with the scaling. Less than 720x486 divx files looked way better than they should have. Like I said, with my size set and the distance I sit, etc., it is unlikely I will be able to tell one from the other, but Moire issues drive me bananas--I will absolutely keep my eye peeled. The scaler in my LG tv is terrific, but deinterlacing leaves something to be desired. As long as my aspect ratio is correct and it isn't looking like VHS, I ain't terribly fussy.










Since then it's been doing duty in eitehr the second TV room or the bedroom.


Maybe if enough of us request it...