bguzman, that 300 shot is remarkable! What is your display device?
To make a fair screenshot battle, we'd have to throw out the variables which to me would include differing cameras and settings. To make it a fair fight, everyone would have to have the same cameras set up with the same settings, same resolution. Then I think you could make some differentiations between display devices IMO. None of this where some screenshot posters are actually taking them through Photoshop white balancing and posting them and tweaking them in god knows how many other ways! Also, as far as material, we'd have to pick an absolute frame from a reference level disc which to me is the human form as it's the most familiar to everyone. Shots that are taken from animated films and stylized movies look great but what's the reference? They are just not going to cut it for a screenshot battle royale IMO. I do agree that screenshots can not necessarily show how good the actual image is but it can tell you quite a bit, and when you see a great screenie, you know that someone has got it goin' on, baby!!