Quote:
Originally Posted by
JimLely 
Ron,
My correspondence with 234 yielded the following:
Regarding PCB and Burner issue,
actualy his explanation was correct.
Burner contains only burner.
Main PCB (green PCB) controls burner laser power and other.
And every burner has perticular calacter, we let main PCB memorize and adjust for each burner.
It means nobody can replace single burner or single PCB.
It must be pair always.
FW is in main PCB.
Please remind :
I think Main PCB is not included in burner.
Please confirm to a seller before you place an order.
It looks like a definite maybe with some ambiguity. Surely someone on this thread has replaced the drive and the companion PCB . Did the FW change after installing the companion PCB? For those who replaced ONLY the drive, did it work well in concert with the old PCB?
hello jimlely
ok....
1 - Regarding PCB and Burner issue, actualy his explanation was correct.
( this means ( translation ) the FW is located in the main PCB )
2 - Burner contains only burner. Main PCB (green PCB) controls burner laser power and other.
( other = FW is there and most functionality is also there in addition to burner and HDD control )
3 - And every burner has perticular calacter, we let main PCB memorize and adjust for each burner.
( correct - the main PCB adjusts to specific burner requirements ( see SKIP Codes to do this manually with an ' un-matched 'set. the SKIP test reaches out to an inserted DVD and performs read/write tests in the disc's test region in order to calibrate appropriate power required by the drive unit to successfully burn a disc)
4 - It means nobody can replace single burner or single PCB. It must be pair always.
( not quite correct - they ship this way to ensure that the Main PCB has been calibrated to the shipping companion drive unit... a new drive unit CAN be calibrated by an EXISTING main PCB, assuming the burn power requirement is not beyond the ' range capability ' programmed and designed into the main PCB... in our case, this should not be an issue. if the main PCB were mated to some VERY different drive, such as a different manufacturer's drive unit, there could be issues. the ability to calibrate to a given drive makes the main PCB able to be more universal, essentially ).
One caveat, here. I do not know how similar a 2160 drive unit is to a 513 drive unit. of course, my sense is that they are indeed similar in characteristics, and that the 513 drive unit will indeed, mate up to the 2160 main PCB without issue.
5 - FW is in main PCB.
( correct - your double fix will work )
6 - Please remind : I think Main PCB is not included in burner.
( raw translation - the Main PCB is a separate board )
( actual translation - when ordered from Funai - you get a box with a drive unit and a main PCB and, of course, they recommend that you install them as a set )
==========
It looks like a definite maybe with some ambiguity.
( not really ambiguous - just need to translate a bit for language barrier )
Surely someone on this thread has replaced the drive and the companion PCB.
( i have NOT done this. The 513 Main PCB that came with my 513 Drive Unit is still ( mostly ) virgin. i did some 'carving' on one of the connectors to try to test the thing in my 3576 - the connector may have poor connectivity, now, with its associated ribbon, but i will soon test the shipped 513 Main PCB in my existing 513 to check Firmware revs and confirm that i did not mess the board up... i might need to epoxy one side of the carved connector to ensure ribbon connectivity )
Did the FW change after installing the companion PCB?
( i'll advise as soon as i finish the 513 ' clock accuracy adjustment ' process )
For those who replaced ONLY the drive, did it work well in concert with the old PCB?
( i did this. installed 513 drive unit ( as shipped from Funai ) into my Philips DVDR-3576H machine and it worked flawlessly with the original 3576 Main PCB )
rgds,
ron g