AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Home Theater Computers › HTPC - Mac Chat › Excellent article on QuickTime, Leopard etc on AppleInsider
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Excellent article on QuickTime, Leopard etc on AppleInsider

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
There's an excellent article over at appleinsider about the history of QuickTime, iTunes, the associated media features and how these things in the end converge with Tiger and Leopard:

http://www.appleinsider.com/articles..._features.html

It's probably the best historical technical article I've read about Apple technologies in a long time. There's quite a few historical details in there that are simply amazing; for example that it was Microsoft that, by pressuring Apple about QuickTime, led Apple to buy the Final Cut development team and project from then-Macromedia. There's other ironic twists and turns in there... simply perfect stuff!
post #2 of 4
Quote:
Originally Posted by analogue900 View Post

There's an excellent article over at appleinsider about the history of QuickTime, iTunes, the associated media features and how these things in the end converge with Tiger and Leopard:

http://www.appleinsider.com/articles..._features.html

It's probably the best historical technical article I've read about Apple technologies in a long time. There's quite a few historical details in there that are simply amazing; for example that it was Microsoft that, by pressuring Apple about QuickTime, led Apple to buy the Final Cut development team and project from then-Macromedia. There's other ironic twists and turns in there... simply perfect stuff!

There's a not-so-ugly rumor that these AppleInsider articles' author, Prince McLean, is none other than Daniel Eran Dilger of Roughly Drafted infamy. You can see that he links to all of these AppleInsider articles from RDM (and vice versa). Run to Google and do a search on "Prince McLean" + Dilger, and you'll see what I mean. There is no legitimate Prince McLean persona that could have accumulated this knowledge.

While I ignore Dilger's commentary about Audio/Visual topics, as he hasn't a clue about issues dear to the audio/video-phile hearts here, he does have a knack with some historical Apple elements. I have always thought that Dilger's writings needed a tough technical editor and fact checker to back them up, and it appears that is what AppleInsider is doing with him and his writings. Nonetheless, unless you want a history lesson with your Leopard analysis, each article is prefaced with a "click to page 3 to read the meat" disclaimer. This is emblematic of Dilger's writing as he inevitably must preface any piece he writes with a history lesson, and a comparative computer platform mashup.

Maybe one day, after he gets all his facts checked, and his histories edited, he'll release a decent book about the history of Apple's rise and fall and rise again, against the onslaught of Microsoft and their evangelist and media corp darlings.

But for contemporary analysis of Apple's strategic and tactical directions, I look elsewhere. A ghost writer is still a ghost writer. If Dilger wants to go legit and mainstream, he needs to answer his critics in a more transparent and humble fashion.
post #3 of 4
One of the core features of QuickTime that was not mentioned in this article is its backwards compatibility. You can play a QuickTime 1.0 file in today's QuickTime 7.2. The same can't be said for the various incarnations of Windows Video/Media.
post #4 of 4
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by wildrock View Post

There's a not-so-ugly rumor that these AppleInsider articles' author, Prince McLean, is none other than Daniel Eran Dilger of Roughly Drafted infamy. You can see that he links to all of these AppleInsider articles from RDM (and vice versa). Run to Google and do a search on "Prince McLean" + Dilger, and you'll see what I mean. There is no legitimate Prince McLean persona that could have accumulated this knowledge.

You know, after having read the article I followed one of the links which leads to a story on roughldrafted.com. What struck me when reading that other story was the similarity both in writing style and content - to the extent that some sentences and paragraphs are almost identical. At the time I was wondering who's copy-pasting from whom and I thought it's pretty embarassing if the plagiarism is so obvious.
After having read your post, it makes sense. Still, I would expect proper author identification and affiliation. If the "Prince McLean" thing is a kind of game for him, then, well, what can one say....
Anyway, thanks for the eye-opener!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: HTPC - Mac Chat
AVS › AVS Forum › Video Components › Home Theater Computers › HTPC - Mac Chat › Excellent article on QuickTime, Leopard etc on AppleInsider