WhatHiFi reviews have been a mixed bag for me.
They did not like the original Elac Debut's. I think that speaker is fantastic. They love the Debut 2.0's...I am just "meh" on that one.
They gushed on the Monitor Audio Silver 100's. I bought a pair due to this review. And while it was a good speaker, it just didn't have the magic that they told me it does (especially for the price point).