ADT vs Vivint Vs Stand Alone Controller
I've been looking at Home Automation Controllers and can't figure out which one looks best. I am currently an ADT subscriber (Under contract until ~Feb 2020) and noticed that as of this year they've dipped into the Home Automation world more with their Command/Control series. Unfortunately I can't find much information about the system online as far as capabilities and devices it interfaces well with (website just says Alexa, Kwik set, Liftmaster and Zwave). Does anyone have any experience with ADT or Vivint's Home Automation component? If so are devices easily configurable/able to be added by myself or does it require the dealer?
Here's what I currently have device wise vs what I would be adding in the future:
Sonos Connect/Connect Amps for WHA
Amazon Firesticks/Amazon TV's
Liftmaster Garage Door Openers (Don't have the MY QWifi Gateway Yet)
Rain Bird WiFi Sprinkler Controller
Harmony Hub For Primary Living Room TV
Amazon Echo Dots
Potentially looking to add (Slowly not all at once):
Ring Style Doorbell Camera (Not married to ring as I see that both Vivint and ADT offer their own doorbell camera's with storage/viewing that may be included in their monthly costs. I would like to avoid the additional cost for the Ring Cloud service if I can. Also appears that the ADT camera can provide picture/video via the fire TV?)
Wifi Garage Door Opener (Liftmaster has their own MyQ which I assume is what the ADT integrates with, but it looks like Vivint may offer one as well)
Outdoor Security Camera's (Already wired to locations with CAT6 Cable)
Additional Harmony Hub for Theater room
Smart Thermostat (Currently only have a programmable one)
Lighting Automation (Not married to any specific brand or type here, I am finishing my basement and would look to start adding controlled switches here and then moving to replacing the upstairs ones over time)
Misc Controlled Outlets as needed (Control Home theater items like lighted Poster boxes, RGB lights for the screen, etc.)
Would Ideally like to be able to use a combination of wired keypads, voice commands from Alexa, Harmony remotes, and Iphone/Ipad apps for control (along with the proprietary tablets/panels that come with the security services)
I like the idea of having one central place like the ADT app or vivint app to control everything, but also have concerns that they might be limited when it comes to some of the options above. Perhaps a better solution would be to maintain my existing Security only contract and use a third party (Homeseer/Charmed Quark) for the rest of the Home Automation since I would have much more control over them? Or maybe even use the third party with an integrated Z-Wave controller and let the security systems interact with the home automation that way? I think that having the ability to say "Alexa, Goodnight" and having all the lights turn off, Alarm set, TV's/music turned off, and Thermostat adjusted has an appeal to it, but not if it becomes so complicated to add and remove devices or us that its not user friendly.
Avg Price of Blu-Rays: $6.36
Thank you Blu-Ray Deals Thread!
Last edited by DaDeuce; 07-30-2019 at 11:11 AM.