Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hyrax 
Kelson-
What I used to do is use VideoReDo (VDR) to create a MPG files and then use Ripbot to create AVCHD disks to play on my Blu-Ray player. That is time consuming (8+ hours to transcode a football game on core 2 computer), but produces excellent results. I just got the new VRD that supports .H264 encoding and it looks as though I'll use it to write .m2ts files, if I decide to use disks. I'll then use tsMuxer to create AVCHD disks.
However, I've started to use StreamBaby to send Mp4 encodings to the Tivo instead of using disks. It really is a lot easier. I need to play with version 4 of VRD to see what the options are for audio encoding - it appears that MP4 files only support stereo.
since you're no longer burning to disks, why not just go back to streaming the mpg files?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hyrax 
I've used VRD for years and love it, but there is a problem with its commercial skip. The commercial skip does a 99% perfect job, but still needs careful editing on your part. I cannot tell you the number of important scenes in a show or plays in a game that I accidentally lost because I didn't take the time to make sure I was only cutting commercials.
I have to tell you that, because I am able to use .H264 encoding and use StreamBaby to send the recordings to my Tivo, I no longer cut commercials.
Not sure I understand this either. Why
not cut commercials? Does encoding with .H264 somehow disallow or become too complicated to do when it is presented with an mpg file that has edit points where commercials have been removed?
As background for why I am asking these questions, I started out reading a few of your posts as you seem to have used most or at least be familiar with many of the free conversion software tools, in addition to the pay-for program, VideoReDo.
Before taking that purchasing plunge, I wanted to make sure that the use of VideoReDo hasn't become "quaint" among any segment of current or former users who now look to other free software tools to get the job done just as well, better or for cheaper.
Particularly people that work a lot with .tivo/mpg files and who perform relatively basic editing of those files (i.e., removing commercials and sometimes splicing them down further to isolate segments which are then merged with other segments or disparate scenes, for the purpose of creating highlight packages).