I tried this with the latest Pirates movies, and ended up burning a few coasters. The burned discs play fine on my PC (in 2D and downmixed to stereo, but presumably from the 3D and Atmos tracks) but my players refuse to play them.
Well, they don't refuse, they just play a black screen and stay on 0:00:00.
I thought maybe I needed the CERTIFICATEs copied over, as was specified in the Gravity thread, but that just ended up in another coaster.
My process was more or less based off the Gravity thread, but involved:
Backing up discs with MakeMKV, identifying Playlist 00800 as the right one with BDInfo, using txMuxeR to combine the 3D disc (minus the DTS audio) with the Atmos track, and creating a Blu Ray folder with it, then burning with ImgBurn (to media that are known to work great).
EDIT- DON'T build BD folder with tsMuxeR! It was the source of at least some of my problems! Only build BD ISO.
After the burn, my Leawo Blu Ray software immediately started playing the disc. But my two Sony 3D BD players would just show the black screen. They are known to play other burned discs just fine.
Any idea where I went wrong? I wonder if I clicked that 'Use base video stream for right eye' option in tsMuxeR... would that result in this behavior?
BDInfo doesn't show two video streams (this is analyzing the disc I burned):
But tsMuxeR does:
EDIT: I tsmux'ed again, ensuring I didn't select the right eye option. BDInfo is still telling me I only have one stream there.
EDIT2: Hmmm... used tsMuxeR's BD ISO mode instead of BD folder mode, and now I show 2 streams. Time to burn again.