Ordinarily it would be out of character for him, unless you consider he has unrequited feelings for her, along with Eugene, I'd even go so far to say she planted the seed. Dante could have killed her and her baby. She certainly didn't look surprised when he came walking out.

Carol has actually been a liability from the very start, in that sense she's never changed.

Yeah, I definitely spoke too soon on the piss poor writing comment.

Lots of impactful scenes in this episode! Pretty good episode. Hopefully, they can keep it going.

Solid mid-season finale. Carol's part was a little eye rolling at times being so dumb at times. Liked everything else. I predict everyone magically gets out of the pit when they find another path leading out that they can clear out somehow.

I cant believe no one ever gets a tooth ache ' what they do then. Love the final but every one running into the cave was pretty stupid. Reminded me of the commercial where all the teens hide behind the chain saws. Stupid

Why don't we just get in the running car?

Are you crazy, lets hide behind the chain saws.

Good commercial and so true of those types of horror movies (and Carol).

I've pretty much enjoyed this Season so far, the mid-Finale was quite good other than Carol taking the bait .. I mean, running into a cave/mineshaft in pursuit of Alpha .. ?? And then the rest of the Gang following .. ?? I guess on the positive side, it did leave a nice cliffhanger ..

More Michonne lopping off Walker heads in slow mo, please ..

Very curious now on the "Island of Weapons" and how that plays out ..

It could have played a bit better, if just one ( Daryl?) followed after her into the cave ....
It's understandable that Carol is a bit blinded by her hatred of Alpha, & would run after her into the cave, that alone is OK ....
Daryl could have said "You guys all stay here, I'm going in after her" ...

Yeah, true .. although the Alpha pursuit took place soon after the Walker Horde was discovered to not be in the field area .. that should have been a tip-off that something was amiss ..

Well the island of weapons will be I think the end of Michonne ' since she is leaving the show. This must be how they write her out. Happy Turkey Day.

"Lost at sea" would be suitably ambiguous and allow for periodic returns.