AVS Forum banner
1 - 20 of 32 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
20 Posts
I just got the HDR-30 about a month ago and used for a 2 week vacation through Europe..The camera worked Great! Video quality was superb and the 3D was very engaging


I would suggest that you get a few extra batteries for when shooting in 3D battery life was less than an hour.. I got the wall battery charger with the extra battery kit from Sony I actually got 2 extra batteries and having the extra power worked well..You do have to buy an SD Card so that's an extra expense but you can find on usually on sale on Amazon or Best Buy..I got the 64 Gig San Disk I think its the Ultra but might be the Extreme it is the one with the 45 MB write speed and no problems at all..It also shoots still pics at 20 MB with lots of detail and good color..I work in television and was extremely pleased with the 2D video quality and the 3D was incredible.


Any questions you might have feel free to ask


Hunter
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
471 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
Can the depth be adjusted? How is the 3d for outdoor stuff? I have been using a Panasonic 3d1 and am worried about how much closer the lenses on the Sony are, compared to my 3d1.

Also, how is the sound? Is it full range, is there good seperation?

Can you take the SD card out, put it into a 3d bluray player ( I have a panny 220) and watch it ?

I'll be traveling next month, probably take 1-2 hours of video tops- do you think I could get buy with two batteries?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
20 Posts
Yes the depth can be adjusted although I have it set to auto till I get a feel for the 3D over time..I thought the sound was very good but did not listen to it on a full surround system yet..Im not sure about the blu-ray player using the SD Card into it I'm actually trying to find that out myself I have heard that it can be done on the new Panny blu-rays but not sure of the model number..I think 2 batteries should be suffice for that amount of video just charge them each night so you always have the back up...again I would get the wall chargers so you don' have to use the camera to charge the battery it is just easier or get 1 wall charger and then you can charge 1 battery in the wall and 1 in the camera
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
I've got the HDR TD20v .....


go here and buy it


http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/838301-REG/Sony_HDR_TD20V_S_HDR_TD20V_Full_HD_3D.html


no tax , free shipping , reputable ...


Listen , the HDR-td20-V is the SAME CAMERA as the HDR 30 ...the ONLY difference is the HDR30 doesn't have 64GB of on board memory and they removed the manual focus control knob for 3D ...



The HDR 30 is actually a downgrade ... they made it this way so they could lower the price point , the prior model the 20 sold for about 1500 new ...


if you don't believe me , go to the Sony website and pull up the PR page for the HDR 20 , and the HDR 30 ... scroll down to the feature list and compare them side by side .... they moved the words around a little , but the features are exactly the same ...


save yourself some money and buy last years model ...


As for the 3D ...... meh .....going into this i was really excited for 3D ... what helped me buy this camera was it's strong 2D filming . i had delusions of being able to make great 3D video with this thing ..and after using it for awhile i have to admit that what i read is true ....The 3D is great for shooting things like kids ( which if you look at their promotional material is the focus ) but not much else since the field of 3D is rather limited ..


I will also say that the Camera feels very lightweight and breakable ... but it DOES perform well ...


i spent alot of money on this thing 899 ....so far i'm SO, SO on it ... if your looking for one camera to rule them all then this might be it , with great 2D and the ablity to capture 3D , this thing should be future proof for at least a few more years .
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
This is gonna take me sometime , I have to hook up my 3d monitor that I have by my desk but don't actually use that often ...


looking at the 2D , I would say your Camera is OK as far as video quality goes , but I definitely think the 20V is better ...also you need to be aware that the 20V does NOT take 3 D photo's ... I don't remember if the 30 does , but if I recall right it also does not take 3D pictures . i'll get back to you in a bit on the 3D comparison .



if your talking about still pictures , I can't really quantify that , I've taken a few stills with it and they seem fine , the promotional material says it can take up to 20MP still pictures ...

http://store.sony.com/p/Handycam-Full-HD-3D-Camcorder/en/p/HDRTD20V#features
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
471 Posts
Discussion Starter · #10 ·
I don't think the 30 takes 3d pics, I am going to keep using the 3d1 for that.The 20mp figure for sony pics is probably for interpolated processing.Makes for good selling points.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
hey as far as video goes ... to be honest I cannot give you my own opinion on videos from your camera vs video's from my camera ... There are so many 3D displays , and each of them are different ... I happen to have a low end computer monitor , so what plays well for me , may not play well for you or look awful ... I suggest you log onto YouTube and watch some 3D video's for yourself , there is test footage for both Cameras on there in 3d .
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
Replying Depression4u,


I trust your words completely after I've found that TD30 is still unavailable in Japan (as until today 21May, 2013)! How is it possible? Japanese are complaining all over the internet (Japanese forums). Sony posts nothing about the TD30 on Japan official website. But strange enough, the Pal version is officially supplied to it's neighbors such as China and Hong Kong while Taiwan and Korea gets the NTSC version. Put it this way, it's available worldwide except Japan!!! HUH?


I am not sure if your statement "The HDR 30 is actually a downgrade....." is accurate but I do agree with you that TD30 has nothing at all to compete with an year-old brother.


Thanks for your heads up! Cheers.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
471 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
Got my hd 30 today.I paid $1,000 for it, came with USA warranty and a package of goodies which included an extra battery, charger, case, 32g card, screen protectors and a tripod. One interesting thing- the battery will fit my old Sony HC3! However, my batteries from my Sony HC3 won't fit the hdr td 30. What this means is that if you just happen to have a wall charger from that series of camera, you can probably use it to charge up the batteries for the HDR TD 30.

Initial impressions- I like the LCD screen.Zoom is quiet. I took the card out of the cam, put into my Panny 220 bluray player, video played just fine.

Sound sucks though. The 5.1 digital creator thing appears to be no more than stereo sent to five channels. The cam has only two mics that I can see, under the lens. I took it in the yard, even though there was a bird chirping from the far right of me,it played back from the middle speaker (the 5.1 lights were on my receiver).

I'll probably break out my old Cascade audio surround mic for my next trip and plug it in.

Don't understand why Sony still won't allow people to take 3d stills with these cams, I'll just have to bring along my panny 3d1.

Pq is better than 3d1, looks like high def. The 3d1, as much as I like it, has video quality that often looks more like dvd. I guess that is the cost of doing sbs.

The Sony also has manual and auto depth setting. I wonder if the auto setting works to play with the depth, to "enhance" things, to compensate for small IA.

Yes, the 3d doesn't look as dramatic as the 3d1 but the picture overall looks better. Just pointing and shooting at the mountains makes for a 2d looking video, when I got a tree in my yard in the forground, it still looked good.

The camera has pretty good stabilzation. However, it is pretty small. I'll dig out my old L bracket, attach with surround mic on top, look forward to using it next month.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
471 Posts
Discussion Starter · #18 ·
Yeah, i am happy with the cam but a little disappointed with the sound.

If you want to plug in a different mic, the mic jack is under a flap on the side with the screen, the worst place in the world for it.You won't be able to close screen without removing the mic plug and I fear frequent unplugging/plugging will wear out the jack. If you don't have the VMCK100 adapter, it would be tempting to drill a hole in the side flap so that you can use the mic input without having that laerge falp open. I can understand how Sony doesn't want you to use a non Sony mic, I get it. However, they should offer some mics for sale! My Sony blutooth mic seems to work with it (yeah!) as does my Sony stereo mic ,Sony ECMHST1. If you want a good cheap mic that works with the active shoe, you can find used ones for $60.

Lucky for me, I have a VMCK100 adapter from my old Sony hC3. It took a little wiggling, but it fit into the active shoe and immediately, the cam defaulted to 2channel. So, I can use one of my vive mics. I might try glueing the mic to the adapter as my L bracket doesn't clear the screen and on the other side, blocks my hand.

I emailed Sony about optional surround mics and they said that they will all default to stereo mode. I'm still waiting on a response from Sony but I am dead set positive that this camera has only two mics and "makes" 5.1, sort of like how prologic IIx takes stereo and makes surround, hence the name "Dolby Digital 5.1 Creator" on the cam. The cam has a little 5 channel graph telling output in five channels, but the only thing it tells me is that it like a mono mike. Make a loud sound from any side of the cam and all 5 little graphs blip up. Think of the cam as producing 5 channels of monophonic sound and you got it right..

It does seem to really suck down batteries. I have the aftermarket battery that came with it and a Sony. I have only charged the aftermarket one, but it seems like it takes forever to charge, so I'll travel with two chargers. If I run out of juice, I'll just rely on my 3d1 until I can get those batteries charged.


Update:

I asked in an email if this cam had 5 mic elements or just two, and it takes that signal and uses electronic processing to make "5.1". Here is the response- note how they tiptoe around the question:


"I underdstand your concern. The Camcorder has only one Built-in Zoom Microphone which records the sound in 5.1 channel.


Thank you for understanding."


I think the key word here is "records". The sound is recorded as 5 channels, but it really is picked up as 2 channel stereo.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,215 Posts
For the older TD10, you can set the audio recording to 2.0 too. And yes, you need an adapter to use a microphone from a third party supplier - but that works fine.


That is worser is the situation that you cannot adjust the audio pegel - only in two steps with the TD10 at least (and I think that will be similar for the TD20 and TD30).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
471 Posts
Discussion Starter · #20 ·
The adapter is hard to find in the U.S.. It is one of those discontinued items that you can probably find but have to pay a lot. I just did a search on ebay, amazon, etc and found only one place selling it and they are in Australia..

You can select 5.1 or 2.0 on the TD HDR 30.. All that means is, do you want your stereo to be recorded as stereo, or do you want your camera do take that stereo and "turn" it into 5.1? If you pick the latter, then you letting your camera do the work of your receiver (on a the reciever you can choose Dolby or DTS to convert 2.0 to 5.1/6.1 and so one)
 
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
Top