AVS Forum banner
  • Get an exclusive sneak peek into our new project. >>> Click Here
  • Our native mobile app has a new name: Fora Communities. Learn more.

Am I asking for trouble by switching from wall mounted to In-wall?...

1932 Views 45 Replies 5 Participants Last post by  Phil Indeblanc
I recently moved, but in the old place I was rather happy with my 5.1setup, as I like movies, but not enough to do anything more than 5. I really enjoy music as well, and like a 2.1 sound for that....
My old place had the Infinity Ref3 Video monitors being mounted and aimed down from a 11foot ceiling height(rather directional and toed in) as mains, and using a INwall Di6.5 LCR(as Center) DefTech center channel, with not so good surrounds. I have a 8" Sunfire sub that sounds pretty good to my ears(maybe I will get a 2nd if I find one).

So I still have the Infinity Ref3 speakers I kept, I also happen to have Deftech Studio Monitor40 or 50s/? (rather small for mains I had used in another room). AND I did repurchase the Di6.5LCR DeFTech, as I thought I was going to replicate what I had before...
Add either the INwall DefTech Di55 BPS BiPole as surrounds or the ONwall SR 9040s (they are about $500 vs 250each, respectively)

Oh, I also have a pair of older KEF iQ9 or C95(? I think they are) series towers sitting in the attic ...Which The Boss of the house is actually very OK with using, as that would be one less purchase!
I am a bit confused, as you might be at this point :). Maybe the title should be "A win for tower speakers"?

One of my fav sounding speakers were the Paradigm Studio 20v3 bookshelf, which I never purchased as they went up in price and could not justify another pair of speakers, but now that I have a blank slate....AND with the direction going for INwall for aesthetics, and the Bosses wishes, I was aiming for all INwall.... MAYBE ONwall being an option if keeping the Infinity as mains..depending on the advice I get here :)
Or , perhaps the Kef C95's are actually better than these I am considering?

I was thinking to either start fresh, with 3 Paradigm (LCR or the SR 25?) or something around or under $375 ea) INwall ...IF they will have the same sound as the Studio20's. That is likely not so realistic, and maybe scratch that off the list.
OR, keep the Infinity Ref3 with the Di6.5 in wall LCR, and get some other surrounds, since I have the LCR covered and just need rear surrounds.

The space is a rectangle 3 wall space. There are windows in one corner where one Left speaker would go. Other has a half wall which is open next to the Right main, while surrounds have walls on each side. Its a small space, being 15.5x18.5ft. The TV to couch distance is the 15.5ft length. (wider distance between the surround speakers).

I hope I get get some constructive feedback from experience. I also notice that I could not find anyone whos had the DefTech Di6.5 LCR speakers, and that DEfTech is actually not so well regarded here. I have heard a few of their lines, and I liked a couple of them. I didnt like Mythos. Anyway. Thanks in advance
See less See more
1 - 20 of 46 Posts
The Paradigm Studio series is about two levels above a $350 in-wall speaker. I seriously doubt you can find a Studio 20 for $350 anywhere.
I recently moved, but in the old place I was rather happy with my 5.1setup, as I like movies, but not enough to do anything more than 5. I really enjoy music as well, and like a 2.1 sound for that....
Movies are mostly dialogue, and the center speaker does not only 99% of the dialogue but at least 50% of the front sound effects...so on average, 60-80% of the total HT output. Therefore I would get the best freestanding in-room center speaker you can, a 3 way if going horizontal. It's the true workhorse and backbone of any HT setup, so it makes logical sense that it be the biggest and best speaker in your whole setup.

Also, if you watch a lot of big budget action/thriller movies, you'll laugh out loud at what a humongous difference a humongous sub (in comparison to the 8" Sunfire) will make---even a 12" sub like a Hsu VTF-2.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Thanks for the replies...
Sigpig...I was not looking at using Studio 20's, but their inwall "equal" at around 350-450 ea is reasonable.
I imagine speaker makers are loving this iNwall market direction...No box, no finish, none of the added work and still the top dollar....that's another topic :)

@Zorba922
The one thing I was hoping to get off the room and into the wall was the center channel, and I already have the DefTech Di6.5LCR. Its 2 6.5" drivers with a center tweeter. BUT, I can sell it and get something else....I liked the neutrality and its ability to smooth out any peaks...according to my older ears.
I did a hearing test last time about 8 years ago, and I think anything over 14,000 Hz is too high for me to hear well.
So each person will be different...
YET, I am not so selfish and only doing this for my ears, but the rest of my younger eared family :)...

So maybe a large boxy hunk of a Paradigm center channel is something I should consider.
The center channel has LESS resonance than mains, as the vocals are usually above 500Hz, so this is less important than the L/R or sub, as they need enveloping space. How much better is this going to be than a in-wall center channel? (But maybe there is a counter point I am not considering?)
See less See more
If you liked the Studios, then today's closest counterpart is the Paradigm Premier series. You won't find them for $350/speaker, though.
Here's a listing of in-wall speakers at $350 and below from Crutchfield: In-wall Speakers, Wall Speakers - Crutchfield
  • Like
Reactions: 1
@Zorba922
The one thing I was hoping to get off the room and into the wall was the center channel, and I already have the DefTech Di6.5LCR. Its 2 6.5" drivers with a center tweeter. BUT, I can sell it and get something else....I liked the neutrality and its ability to smooth out any peaks...according to my older ears.
I did a hearing test last time about 8 years ago, and I think anything over 14,000 Hz is too high for me to hear well.
So each person will be different...
YET, I am not so selfish and only doing this for my ears, but the rest of my younger eared family :)...

So maybe a large boxy hunk of a Paradigm center channel is something I should consider.
The center channel has LESS resonance than mains, as the vocals are usually above 500Hz, so this is less important than the L/R or sub, as they need enveloping space. How much better is this going to be than a in-wall center channel? (But maybe there is a counter point I am not considering?)
There are certain inherent advantages that a 3 way horizontal center enjoys over a 2 way.

The DT center is a 2 way, iirc. If you place it at ear level and sit straight in front of it, the 2 way disadvantages will be less apparent than for people sitting off axis and/or not at ear level to the tweeter.

You don't necessarily have to blow $700-1000 just to get a solid 3 way center speaker.

Here are some proven performer 3 way centers in the $250-400 range:
Emotiva C1+
Emotiva C2+

Infinity Reference RC263

Polk LSi-M 706C

If looking for a "neutral" sound signature, the Emotivas might be your best bet. The Infinity does come with free return shipping though, which is a nice extra bonus.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Hmmm, I like the Emotiv Airmotiv C2+ for a external center..., I see the Definitive Technology UIW RLS III In-wall multi-purpose speaker with built-in back-box735RLS3, but that is $699 AND its only 2way. Those radiators tricked me at first. The inwall Di6.5 LCR center I have is 2way and its $599. Maybe I can sell and get around $400 for it :)
That polk in Chery box looks nice..Between the Emotiv and the Polk...OR this NHT(I have heard the bookshelves and they sounds decent) https://www.amazon.com/NHT-Center-Channel-Speaker-Black/dp/B019PZ9BQY

Would be great if any of these had a horn tweeter, but maybe more important to have that on LR?
There are certain inherent advantages that a 3 way horizontal center enjoys over a 2 way.

The DT center is a 2 way, iirc. If you place it at ear level and sit straight in front of it, the 2 way disadvantages will be less apparent than for people sitting off axis and/or not at ear level to the tweeter.

You don't necessarily have to blow $700-1000 just to get a solid 3 way center speaker.

Here are some proven performer 3 way centers in the $250-400 range:
Emotiva C1+
Emotiva C2+

Infinity Reference RC263

Polk LSi-M 706C

If looking for a "neutral" sound signature, the Emotivas might be your best bet. The Infinity does come with free return shipping though, which is a nice extra bonus.
Some nice options Zorba the Greek
I should be considering the ohms and sensitivity...for the Kef(i think 4ohms) vs the Infinity Ref3 vs others as I dont think my receiver can adjust this..I forget!?
The C2+ is a sweet 92db
So the Emotiv sounds like a good pick...some rear bipoles, and a decent selection of mains and we are good!! LOL..long way, I know!
Hmmm, I like the Emotiv Airmotiv C2+ for a external center..., I see the Definitive Technology UIW RLS III In-wall multi-purpose speaker with built-in back-box735RLS3, but that is $699 AND its only 2way. Those radiators tricked me at first. The inwall Di6.5 LCR center I have is 2way and its $599. Maybe I can sell and get around $400 for it :)
That polk in Chery box looks nice..Between the Emotiv and the Polk...OR this NHT(I have heard the bookshelves and they sounds decent) https://www.amazon.com/NHT-Center-Channel-Speaker-Black/dp/B019PZ9BQY

Would be great if any of these had a horn tweeter, but maybe more important to have that on LR?
I don't know of any 3 way centers with horn tweeters, Klipsch and JBL all have 2.5 ways centers

The NHT website lists the C LCR at a not-great 87db sensitivity.

The wild card here is the Hsu CCB-8 which is a concentric horn design with an 8" woofer, so it can be positioned horizontally or vertically.
I like point source/horn design on the CCB8 HSU

Ok, I also looked around on the used market, and since so many folks that are more in the function follows form...which I can be on the border of, are selling off some nice gear for nice prices. For example...

----I think these are 2.5-3-way---
Meridian DSP5000C (2.5way) If I read it right it claims 108db...hm, never heard of such
Revel Concerta C-12 (3way)
Paradigm studio cc490 v5

--- 2-way ---
Paradigm 2way? CC370 v3
Paradigm CC350
B&W CC6 2way
B&W - Bowers and Wilkins LCR600 S3
B&W LCR 600 S3Klipsch KSF-C5
B&W CM-5 bookshelf speakers with matched B&W CMC center speaker
KLIPSCH KSC-C1
ELAC - Debut 2.0 Dual 6-1/2" 2-Way
Phase Tech T Center
Boston Acoustics 404V I have heard different Bostons and like them
Definitive Audio ProCenter 1000
Altantic technology Compact Theater Two 3 speakers L-C-R
PSB Image 9C
Monitor Audio Gold Reference Center/LCR
Tannoy MX-C
JBL EC25
---
Hmmm, so for LR.....
So are the KEF 4ohm C95 out , for the most part?
The large bookshelve Infinity Ref3's maybe still contenders for LR
I also have the Def Tech Sutio Pro monitors, SM45 I think they are

If any above like the Revel, or Meridian(2.5way) can be as good, better or close to the C2+, maybe worth it...
Or between the B&W 3 speaker or Atlantic 3 speaker setups?

Also my receiver can add on additional channels, yet I dont think it has 2 sub outs..Its in storage, so we shall see! (I hope there is a way!)
See less See more
Maybe for the Revel c12 thats under 200 it should be a good deal? or the C2+ is worth it?
Maybe work smoothly with the Infinity Ref3 being some what in the same family?
Maybe for the Revel c12 thats under 200 it should be a good deal? or the C2+ is worth it?
Maybe work smoothly with the Infinity Ref3 being some what in the same family?
Any neutral center speaker will easily blend with any other speakers during HT. The C2+ is definitely neutral by all accounts.

You would be more likely to hear any "timbre differences" if doing multi-channel music or gaming.

Used speakers don't have any return options or warranty. I'd only buy used if at a huge discount for a speaker that I was quite certain I'd like, preferably from a trustworthy seller.
Any neutral center speaker will easily blend with any other speakers during HT. The C2+ is definitely neutral by all accounts.

You would be more likely to hear any "timbre differences" if doing multi-channel music or gaming.

Used speakers don't have any return options or warranty. I'd only buy used if at a huge discount for a speaker that I was quite certain I'd like, preferably from a trustworthy seller.

Yes, its a bit of a balancing act, but out of buying used, I have gotten 1 rotten deal out of many great ones. So, I am not so shy in that perspective
These 2 look like the ones for 3way used so far
---Revel Concerta C-12 (3way) under 200(maybe 150)...Hope its like other Infinty speakers, which I have liked in the past.
---Paradigm studio cc490 v5 under 400(maybe 350)....Hope it is like a Studio 20 line of a speaker which I have liked in the past
---Paradigm Studio 20v4 pair with a included center channel (2way)
Or the C2+ for $400 plus tax and ship, etc
Any neutral center speaker will easily blend with any other speakers during HT. The C2+ is definitely neutral by all accounts.

You would be more likely to hear any "timbre differences" if doing multi-channel music or gaming.

Used speakers don't have any return options or warranty. I'd only buy used if at a huge discount for a speaker that I was quite certain I'd like, preferably from a trustworthy seller.
BTW, I agree with your signature rather strongly...most of it!
I’d run away from in walls unless you plan on keeping them for awhile , or are for sure you like them. Returning and uninstalling is a pain ...
Any idea what regular speakers you’d want ?
I’d run away from in walls unless you plan on keeping them for awhile , or are for sure you like them. Returning and uninstalling is a pain ...
Any idea what regular speakers you’d want ?
I know I have liked the Paradigm Studio 20v3, I do enjoy my Infinity Ref3.
In general, for home...
I have liked some things of the DefTech Studio Monitors/SM45/55/65 to some degree. I like NHT
I like my old Altec Lansings, I like wide dispersion horn, I dont like tinny sound or harsh highs fatiguing sounds. Have had some JBL's Control monitors do that. For some reason I can see Klipsch do that as well with the metal cones and such?
I like Bose 901, I have liked Boston Acoustic.
That is all I can think of...I know I dont like a pair of Sonus Faber, and some pair of Energy or something.

This would be going into a pretty long term permanent living space :)
I like wide dispersion horn, I dont like tinny sound or harsh highs fatiguing sounds. Have had some JBL's Control monitors do that.

This would be going into a pretty long term permanent living space :)
I think the Emotivas would be a good choice for you in terms of trying to avoid "tinny or harsh highs fatiguing sounds" but still providing gobs of detail/clarity. Chane A5.5 / A2.2 / A1.5 as well and these have a slimmer profile if sleek looks are important to you. Although the Emotivas look much better in the wild than in their awful black-on-white website photos:
3141234
See less See more
Couple negatives on the Emotivas I read is that they have a tendency to have a strong pronounced "ssS" on the vocals. That is something I cannot stand. And they are 4Ohms. My receiver can probably do 4ohm for a couple drivers, but not likely get a good expansive range with 4 ohm being 3 or more drivers. Besides, if the center is 4ohm, my mains will be more efficient and sound louder.
I dont know if my receiver can adjust for it, its a bit old.
The Studio CC490 is the matching centre to the Studio 20s.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I think I maybe going that route with the Studio 20's. get the 2 speakers I have always liked, match a center to it, and not worry about 4ohm amping.
One thing I am considering is a second sub. Is there a way to have amps support a second sub?

Now I hope they/Studio 20's have a wide dispersion sound. I cant remember when I listened to them years ago :)
1 - 20 of 46 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top