AVS Forum banner

What kind of 35'+ foot hdmi cables have you tried?

  • Amplified and it worked

    Votes: 3 23.1%
  • Amplified and it didn't work

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Passive and it worked

    Votes: 10 76.9%
  • Passive and it didn't work

    Votes: 0 0.0%
1 - 20 of 20 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
714 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by ElectronicTonic  /t/1470902/35-hdmi-cables-do-they-really-work#post_23267698


I have 2 RedMere cables from Monoprice, and they both work great. One is 40ft, the other is 50ft. They both pass 1080p and 3D fine.

I would count Redmere as amplified, even though I don't believe that is technically right.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
66 Posts
I'll just repeat what I said in the other thread that spawned this discussion:
Quote:
Once you get past 25' (really 15') you can't expect a passive HDMI cable to "just work." There are so many factors that affect how well the signal will travel on a lengthy passive HDMI cable. For example, don't assume a consumer-grade camcorder will send or a +5 year old HDTV will receive the signal at lengths of 25' or more. There's also more than a few stories out there of HDMI cables working initially, but the signal fails (most likely due to corrosion on the connectors) after a period of time. Also, the longer the cable, the more the quality of the cable becomes a factor. Redmere gives the installer strong assurance that those potential issues will not be a problem, which is especially important for in-wall installations.

I have used a 22 ga. HDMI cable 40' in length that has reliably passed the signal from a spliter to an HDTV. I have also had to daisy-chain a couple of cables and add a passive and active signal booster to travel 30' for a very finicky piece of equipment (an ATEM Television Studio) after trying a monoprice cable, the Belden HDMI cable from Blue Jeans and the Atlona ribbon-style HDMI cable, both at 30' in length, and both without success. I would always suggest getting an over-engineered HDMI cable for long distances if it is within financial reason to do so, and test it with the equipment you will be using before any in-wall installation. Whether an HDMI cable will work, and whether it will continue to work is just a crap shoot over long distances, but you can tilt the odds in your favor by getting quality cables (but not expensive--monoprice and Blue Jeans are fine, but I would not rely on no-name Amazon Third-Party sellers)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
96 Posts
I've been running a 50' HDMI cable (1080p signal) for the past 2 years with no issues whatsoever. Bought cable on amazon
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,642 Posts

My 35' monoprice (22 AWG CL2 Cable, passive, non-redmere) has been flawless, about $1/foot

100% trouble free running from my AVR to my Epson 1080UB projector for over 4.5 years.

PS3, XBOX 360, Sony BD Player, all at 1080P ,  Motorola HD PVR and Toshiba HD A2 HDDVD at 1080i

 

I also have a monoprice 10' HDMI cable running to my wall mounted Pioneer 50" Kuro (AVR supports 2 simultaneous HDMI display outs)

and I can run the PJ and the Plasma at the same time with the same 1080P signal split, without signal loss.

 



 

 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
6,500 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by Michael Sargent  /t/1470902/35-hdmi-cables-do-they-really-work#post_23270022


I've been using a 45' Blue Jeans cable (BJC-01?) for 3 1/2 years, with no problems what so ever. That's 1080p to a Panasonic AE4000 projector from Denon AVR 4308ci.


Mike

+1. Blue Jeans Cables for trouble free performance. Their Belden Bonded-Pair HDMI Cable is as good as they come.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
714 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by CartmanDDT  /t/1470902/35-hdmi-cables-do-they-really-work#post_23269312


I'll just repeat what I said in the other thread that spawned this discussion:

I have used a 22 ga. HDMI cable 40' in length that has reliably passed the signal from a spliter to an HDTV. I have also had to daisy-chain a couple of cables and add a passive and active signal booster to travel 30' for a very finicky piece of equipment (an ATEM Television Studio) after trying a monoprice cable, the Belden HDMI cable from Blue Jeans and the Atlona ribbon-style HDMI cable, both at 30' in length, and both without success. I would always suggest getting an over-engineered HDMI cable for long distances if it is within financial reason to do so, and test it with the equipment you will be using before any in-wall installation. Whether an HDMI cable will work, and whether it will continue to work is just a crap shoot over long distances, but you can tilt the odds in your favor by getting quality cables (but not expensive--monoprice and Blue Jeans are fine, but I would not rely on no-name Amazon Third-Party sellers)

I would like to know why you have such a hate of cables from Amazon?


Personally I can't justify spending $163 on a cable when a $20 cable works just as well(50ft blue jeans belden versus Aurum cable). I would suggest not spending more money than you have to on a cable that is unlikely to work with future standards(2160p60 or 4320p).


Thank you for letting me know not to buy an ATEM Television Studio.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
66 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by macks  /t/1470902/35-hdmi-cables-do-they-really-work#post_23271690


I would like to know why you have such a hate of cables from Amazon?


Personally I can't justify spending $163 on a cable when a $20 cable works just as well(50ft blue jeans belden versus Aurum cable). I would suggest not spending more money than you have to on a cable that is unlikely to work with future standards(2160p60 or 4320p).


Thank you for letting me know not to buy an ATEM Television Studio.
1). Time is money. If it doesn't work, you spend time troubleshooting, reordering, and installing again.


2). Your reputation is valuable. If it doesn't work, or it fails in 3 months, that will reflect on you.


3). Generally speaking, Amazon is a race to the bottom. If you are not trading on your name, you are trading on price. And if price is the primary concern, then quality is not. Wouldn't say that is true of every 3rd party seller, but the seller who gets featured is the one with the lowest price. Blue Jeans Cable and Monoprice have a name and reputation to uphold, generics do not. Sooner or later, they will burn you.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,698 Posts
I have an old 50' HDMI cable I bought used off ebay over 5 year ago for about $30. I am sure its the old 1.3 spec cable and it works flawlessly for 1080p and 3d from my Denon 1912 to my HD33 projector. I have no idea what this cable cost originally but was obviously was made well.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
714 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by CartmanDDT  /t/1470902/35-hdmi-cables-do-they-really-work#post_23272085


1). Time is money. If it doesn't work, you spend time troubleshooting, reordering, and installing again.


2). Your reputation is valuable. If it doesn't work, or it fails in 3 months, that will reflect on you.


3). Generally speaking, Amazon is a race to the bottom. If you are not trading on your name, you are trading on price. And if price is the primary concern, then quality is not. Wouldn't say that is true of every 3rd party seller, but the seller who gets featured is the one with the lowest price. Blue Jeans Cable and Monoprice have a name and reputation to uphold, generics do not. Sooner or later, they will burn you.

1) If it doesn't work then you return it. The point of me putting up a poll is to show that not many people have issues with long HDMI cables not working. Don't think I have ever gotten a product that doesn't work from Amazon.


2) Cables failing in 3 months, not sure I buy this.


3) Amazon has ratings for both items and for sellers. Blue Jeans Cable like all companies only really cares about making money, their prices represent a good margin of profit. Monoprice has always been about cheap prices with normally decent products.


If I believed monoprice was a better place to buy things than Amazon then I would happily pay 10% more to buy a cable from them. Problem is the price is double or triple + shipping costs.


I expect any cable I buy to "just work" in its prescribed use.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,974 Posts
Bluejeanscable, in addition to selling quality cables, also has some interesting and informative articles. Here is one on HDMI length:
http://www.bluejeanscable.com/articles/how-long-can-hdmi-run.htm?hdmiinfo


Their take is that 50' is the tipping point for problems, so it would be interesting to compare the results of this poll with a poll on distances over 50'.


From the article:

"In practical terms, today, for distances 50 feet and shorter, even economical HDMI cables are usually reliable at 720p, 1080i and (though this is less consistently so) 1080p. For very short runs--all those 3 and 6 foot cables out there in the world, at least when not being used as part of a much longer signal chain--it's best not to worry about it at all. But for those long runs, the future is still very unclear. Low-cost 50-foot cables which are near their performance limit at 1080p today may not work with 16-bit color 1080p tomorrow.


If you're in the longer-than-50-foot category, it gets dicier. We have had good consistent results with the Series-1 cable out to 100 feet, with reports of no trouble in the great majority of installations. Cable quality starts to be a real concern at these distances, and performance always is hard to predict, especially because the cable that works on one source/display pair may not work on another. There is, unfortunately, no really good way to know what will work without plugging it in.


So what should you buy? We get a lot of questions from customers who are not sure whether to buy our best cable or our cheapest. There's not one consistent "right" answer to this; if the cheapest cable will do everything you ask of it, there's no picture improvement to be had in going to the best cable (this is, after all, a digital signal), but if what you ask of it may change, the answer may change, too. We strongly encourage people who are installing cable behind walls, in ceilings, and the like to weight their choices heavily in favor of buying the very best HDMI cable possible, simply because the cost of revisiting an installation later can be much higher than the cost of the best cable. On the other hand, if your installation will not restrict your access to your cable, and if the inexpensive cable works well with your gear today, there's no compelling need to have the best possible cable quality."



I have a 35' Bluejeans cable, and I have not had any issues, although some source devices take a little longer to sync then others at the distance.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
714 Posts
Discussion Starter · #19 ·
CartmanDDT,




JeffKB,


I was actually hoping someone would post their experience with an over 50' cable. I've noticed that there aren't "cheap" cables over 50'.


I had to smile at there reference to 16-bit 1080p. Other than that it is a very good article that I agree with.


I never thought about a long cable causing longer sync times, always blamed the projector being slow.
 
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Top