AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Home Theater Computers › Suppose I make it easy for all the newbies and budget folks?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Suppose I make it easy for all the newbies and budget folks? - Page 4

post #91 of 1046
Quote:
Originally Posted by pcCinema View Post

...

Quote:


I had thought of the same thing, and all the demo versions of software, but you do have to have permission to include them in any kind of distribution even if you share them free and don't alter anything from what I've figured out so for.

Anytime you are not the end user for a product, hardware or software, you fall into the mucky grey world of resellers, OEM partners, distributors, managed ASP provider etc etc, where the licensing and NDAs and what not kick in.

The problem is not that they don't wanna give permision, the problem is (more times than often) they CAN'T. Why? Because that will violate their agreements with OTHER vendors. For e.g. Dell. (and I'm just picking one). This is a vast grey area.

Quote:


From what I can tell open license stuff GNU/GPL can be distributed on our disks just fine.

That would seem to be true.

Quote:


It's all very tricky when you really start reading the fine print on this stuff.

If it was simple, a lot of lawyers would be out of business.
post #92 of 1046
Troy,
As far as I'm concerned, please take all the time you need on this. Better slow and right than fast and unworkable.

But regardless of how quickly you accomplish the mission, the present LG GGW-H10N dual-format drive is still around $1k, I think, and I simply don't want to pay that much for a drive. So I will be waiting for one of these two drives to be released by LG very soon:
http://www.engadget.com/2007/07/19/l...id-drives-and/

and also described here on July 29:
http://www.dvd-intelligence.com/main...new_hybrid.htm

The article on the latter link states "LG is about to launch later this quarter ................"

The month of July is in the 3rd quarter and the month of August ends that quarter, so LG could potentially release their two new dual-format drives in the next ten days. But who knows, maybe it will be somewhat later and, if so, I'm fully prepared to wait.

I think waiting for a next-gen, dual format drive is better than now buying two first-gen single-format drives, or two external USB or firewire dirves, etc.
___________________________________

As far as providing a simple ISO disk to potential users goes, rather than doing that at all, I think most folks interested in getting an HTPC (as opposed to a far more simple stand-alone box), are competent enough to carry out written step-by-step instructions on how to configure their systems.

This would of course be similar to what has been done many times on this forum in the past - usually based around a specific motherboard and, maybe, video card.

To me, the beauty of what you propose is that you are volunteering to be the guinea pig - the person who will build a HTPC that plays (and zooms) both HD formats perfectly, and, most importantly, report to others every nitpicking step it took to achieve that perfection.

I think the main difference between this and other threads could be that all of those concerned are committing to obtain IDENTICAL components and software. That being the case, what works for the prototype will (with likewise identical software configuration) certainly work on every other identical machine.

This must be precisely what computer companies like HP and Dell do. While documenting every single step, they develop a prototype "model" that does what they want it to do and then stamp them out like cookies. Everything identical on a particular model. Their last step in production must be to install that ISO disk that automatically configures everything on the individual machine (or the hard drive is put in the machine already configured) every time it boots up.

Because of whatever legal issue with the ISO sofware, again, it may simply be necessary for each builder to do that configuration by following a list of step-by-step instructions. I'm sure I could handle that, and I'll bet others could, too.

Now............... a .doc that contained those written instructions might be considered by many people to be valuable thing - something worth maybe some dollars, and maybe something in the end worth far more to its author than any ISO disk. In short, you could sell your magic recipe for HD-playback perfection.

I think I'm now up to eight cents.
post #93 of 1046
Does anyone know if either of the dual format drives referenced above will read material from an HD DVD recordable or a DVD recordable with HD DVD content? An earlier hybrid drive, apparently, would not. I have a collection of single and double layer DVD's with HD DVD content.

I almost pulled the trigger on a set of home theater components (including the Antec NSK2480 case mentioned earlier), an Asus P5B-VM-DO microATX mobo (which I'm currently also using in an UnRaid system), Core2Duo CPU, etc.), but was kinda waiting for the dual drive from LG to hit. If you want another guinea pig on such parts, I'd be happy to bite on this stuff now and see how well it works. I already have an Asus 8600 GT, fanless, running in another PC, so I could easily move parts around to begin some experimenting now. I actually wanted to get an ATI 2600XT, but the driver situation on that card seems like a real mess right now.
post #94 of 1046
Thread Starter 
The way I'm handling the project is exactly the same process we used to use for corporate hardware and software rollouts. We tested systems meticulously, standardized on a stable hardware platform, worked on a master software build and meticulously tested that, then created either master gold images or unatend.txt style installs. The unatended installs would be set to autologon when finished and start a first script in the startup group. It would autologon admin for the local pc and start the first script, which then installs something and then calls script after script to do silent installs of each software package and when needed re-booting between installs and carrying on. When finished it would append a text file on a server somewhere to list it as finished and you could just watch the text file grow as systems came on line.

There is the same process used today everywhere for standardizing desktops in corporate environments but now there are also tools like nlite and remote deployment and all kinds of newer goodies I'll have to catch up on.

One of the reasons for the ISO's that I wanted to include was so they could include automatic diagnostics like memtest or whatever, or automatically have windows carry out it's new memory tests. Plus like I said before it could update the bios and set all the settings to safe and proper levels. A lot of problems could be avoided I think if it just did that for people and made sure the hardware was stable and set up right before it installed anything to begin with including testing the hdd and sata controller well. No point in getting started on a system if it's not tested and set up right to begin with.

Much of the process has changed though with vista especially and many software programs don't seem to even support good old silent installs. I will have a lot of research to do in this area and help wouldn't hurt if anyone has advice on a newer better way to do things.

Honestly I do not intend to buy a blueray or hd-dvd drive now unless I have to. I may get an xbox hd-dvd for testing and then flip it on ebay when I'm done but the plan is more likely to just test with high bitrate sample and demo clips off the HDD.

I'll be damned if I'll pay $1000 for a drive that we all know will be $150 or less in a year or so. Not counting the fact I can't possibly even afford it. And of course the first models are never as good as after it's matured a bit and the bugs are worked out, but the ones coming out around xmas should be mature and stable enough to make me want one. I didn't even notice it was that much so we'll certainly scratch that off the list. The new multi format drives coming out are supposed to be around $300 or less aren't they? I think I read that somewhere.

I might be tempted to keep the xbox drive though if I buy it...

As long as the system can play samples without a hiccup that should be totally fine.

Step by step directions are a large part of the scope of this project and I know they will be much appreciated and well used by all kinds of people. The automation is just an extension of those and because I want to do it, I like to do things like that. Don't ask me why I don't even know.

I want to support the newer ATI cards but I am also leery of doing so until lots of problems are resolved I keep hearing about.

I don't even have a new card of either brand. I'm still on a 9800pro on my main system which I have been extremely happy with all along.

I don't have any kind of demo or sample clips to play so if anyone can point me to really good very high bitrate stuff that would help. Whatever you know of that is the absolute toughest of each file type. I have no rips or any of that stuff.

Troy
post #95 of 1046
Quote:
Originally Posted by pcCinema View Post

I don't have any kind of demo or sample clips to play so if anyone can point me to really good very high bitrate stuff that would help. Whatever you know of that is the absolute toughest of each file type. I have no rips or any of that stuff.

Movie trailers are often good. "The Greatest Game Ever Played" 1080p trailer is considered one of the toughest. Apple.com has a lot of trailers, but they can be found lots of places, of course. And having mentioned Apple, I can't believe how horribly the Quicktime player plays those clips.

A decent mpeg2 1080i OTA clip is here: http://samples.mplayerhq.hu/HDTV/LingerieBowl.ts It has some glitches in it which can be a good test.

Unless the hardware goals were changed and I missed the post, I think the talk of overclocked 3ghz Core2Duos and 2gb of memory is overkill and also probably not practical. There isn't that big a deal for playing files between a 1.6ghz C2D and a 3.0ghz C2D, and OC'ing to 3ghz, while common, isn't a walk in the park particularly for someone who needs what is being talked about in this thread anyway.

The only time I truly need 2gb of memory in XP is when multitasking with some heavy hitters such as encoding a file while also having 20 browser windows open while also playing a game, and the browsers and game take up most of that. A straight-up HTCP is fine with 1gb. Maybe 2gb for Vista, don't know, since I'm trying my best to stay away from it.

For software, I'd think the only main problem is with Windows since for everything else there is a free alternative. VLC player, Media Player Classic, GBPVR, Media Portal, there's plenty of good and free encoders, etc.
post #96 of 1046
Thread Starter 
I don't think you're quite following along or you just skipped to the end.

I need blueray and hd-dvd encoded demo clips to test. I have loads of 1080i. The goal of the system is to play everything, regardless of me not buying a drive right away. X-mas is coming.

Plus you're off on how easy overclocking is. It all depends on which processor you use, for the right ones it is a _complete_ walk in the park. Period. I get 2.66 ghz with my e4300 on two of the absolute cheapest motherboards ever made and all it takes is raising the FSB from 200 to 266. Nothing else. One bios setting. Done.
If my current motherboards were even half decent they'd go much higher on the FSB and 3ghz plus would also be just as easy.

It makes no sense at all to not overclock or to buy a c2d that doesn't easily overclock. Where people have trouble overclocking is when the make the wrong processor decision with a multiplier that's tough to handle or they intentionally go down that path for more FSB performance on purpose. Then they have to go crazy with expensive ram and pick a motherboard that handles being pushed like mad and mess with voltages and it becomes a real effort. We won't be doing that.

Cooling is not even an issue, a stock HSF is fine.

Plus the project is aimed at gaming power and just overall system power.

The amount of ram is optional, but ram is cheap too... That's up to the builder. Vista will eat it up.

Troy
post #97 of 1046
Troy, if need be, I can rip some BD, HD DVD movies (it would be too much work to try and shrink them down to trailers or a chapter or two), and put them up on my server, with a login so you can download them for testing.

You'll have to promise to delete them when you're done testing..
post #98 of 1046
Troy,

Sounds like a great idea as from what I've seen setting up a system isn't even that trivial for the experienced. On a related note, at MeediOS is a project called BluePill to create an auto updating self configuring HTPC system. The two projects may have something to learn from each other.

http://www.meedios.com/forum/viewtop...er=asc&start=0
post #99 of 1046
Quote:
Originally Posted by pcCinema View Post

I don't think you're quite following along or you just skipped to the end.

I need blueray and hd-dvd encoded demo clips to test. I have loads of 1080i. The goal of the system is to play everything, regardless of me not buying a drive right away. X-mas is coming.

Plus you're off on how easy overclocking is. It all depends on which processor you use, for the right ones it is a _complete_ walk in the park. Period. I get 2.66 ghz with my e4300 on two of the absolute cheapest motherboards ever made and all it takes is raising the FSB from 200 to 266. Nothing else. One bios setting. Done.
If my current motherboards were even half decent they'd go much higher on the FSB and 3ghz plus would also be just as easy.

It makes no sense at all to not overclock or to buy a c2d that doesn't easily overclock. Where people have trouble overclocking is when the make the wrong processor decision with a multiplier that's tough to handle or they intentionally go down that path for more FSB performance on purpose. Then they have to go crazy with expensive ram and pick a motherboard that handles being pushed like mad and mess with voltages and it becomes a real effort. We won't be doing that.

Cooling is not even an issue, a stock HSF is fine.

Plus the project is aimed at gaming power and just overall system power.

The amount of ram is optional, but ram is cheap too... That's up to the builder. Vista will eat it up.

Troy

OCing my 4300 on an Asus P5B Plus was exactly as easy as you describe. It OCed to 3 GHZ with one BIOS setting and the standard HSF. It's almost always that easy with the 4300, from what I've read. Using Corsair PC6400 RAM ($89 on sale for 2 GB) assured it. I read a review in which that little chip survived OCing WITHOUT its HSF. Core2Duo rocks.
post #100 of 1046
Quote:
Originally Posted by pcCinema View Post

Motherboard selection is proving itself to be the most difficult , so still working on that. I'd very much appreciate any and all your suggestions for anything you think deserves a look. There are several new boards that haven't quite hit the shelves yet that sound VERY promising, but this project can only be based on proven (not promising) hardware. uATX requirement and not wanting to give up any features are tough to balance. I want lots of usb2 ports, firewire, at least one ata100 and many SATA connectors, at least one eSATA connector, SPDIF optical or digital or both on motherboard or from headers, 7.1 channels of analog, two pci slots minimum that won't be blocked by the 8500gt with a fan on it, room for at least one of the very large quiet HSF budget oriented combinations, x16 pcie slot that is not blocked for full length cards. So forth and so on.

Hi Troy,

How about the MSI P6N SLI-Fi motherboard? I bought one to replace that ASROCK I sent to you and it has been stellar for me. Everything worked the way it was supposed to right from the start, including the SPDIF optical output to my receiver, which simply plugged in to my receiver's digital input and started working without the hours of tweaking needed to get my Chaintech AV-710 working. It has every feature you want except onboard video (unnecessary since you're anticipating adding an nVidia 8xxx series card) and an e-sata port (can be easily added on). It's $106 so it's not an ECS-class card price-wise, but it's also not a $200+ Asus, either. Biggest complaint seems to be that the northbridge runs hot, which may be the culprit with a number of crashing boards people are reporting, but it seems that you simply attach the heasink better or add a small fan and you are set for some very decent overclocking. I've got mine running at stock with a D805 (don't need anything faster at the moment to run my Infocus 4805 854x480 projector but will be upgrading to a 720p projector within a few weeks), but one of the Newegg reviewers mentioned OC'ing a P6N SL-Fi to 3.15gHz with an e4300 and it idles at 22C, which is very good in anyone's book.


http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16813130082

Incidentally, your Non-Profit Home Theater PC Company is a great idea.
post #101 of 1046
I am and am not a newbie but I think its a great idea. I have been messing around with pcs for a long time and I know what they can do.I wanted to get a 360 or ps3 but I can do more with an htpc.I would love to donate myself hope it comes soon because I havent started my htpc just yet but my pc is a media pc
post #102 of 1046
Quote:
Originally Posted by lousygolfer View Post

Hi Troy,

How about the MSI P6N SLI-Fi motherboard? I bought one to replace that ASROCK I sent to you and it has been stellar for me. Everything worked the way it was supposed to right from the start, including the SPDIF optical output to my receiver, which simply plugged in to my receiver's digital input and started working without the hours of tweaking needed to get my Chaintech AV-710 working. It has every feature you want except onboard video (unnecessary since you're anticipating adding an nVidia 8xxx series card) and an e-sata port (can be easily added on). It's $106 so it's not an ECS-class card price-wise, but it's also not a $200+ Asus, either. Biggest complaint seems to be that the northbridge runs hot, which may be the culprit with a number of crashing boards people are reporting, but it seems that you simply attach the heasink better or add a small fan and you are set for some very decent overclocking. I've got mine running at stock with a D805 (don't need anything faster at the moment to run my Infocus 4805 854x480 projector but will be upgrading to a 720p projector within a few weeks), but one of the Newegg reviewers mentioned OC'ing a P6N SL-Fi to 3.15gHz with an e4300 and it idles at 22C, which is very good in anyone's book.


http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16813130082

Incidentally, your Non-Profit Home Theater PC Company is a great idea.

I thought we wanted to stick with mATX. Alot of the really nice AV HTPC cases only take mATX.
post #103 of 1046
Thread Starter 
Correct.

Project may stay on hold until the Asrock 4core1333, the g35 based uATX, or another solution comes out.

I don't like what's out right now for Micro ATX and it should be a mere matter of days or even a couple weeks max.

This non-profit plan is to be all set up as long before x-mas as possible for all the people who will get geeky new toys like me.

There are all kinds of computer and Home Theater companies who want to bend you over and steal your wallet practically, then there are most that are just a bit too expensive for the average joe, but there is nothing non-profit I am aware of.

The goal is to be a completely non-biased user based organization dedicated to giving anyone at any level the best performance and experience possible and try to match things only the affluent can afford.

HOWEVER I am running into some real problems and the whole non-profit thing no matter how noble a cause it may have been may not happen.

Regardless the project will press on.

Troy
post #104 of 1046
Thread Starter 
I'll check into the meedios thing, thank you.

Troy
post #105 of 1046
Can we do a ball-park estimate of what a custom HTPC will likely cost? My last HTPC build - about 4 years ago - ended up costing approximately $1600. I think this one might very well be about the same.

Assuming that the new LG drives actually cost LG's announced price - $400 for the ROM and $500 for the BR-writer-HD-DVD-reader - we start off at that point and go onward and upward. How much is an OEM version of Vista, $150 to $200?
So:

D. Format Drive..$400
OS...................$200
Misc. SW...........$150
MB...................$125
Case................$100
RAM.................$100
8600GTS...........$180
PS...................$80
Cooling.............$80?
KB+mouse..........$60?

Total around $1475?

Please let me know if I've missed something, or I'm way off on any of my estimates, because I just pulled those numbers out of thin air. I wouldn't mind a bit if the total were much lower, but considering the cost of the drive and OS alone, I doubt like heII if we're going to get out of this for under $1k.

Once the MB and OS are decided (and maybe RAM and video card, too), it might be economically beneficial to investigate so-called "bare bone" systems that might contain some of the same major components but cost less than buying them individually. But maybe not. It's been a long time since I've done this.

Also, if all of the components could be bought individually from a single e-tailer, then maybe one could ask for a "package" (reduced) price, but that might be fruitless, too.

Maybe a "group buy" for one or more components?
__________________________________________

HP already has what they call a media center PC that can be configured with the LG GGW-H10N drive. Below is a link to their m8100y model PC. If you hit the "customize" button on the right side of the page, you are then presented with all of the upgrade options on the base PC - including the dual-format drive.

http://www.shopping.hp.com/webapp/sh...=m8100y_series

Selecting the dual format drive (for an additional $600) and the necessary upgraded video card makes the grand total somewhere close to $1579.

I don't know if that HP will even boot up flawlessly, let alone play HD or SD disks, so buying it would be a complete gamble.

It is worthy to note, however, how much less HP charges for the dual format drive, as compared to what it costs from a retailer - $400 less. Maybe when LG's new drives hit the market they'll also be much less from HP as add-ons. If the new dual-format ROM-only drive was a $200 option, then the total price of HP's pc would drop $400 to around $1200 - not a bad price, especially if it does the job.
___________________________________________________

Anyway, just thinking out loud here, but I think it would be worthwhile for everyone to realize that they're more than likely going to spend at least a grand for their HTPC.

Edit: I forgot the CPU and hard drive! Tack on whatever!
post #106 of 1046
Thread Starter 
As I planned to build it, and as my current systems are now based.

$120 cpu Core2duo e4300 (the easy overclocker) or Pentium D 805 o/c'd for even less but it's not as nice as a core2 in any way. Then there's even the celeron D if you just don't need horsepower for games and blueray/hd-dvd. All of these are dual core, it really makes no sense at all to go with a p4 socket 775 single core unless you just already have one.
$65 motherboard (I'm currently running $25 and free boards)
$100 hard drive (Can be found lower, used drives and small drives are almost nothing if you don't mind the noise and small capacity.)
$50 to whatever Ram
$120 or less video card (can be much less, just onboard free video for HTPC use only with the right new board if that works out. Current onboard video solutions are only really ok for DVD and ATSC HD.)
$25 mce remote
$30 optical dvd-rw
$50 or less case and power supply (people over do it on the power supply all the time, in reality a new 8600gt and e4300 at 3ghz doesn't take that much and on board video much less.)
$30 low end wireless logitech set
$3 fan (too funny) shipping it would cost more than buying it
Rechargeable high power batteries are a good idea for heavy users of wireless mice and keyboards, but you have to be sure to get better than typical Nimh or 1.2v stuff since they don't like those. An expense often overlooked. Built in to high end sets.
$25 or so for the Corldess Rumblepad 2 if you want wireless gaming. Mine still has it's first set of rechargeable batteries in it from several months ago when I bought it and still not dead and haven't charged them yet. Very nice power management.

Add whatever software and the OS will cost. Anyone with a child in school or college or going to school themselves (I think a certain number of credits are required) qualifies for Academic versions of Windows at great savings. Vista Ultimate is around $200 or less, I haven't checked in a while and the price goes down for lesser versions like just premium. Also there is discount software all over ebay if you know how to spot the legitimate stuff from the pirated stuff. Make sure it comes with a real certificate with real hologram and has not been used before. Software like PowerDVD etc is often unbundled from the optical drives it came with and sold seperately too and you can save a whole lot there. Also lots of folks buy and part out Dell's etc and sell the licenses off by themselves like they do the rest of the parts. Again though you have to be really careful to avoid pirated stuff and I don't know what the legal situation is on that unbundling. I think they are at least breaking some rules but perhaps not really breaking the law. Someone else will have to tell us. With activation requirements I don't think an unbundled Vista would even work. Be careful in this area.

Add maybe $30 tops misc accessories like a blank 4u rackmount cover, nice handles, and VFD to turn a cheap plastic face desktop into looking like expensive rackmount gear or others can just buy a nicer looking case to start with. (this is my current case I spent less than $10 for the case and maybe $5 for the rackmount cover and $5 for the handles and $25 for the huge VFD, and then ripped apart junk I had for cables and other little bits like a volume knob and buttons.)

Much of this is using sale prices but no mail in rebate stuff. It's also assuming you get free shipping like from newegg a lot of the time or you'll have to add that up too and if you're not careful shipping alone will add up fast.

The idea had been to have links to sales and yes maybe even get companies to compete for bundle prices.

Optical drive prices are going to dramatically drop soon, for now it could just be the xbox hd-dvd for whatever the lowest is that can be found at or just leave it out.

A good Dell or other manufacturers systems at a good sale or whatever are hard to beat, aside from having to rebuild the OS and usually they don't give you a good video card you have to add it in. Be careful sometimes their motherboards don't have a slot to even upgrade the video card. They pay next to nothing for a lot of massive bulk stuff and the OS is so cheap for them you would literally be sick. If only the consumer paid the same prices for parts and software.

Computers are pretty much becoming a necessity, especially if you have kids in the home and want them to have any sort of a decent future. Too bad there is no low income program to get windows or whatever.

The best way to build a cheap system is to pounce on the sales and try to get everything at rock bottom prices and avoid shipping, you can collect the parts cheap that way and build it when you finally have enough stuff. Sales (not mail in rebates) can cut the price of a system in half or a quarter if you manage it right.

Mail in rebates aside from taking forever or not working at all just get your name and personal info out to the junk mailers and telemarketers.

Craigslist is a good source of used parts for anyone really scraping the bottom of the barrel, like a used case or hard drive or dvd drive etc but you need to know what you're getting and understand that it doesn't make sense to spend much there when new parts on the right sales might make more sense in the bang for the buck dept, and used stuff is not as silent of course.

Also online retailers have rebate codes, and special promotions. There are sites dedicated to rebate codes and such. I noticed someone talking about a rebate code a week or two ago in this forum for Newegg that was 20% off of any purchase over $100 if you paid with Paypal and used rebate code "paypal", so I immediately went over to Newegg and had some fun shopping and decided I would buy their WD 500Gb Sata2 drive that the project will use. It was already on special for $109 with free shipping and after instant rebate code then it turned out to be $89.99. It was a toss up on whether to get a video card or a hard drive, but I needed more space more than the video card at that moment. I am pretty sure that rebate code is over.

Troy
post #107 of 1046
We could call this Project Helen. You know, 'cos it's of Troy.
post #108 of 1046
Wish I would have stumbled on this thread sooner. I purchased all my parts from Newegg and Tigerdirect last week. Assembled them all today and was reading up while XP MCE is installing (well, almost since the drive is still formatting.

Due to the same issues you mention with MOBO's I decided to go ahead with an ATX setup using the ABIT IP35 Pro (I have a 42U rack in my utility room which holds all my HT gear so size, appearance and noise level are moot). Solid MB with pretty good feature set and very easy to OC (if I need to).

I also settled on C2D E6550. Total cost with case, 650W PS, DVD/RW, 2GB Dual Channel RAM, 8500GT and 320GB SATA HD was $810. If the praybates come back the cost will be $670.

I have both an XBOX 360 Elite and PS3 for HD media playback so I will use this system (at least on the outset) as a media server to the XBOX and it will also be replacing my relic P3 XEON server which I currently use to backup all of the clients in my house. I will wait for combo burners to hit the $250 mark before adding that capability.

I am very interested in how this project progresses. If you can get a solid system tuned for playback that I could deploy in my great room I would definitely consider it as an option. With everything else I have going I just do not have time to fiddle with the software and settings to get a solid user friendly system up and running.

Thanks for your ambition in this regard. I hope to be a future contributer to your cause,

JD
post #109 of 1046
Hi Troy, I setup a skeleton demo site http://auto-workz.com/home_theater/ Let me know if this is the basic structure you were looking for.
post #110 of 1046
Quote:
Originally Posted by pc1984 View Post

Hi Troy, I setup a skeleton demo site http://auto-workz.com/home_theater/ Let me know if this is the basic structure you were looking for.

I'm not Troy, but I, for one, am very very impressed with what you've done. Congratulations.
post #111 of 1046
Quote:
Originally Posted by pc1984 View Post

Hi Troy, I setup a skeleton demo site http://auto-workz.com/home_theater/ Let me know if this is the basic structure you were looking for.

Very nice. What a great start!

OK, who can translate the Latin?
post #112 of 1046
hey guys this is looking great. as soon as i get my parts in i would like to see some help for software support. keep up the great work.
post #113 of 1046
Thread Starter 
Ok so you are the webmaster. No make that Web Master. One catch though, you need to be willing to mentor backup webmasters time permitting and if they desire to learn.

We bow to the Web Master

Thank you so much for all your work.

Well, that is I guess unless GreenIguana is still working on something to wow us too. Do you waive the white flag sir or will there be a fight to the death?

Troy
post #114 of 1046
Hi Troy,

I think you have a great idea, that you should follow.

I'm build my first HTPC a few years ago and I'm still trying to optimize my PC setup regarding picture quality and ease-of-use. One the one hand its fun, on the other hand I feel sometimes like a guinea pig.

Recently I switched to Vista Ultimate 64bit and I thought I can build a nice installation DVD with vlite, comparable what I've done with nlite and MCE 2005. But right now vlite is just a deletion program for Vista features

Then I read this thread and some ideas came up into my mind:

A basic 'HTPClite' Vista DVD (with a recommended profile) with all Updates, newest drivers for the recommended software, pre-installed (free) codecs (incl. post-processing filters) for different video-formats would be already a huge leap ahead.

Newbies would be able to have a basic HTPC that plays all video files smoothly on a solid system and advanced users can customize their system even further, but with less effort to configure the basic system.

The 'HTPClite' project could be based on the MS Anytime Upgrade DVDs/ISO (works for 30days and key can be bought separately). Therefore you are on the legal side, and any user would be able to test the system first, before buying the license from MS.

In addition I think it might be a great idea to develop a second project 'HTPClite Server' that might be based on Windows Home Server to build a home media network with several HTPCs and a central server.

'dreaming': insert the DVD in the server -> install -> install HTPC client system via network from the server ...

Just my 2 cents

Cheers,
Alex

P.S. My current 'biggest bang for the buck HTPC client system' ATX size

Motherboard: Gigabyte P35-DS4 with DTS Connect onboard and many more features
CPU: Intel E2140 @ 2.93Ghz, but the E4300 should have a higher chance for hitting the 3 Ghz (or the new E6550 with 4MB Cache which should easily run >3Ghz
GPU: HIS HD 2600 XT IceQ Turbo, which has a good cooling system

Other recommended parts from my own experience:
Power Supply: Antec Earthwatts 380W (80+ efficiency) (cheap and cool)
HDD: WD 5000AAKS (what you said: silent and fast)
Case: Silverstone LC20M + Zalman 9500 Cooler (the case comes with Soundgraph remote control, that also can be used as a mouse - the case also has a display and it never has been that easy to achieve a stable standby via remote, due to the fact that there is a special bypass cable to the power supply)
RAM: the cheapest 2x1GB DDR2-800 will be fine for the FSB200 CPUs

Soundcard: I currently have a Club3D Theatron DTS, but I'm not able to get the Vista 64bit drivers to work - C-Media not even has a driver for Vista

Optical Drive: the new LG drive for Blue-Ray AND HD-DVD is on my next purchase list

TV-card: I'm from Germany and I use a Technotrend TT-3200S DVB-S2 card to watch HD-television
post #115 of 1046
Hi Troy,

Project Helen is a great idea. I am new to htpc and it seems like a continual minefield. I am using my home pc to learn and test software and hardware for an eventual htpc build. The only thing I have learned so far is that nothing just works. If you could simplify this process I and thousands of others would be greatly appreciative. Whatever happens this thread is my first stop now when I turn on the PC.

Cheers Bill
post #116 of 1046
Hi Troy I'm binary64 from www.MeediOS.com.

First, a 25.5gb archive of 'weird' media can be found at ftp://samples.mplayerhq.hu/MPlayer/samples /MPlayer/samples - everything from 120fps to HD EVO's to buggy media. I downloaded it to help me test an 'ultimate htpc' list of codecs.

I'd love to get involved in this somehow. I just ask that you first check out my Bluepill .iso in perhaps VMware. First of all, someone downloads the "iso maker" which uses users own XP CD and Key to create thier own .iso. The aim is: Burn and boot the iso on a blank machine, and zero clicks later, you're watching live TV !!

The Bluepill thread is at http://www.meedios.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=851
The ISO Maker is at http://www.meedios.com/forum/download.php?id=646
And the update xml script Bluepill uses, (most useful for technical people wishing to see how Bluepill works without installing it), is at http://www.meedios.com/bluepill/update2.xml it should explain a lot here.

My aim was to use XP Pro as the base (cost $10 on ebay). People with dual tuners would need their MCE2005 CD handy. Then reshape www.driverpacks.net to a SVN server, so that drivers can be downloaded and installed individually on-demand. Eventually, Bluepill can run on Vista I guess.

Using GEOIP services, to determine your local country, I was then planning on using a wikiD database (another invention of mine) ( http://www.meedios.com/wikiD/view.ph...se=GeoRegional ) to then work out what timezone, keyboard, culture, language, and even local (national) DVB-T frequencies... which would then be auto-scanned and xmltv integrated etc. I've started this, and it uses MP's TVengine3 for the scanning.

Once finally booted, it boots into a "Master Setup" menu, to basically ask for extra info like screen res (not all TV's have EDID), number of speakers, and user/pass's to extra services like last.fm, then once saved, boots straight into Meedio, with all the icing on the cake. I was also imagining having some folks so user could choose between the available front-ends, and TV backends. Frontends would include MCE2005, VistaMCE, Meedio, Media Portal, MeediOS, even a "Windows/WMP" for a computery feel. Backends are plentiful too; Sage, Meedio, tvengine3, gbpvr, etc.. oh, and MCE's.

I'm hoping we could team up or bounce some ideas. It's good to see you've started with the hardware, as I've worked hard on the software-only Bluepill for a while (but with no help).

BTW, I'm fully opensource @ https://meedios.svn.sourceforge.net/...ugins/binary64
and support free software whereever possible. Where payware is better, i implement the freeware alternative as the base, and let user decide to upgrade when they want.
post #117 of 1046
As far a building a HTPC, one of the things that people often want to customize is the case, perhaps a quiet PSU, etc., but most of what people might want to customize wouldn't affect the core recommendation of motherboard, OS, & video. So as long as the core recommendation is followed, a standard set of recommended software should still be installable via scripts, to keep it fairly idiot proof.

Obviously the recommendations should include a everything needed, case, PSU, hard drive(s), RAM, etc. as well as the core components that would affect the ability to run the scripts. That way someone could still do their customization of some things (to make the HTPC their own to meet what they want), but still stay with the core recommendation products that would affect scripts and software performance.

Ben
post #118 of 1046
Yeah, the core requirements that evolved so far for bluepill is:-

* Nvidia, Intel or ATI graphics only (or manual intervention)
* 1 GB memory
* 20 GB for hard disk and must be C:
* Near-permanent internet connectivity
* No rtl/wide char support
* 32bit OS

plus the common sense items, espesially for HD, which are cpu >3ghz, hard disk >20 Mbps, network >100 Mbps
post #119 of 1046
addition: i tried compiling a 'standard' htpc order list too (uk orientated) @ http://www.meedios.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=959 - it's very amateurish compared to what you've got going here (esp, on the hardware side of things), but someone may be able to grab a tiny tip out of it.
post #120 of 1046
Hi,

I've long lurked here a long time and posted rarely, but this adventure is very, very worth while.
I've built & run multiple HTPC's for 4 years now based on the Microsoft platform.
At last count there where about 85 (yes, 85) different software "packages" that I have to install if I'm building at HTPC from scratch. PM if you want a list.

Can I put in a big requirement in for very, very high WAF (Wife Approval Factor) on any & everything - solve this one & I'm right their with a donation.
Seriously - it has to be absolutely rock solid with a completely consistent
interface.
Change between MCE2005 and PDVD does my wife's head in - she is definitely non-computer literate. All she wants to see is a 10 foot interface and a remote control - that it, nothing else, EVERYTHING through the 10 foot interface, not glitches, not mouse, no keyboard.

Also, I second the "keep it, small & minimal" if for no other reason than power/heat consumption.
My main HTPC runs all day playing music & all night playing movies and watching TV - heat is a problem in my land.
The less watts it uses the better - the less heat to recool.

I'm not a gamer.
Gaming needs power, which equals heat, which equals noise.
I'd suggest a "minimal" config that does NOT address gaming, then add to it for those wanting gaming.
The most basic config needs to be stand-up to the $200 BR/HD player that will be here by X-mas and blow it out of the water for picture quality, sound quality and flexibility i.e. play every format known to man-kind.

I'm personally against OCing - its the heat/noise thing again.
OCing also shortens the life of hardware, considerably in some cases.
When I build my next batch of HTPCs for BR/HD playback, I don't want to touch them for at least 3 years - WAF again and I just don't have the time.

Also, I just don't think OCing is necessary anymore to meet the non-gaming HTPC requirements.
All the reading I've done, says that with new ATI x2000 series cards mean, there is little need for anything more than a Celeron D for BR/HD playback, once the bugs in the drivers are sorted - almost there now with registry hacks.

I'm seriously looking at "no-moving" parts for my next HTPC build - all passive, no fans, solid state disk drive, but no fancy case, just big air holes to let the heat out and you can have big holes cause there is no noise - main storage on a media server.

Having multiple HTPC means a media server is a must, one HTPC is never enough.

Regards,

Neeto
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Home Theater Computers
AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Home Theater Computers › Suppose I make it easy for all the newbies and budget folks?