AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › LCD Flat Panel Displays › LCD Help and Advice
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

LCD Help and Advice

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
I have finally decided to make the plunge to HDTV. I currently have DirecTV and will be upgrading to their HD service and using an over the air antenna for my local channels (tree issues).

I am looking for 4 televisions. The first is going to be in my family room which has two windows that will face the tv and two to the right. We will be sitting approximately 7-12 feet from the tv with some angled viewing as well.

The second will go in the basement which has two small windows on the other side of the room which will have not affect on the light. We again will be sitting 7-12 feet away, but with very little angled viewing.

The third will be going in our bedroom. It has two windows on the left side and we will be sitting about 12-15 feet away.

I have come up with several options, LG 47 and 42LB5D, Phillips 47and 42PFL7432D, and the Toshiba 47 and 42HL167.

The fourth is for the kitchen which has good lighting and windows and will have viewing from throughout the room.

I have come up with the LG37LB5D, Sony Bravia KDL-32XBR4, Panasonic TC-32LX700, and Phillips 32PFL7332D.

I would love to hear some feedback and suggestions regarding these TV's given the environment they will be watched. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

NJ
post #2 of 9
Maybe I can be of some assistance.
It seems that all rooms have good lightening, so you may want to stay away from glossy screens as they reflect light.
However, in the basement you can opt for a glossy or matted screen since there isnt much light down there.

Ok with that out of the way the top 3 dogs of the LCD HDTVs are Sony, Sharp and Samsung.
They currently offer the deepest black levels, best Picture Quality (PQ) and many options.
Unfort. the Sharp's have been suffering from banding issues and the Sony's are extremely overpriced.
So if you want a high quality LCD then take a look at the Samsung series (the 61f/65f or 71f series).


Other good LCD makers are Toshiba, Vizio, LG, JVC.

Toshiba - Offers very high quality LCDs, however their new 167 series (which is 1080p) has a green hughe to it. The best bet there is their 720p version the 67 series.

Vizio - Great if on a budget. Offers the best bang for the buck. Currently their newer lines are very high quality at an affordable price.

LG - Good quality LCDs. Very similar to the Vizios quality, but just a bit better. However, it is more expensive than the Vizio.

JVC - Another good LCD maker, however, not as good as the ones listed above. What these sets are really known for is their conversion of SD (or 480p) material. They have very good down converters.

So there is a summary of it all.
Also, give us a price you are looking at for each room. That would help a lot
post #3 of 9
Thread Starter 
Thank you very much bruin!!

As far as a price range, for the family room and basement up to about $2500, for the bedroom up to $2000, and for the kitchen up to $1000. I am not interested in the best, most expensive tv, but the best tv within a reasonable budget. I do not have a surround sound system or hddvd/blu-ray at this time. I would get a surround sound system before the hddvd/bru-ray.

Hopefully this additional information is helpful. If there is anything else that would help, please let me know.

Thanks again,
NJ
post #4 of 9
Main TV: The best value is the 42" Toshiba 42HL67. It's 720p, but according to this chart, chances are you wouldn't see any more detail from 1080p images on a 1080p from those distances. Consumer Reports says it has an excellent HD and DVD picture, and a very good viewing angle. No other 42" TV they tested could attain that.

Basement TV: Consider a Sony KDL40S3000. The viewing angle's a little worse than the Toshiba, but that's no worry. The picture is supposed to be spectacular, and Consumer Reports agrees.

Bedroom TV: At your distance, the bigger the better, trust me. You should be looking into the 52" department, like the Sony KDL52W3000. If you do go 46", I suggest the Sony KDL46S3000. It's 720p, but for your distance, that's fine. You wouldn't see more detail from a 1080p image on a 1080p TV, anyway.

Kitchen TV: By far, the Panasonic TC-32LX700, or, if you can find it, the Panasonic TC-32LX70. All you lose in the 70 over the 700 is a little styling and worthless 120Hz refresh. Both have unparallelled viewing angles in their class, not to mention top-notch HD and DVD picture.

By the way, both the living room and the basement should get a home theater surround system ASAP. I suggest an Onkyo HT-SR800 for each room.
post #5 of 9
Main .. Bedroom vsv. right?

btw, Sony 46s3000 is real nice set; parents bought 2wks ago & does have nice off-axis viewing ~45-50 degrees off-center. perfect HD & SDTV channels ovr digital networks very clean.
post #6 of 9
Thread Starter 
Mike,

Thank you for the help!! I do notice that you recommend the 720p over the 1080p. Is that because I have no plans at this point of getting hddvd or blu-ray, or because it is a better deal, or both?

What is your opinion of the Samsung LCD's?

Thank you for the great help.
Also, daniel'son thank you for the suggestion.

NJ
post #7 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by njsges View Post

Mike,

Thank you for the help!! I do notice that you recommend the 720p over the 1080p. Is that because I have no plans at this point of getting hddvd or blu-ray, or because it is a better deal, or both?

What is your opinion of the Samsung LCD's?

Thank you for the great help.
Also, daniel'son thank you for the suggestion.

NJ

The toshiba is a great value, but it is going for $1100 I believe right now (The 42" version). Instead I would suggest 1080 Samsung 61F (which can be found for abbout $200-300 more). This set has better black levels, 1080p instead of 720p, more inputs and just more features. That would prob. be the best bang for the buck.

Most people will still say 720p over 1080 since you really wont see a difference.
However, not all people understand the behind the scenes and how down-converting and up-converting works.
In general all HDTV is in 1080i and both the 1080p and 720p Tvs must convert this signal. How they handle it differently is interesting and may turn you towards 1080p. Plus you have the money to get a 1080p set.
post #8 of 9
Thread Starter 
So with all things that I have listed and we have discussed, which sets would you guys recommend?

NJ
post #9 of 9
Thread Starter 
I also wanted to ask thee opinion on the Vizio LCD's.

NJ
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: LCD Flat Panel Displays
AVS › AVS Forum › Display Devices › LCD Flat Panel Displays › LCD Help and Advice