Originally Posted by mjg100
He did not deny that he is Bugs Bunny either. Does that mean that he is Bugs Bunny?
Did anyone accuse him of being Bugs Bunny? Go write a post and say:
"amir, as you are Bugs Bunny, can you tell me if any of the classic WB cartoons will come out in HD?"
Originally Posted by Slaine
Oh give it a rest dude. What is it with this constant desire some people have to "entrap" insiders? You take what they say and twist it to try and prove that you've caught them in a lie. In this particular case, Amir basically said he didn't know if these releases were genuine or not (Given that other Studio Canal Blu-Ray releases were pulled at the last minute) and that people would have to wait and see. And somehow you turn that into "Amir is trying to deceive us and prevent us from knowing the truth about Studio Canal releases on Blu-Ray".
Get a grip.
Sheesh. WTF is with people?
Amir has strongly implied that he believes Studio Canal is HD DVD exclusive. Someone said Amir had said he thought they were exclusive. I tried to find that post and instead found the ones I point to. I could certainly see someone reading a post form Amir in which he responds to someone saying that Studio Canal is HD DVD exclusive misremembering it sometime later as Amir saying such.
I would hope the insiders would correct any obviously false information presented to them. I did not ask Amir jack. Well, I did ask him if Microsoft fixed the bug that caused 360s to transform and kill their owners in their sleep. I also asked him if MS planned to try and crack BD+ because a post he kept too pithy implied that.
In my opinion, the Insiders thread is the worst on this forum. You have Amir trying to trap the BD insiders and acting like he decides if P/DW can be reopened instead of the mods, Dave Vaughn coming in and not naming sources and spouting all the latest HD DVD talking points, Paid and Talk misrepresenting things because they are not all up on the specs and damn near every post in there from the regular forum members is trying to trick, trap, confuse or otherwise impede the insiders. Far better are every thread in the BD and HD DVD forums where people try to help each other get the most out of their equipment and recommend movies to each other.
Yes, people should call Amir on things like this, just like they should call Paid and Talk on not getting the information on HD PiP right from the start. The insiders have an agenda. More so than anyone else in this forum, barring any paid shills. If the purpose is for them to provide those of us who joined the forum with the most accurate information, what is the point if they let gross inaccuracies slide?