One of my colleagues has asked me to recommend a subwoofer for $650 or less. I did find the above subwoofers in this range. He wants to buy it today. so not much time to do research myself. He wants a smaller foot print (WAF). I am not following subwoofer market in last 3years since i bought my eD subwoofer.
His speakers are PSB Imagine series. Room is large 13 x 23 with opening to kitchen. They have a high ceiling.
Family Room: Philharmonics BMR's, MTM Center with RAAL, XPA-5, UMC-200, LG PK550 Plasma
HT Room: Philharmonics Slim Jr, WMTW slims center in curly cherry with rose dye,
120" silverticket, XPA-5, Denon AVR-X4500H, Oppo BDP-103, BenQ HT2050, Rythmik FV15HP